10 Best Bakeries in York

The Copper Crust Co. Bakery • $
966 S George St, York

Customers` Favorites

Paris Bun Savory Scone Coffee Cake & Chocolate Croissant
Pastrami Sandwich
Almond Croissant
Margherita Pizza
The German Pizza
Chicken Salad
Cheese Pizza
Pumpkin Pie
Paris Brest
Carrot Cake

“1 ate for $15.98 before the tip! Oh my GOSH! The BEST Reuben I've ever had!!!! When she laid it on the table you can literally smell the smoked meat. I commented and she winked and said we smoke and do our own meat! Best, best ever! The clam chowder was spot on! You MUST come here! Trendy place, quaint, no frills. Playing smooth jazz and oldies - environment is like a high end book store. Incredible and unique eats!!!!!! Blown away“

4.6 Superb83 Reviews
Crumbl - West Manchester Bakery •
814 Town Center Dr, York

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Dulce De Leche Pink Sugar Cookies
Ferrero Rocher
Lemon Cookies

“I placed my order through the app Tuesday and scheduled for pickup on Wednesday for 530 pm when I arrived and let them know I'm here they said the molton cookie would be another 10 minutes and she could make me the chocolate cookie with the strawberry cream cheese icing I was fine with that I said I would rather know that the cookies are fresh and not sitting and stale like my experience with Taylor Chip cookies over the weekend they said you just heat them up to be ooey-gooey I dont like my cookies stale or heatedx up to be fresh with tat being said, I was happy with the girl that waited on me was friendly, helpful she assured me that cookies were made fresh and they were making more cookies when I went back to pick them up after doing some shopping at Hobby Lobby. I couldn't resist but to try the chocolate cookie with the strawberry cheese it's very yummy and tasted freshly made I'm truly happy it's Valentine's Day so it was a nice treat. Thank you Crumbl cookies as I will ordering more cookies soon .“

4.5 Superb121 Reviews
Dayanara's Delights Bakery •
555 Ryan Run Rd suite p, York

“Recently got a geode cake done here for one of my close friends’ birthdays. It came out absolutely beautiful, the attention to detail was incredible and my friends raved about the taste and appearance! Would definitely recommend them, looking forward to using them for the next event I go to!“

5 Superb26 Reviews
Janina's Fine Desserts Bakery • $$
176 Leader Heights Rd, York

Customers` Favorites

Custom Made Cake
Croissant
Cookie

“This is a great bakery to go to when you have a sweet tooth and want a gourmet pick me up. I got the chocolate mousse cake & a Paris-Brest with hazelnut crème. They both were well made and very filling; so the price is justifiable for the quality and taste. I went in around 3:45pm on a Thursday and thought there wouldn’t be much of a selection to choose from, however there were a decent amount of desserts to decide upon. I look forward to dining in on the café side and ordering from their breakfast menu.“

4.5 Superb54 Reviews
Safe & Sweet Bakery • $
2131 S Queen St, York

Customers` Favorites

Mint Chocolate Chip Cupcakes
Peanut Butter Fudge
Buckeyes

“We’ve purchased a few items from SNS over the last year or so, & everything has been delicious! The zapple cookies, spinach pinwheels, garlic knots, cupcakes, cheesecake, & cookie sandwiches are all to die for. The texture on some items is a little different so if you go in close-minded you may be disappointed. For instance, the cupcakes are dense, not fluffy, but very moist and absolutely delicious. Same with the garlic knots. I’m pre-diabetic with PCOS so I do my best to stay away from added sugars, carbs, & sometimes dairy whenever I can as it’s supposedly inflammatory to those with the condition. I really really appreciate that I can come here and pick whatever I want since it’s all sugar free. My daughter also has abdominal migraines so we have to monitor her sugar intake. It sucks to have to say no to almost every treat but having SNS locally I’m able to swing in & pick her up something delicious. She loves the chocolate chip cookie sandwiches; they’re truly amazing so I understand why! I do wish they’d give some protein brownies a whirl. I bet they’d knock them out of the park! (& I’d be by each week ;) ) Now I just need to come by when there are cinnamon rolls. I’m dying to try one!Dietary restrictions: They offer keto, sugar free, gluten free, & dairy free options.Parking: There is a sizable parking lot with lots of spaces.Kid-friendliness: Lots of delicious sweets for children!“

4.6 Superb40 Reviews
Maple Donuts Bakery • $
204 St Charles Way # A, York

Customers` Favorites

Assorted Box of Donut Holes
Fresh Delicious Donuts
Doughnut

“The best doughnuts around. We go out of our way to get doughnuts from Maple Doughnuts specifically. They have so many flavors, and the glaze is very good. They seem to stay fresh longer than other doughnuts I’ve had, and the dough itself is second to none. My only complaint is that many times I’ve been in there the people aren’t all that friendly. They serve you, but generally hold a conversation with their coworkers or don’t speak at all while doing it. It doesn’t really bother me, but it can seem awkward.“

4.3 Superb45 Reviews
Pop's Amish Pastries Bakery • $
34 W Philadelphia St, York

“Incredible find inside the central market house in York, Pennsylvania. Serving up authentic and premise made pastries ?, massive Amish style hand dipped glazed donuts and edible cookie dough this location is a must visit at the York central market.Friendly knowledgeable staff and owner, fresh hand made goodies.Locally owned and operated.#supportlocal#buylocal“

5 Superb9 Reviews
Paper moon waffle & co. Cafe • $
34 W Philadelphia St, York

Customers` Favorites

Liège Waffle

“Stopped in Central Market for the first time recently shortly after it opened for the day. Not a lot was open, but Paper Moon was so ordered a waffle with fresh strawberries for a quick breakfast. Waffle was made to order and the strawberries were fresh and cut on demand. The waffle was cooked perfectly and just slightly sweet, which allowed the strawberries to shine. Would definitely stop again if I’m the area.“

4.7 Superb10 Reviews
Big Apple Bagels Bagels • $
1021 Haines Rd, York

Customers` Favorites

Swiss Melt Bagel Toasted w Veggie Cream Cheese
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Turkey Club Sandwich
Chicken or Tuna Melt
Southern Tradition
Muffin
Apple

“We come to BAB's a good bit. I love the deli sandwiches, and my fiancé loves the breakfast sandwiches. I always get the Turkey club with 3 mini muffins. The bagels and muffins change every day, but there's still a few consistent ones. The service is always quick, you get your food within 7 minutes. The tables are always very messy and dirty but oh well, not a huge deal. Pricing is decent/average at BABs. We've been coming here for the past 4 years, and it's always been a good experience. The ingredients always taste fresh.“

4 Good50 Reviews
All About Brownies Bakery • $$
201 Memory Ln, York

“For our wedding we wanted something different than a cake and these brownies were the perfect thing! We chose a wide assortment of flavors, and added some fresh cookies just for fun. They brought little goodie bags for guests to take extras home which was a nice touch. Huge hit!!“

4.7 Superb7 Reviews
Loading...
map Map