15 Best Ice Cream Shops near Bainbridge Island

“Great froyo!! Loved the option of reusable bowls if dining in, it take out to go back to our room. Stopped here then two afternoons we were at the Inn. Clean, tons of topping options, great flavor selection though mid winter they only had about half of the machines going. Highly recommend!“

“I can’t say enough about this young lady who was taking orders and making the orders at the same time. She ran the entire place herself and did an amazing job. She deserves a raise. Think about it, she’s doing the job that’s two people in the Pegasus coffee shop can’t do in their own. Whoever owns this place, I hope you appreciate the excellent employee you have and if you don’t believe me, walk down and wait half hour for nothing like I did at Pegasus before walking up to Cups and experiencing what a good barista you have.“

“Super friendly and helpful staff & food was great! Even the doggo was invited in when it started sprinkling outside which I appreciated it :) They have lunch size pizza pies which was perfect since there were a few different flavors I wanted to try. I actually really did like the clam chowdah one - a unique option! Food takes a little while but it's because it's actually freshly made so ordering in advance and picking up wouldn't hurt if you're short on time.“

“Who doesn't like salt and straw?The random concoctions they make up are so fun. The only downsides are the pricing.This location also has zero seating but I've found that to be pretty normal for most of their locations.Dietary restrictions: They have vegan options that are tasty as well“

“What a great, local establishment. You can’t go wrong with any of the sandwiches (the ham salad and the Irish breakfast sandwiches are my favorite). So many flavors of ice cream...all homemade. Locally made chocolates and an amazing assortment of European treats. The owners are so sweet and kind and their staff is always friendly and serves with a smile. Highly recommend (and take a half gallon of ice cream home with you)!“

“Seattle Sorbets is hands-on my fave sorbet! It's DELICIOUS and I love knowing I'm supporting a locally owned business! Every flavor, from champagne orange to raspberry merlot, is delectable. The perfect treat on hot and cold days alike.“

“we drove by tgisblittle town. the bakery is amazing. we got a dark caramel chocolate turtle with seasalt, pecan pie and mini cheesecake. all of them are so tasty!! wish we bought more stuff there!Dietary restrictions: there is gluten free.cakes“

“Awesome gelato, with fun and classic flavours (such as amaretto, pistachio, chocolate, but also açai, and peanut butter+caramel+chocolate chip). The serving size was tasty and reasonably sized. The staff was super friendly and let us try the flavours we were interested in. The space is cozy and has plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. They also sell pints to-go and baked desserts.Vegetarian options: All ice cream options are vegetarianDietary restrictions: All vegetarian menu, and vegan sorbet optionsParking: Street parking available in front of the restaurantKid-friendliness: Kid friendly space with lots of seating“

“The milkshakes here are awesome, the super shakes are amazing! These things are massive and can be a lot for one person, but worth it. Highly recommend bringing a friend or a date and sharing one. I’ve had some of their ice cream here as well, and it’s equally delicious. A nice treat while in the area or waiting on the ferry!“

“My husband is super picky and said the raspberry vanilla chai was fire and I agree! Amazing beautiful people working here, great energy, best coffee and chai we have had out here yet and I fell in love with the yummy Samoa Dude’s Donut that I ate! This is my favorite place to go and worth driving all the way from Lakebay for ❤️ “

“Yup! It’s that genuine and authentic! They have great options for breakfast and lunch. Had a sandwich and a hot tea. The hot tea selection was great and they have very friendly staff! In the very walkable downtown Bremerton area. Would recommend!“

“It's your typical dairy queen. Good eats, cool treats. This particular visit I didn't go inside. The power was out at my house and so was the internet. We had the generator running and I was streaming Netflix to the TV from my phone. I used the dairy queen wifi to download more movies to my phone so we could continue watching TV at home. So another perk, they have free wifi.“

“An absolute gem of a spot with dangerously craveable bingsu - a shaved ice dessert with sweetened condensed milk, fruits, jellies, mochi, sweet red bean, and a melt-in-your-mouth texture that's perfect for these summer beach days. Reminds me a lot of halo halo but the shaved ice texture is so much finer! Staff were friendly and welcoming. Can't wait to go back to try one of their other bingsu flavors!! This is the original, and they've got mango, strawberry, matcha, and a few more too.“

“We know what to get here. Cantaloupe sorbet and Maraschino vanilla ice cream. They are winners. They also have lots of great chocolate ice cream options. Blueberry is strong too. Other places may have more exotic flavors, but Mora's just taste better.“

“The food is fresh and always tastes great. The fish and chips are great quality and have three large pieces. Prices are fair for the location. The staff is kind and fast. I've seen them re-open for a little kid who came for a cone a few minutes after closing. There is plenty of parking and several tables inside and outside.“