“We love Pizza Extreme, but it's not close so it is a treat. I called for two stuffed deep dish pizzas with specific toppings 1/2 and 1/2. It came out to less than $10 per serving. They were perfect! Made with care and EXCELLENT! Harry was the person we talked to and who was making the pizzas. He was so nice and helpful. Pleasant experience and we've really enjoyed our dinner.Thank you!!“
“Two days ago, I had a less than ideal experience with this store. I ordered delivery. Not only did I not get the drink with my combo, but the driver left it outside my workplace for me to find, and did not come in the building. I only found out when a coworker found it outside and brought it to me.Now, the reason for my 5 star rating is this: I reached out to Jimmy John's about this experience, and the Area Manager for the Madison Jimmy John's location responded to me, apologized for the mistake, and offered me a free combo.I wasn't looking for free food (though I do appreciate it of course- who wouldn't). I'm also in customer service. I know mistakes get made and not everything has a happy ending, and I appreciate the quick response to me and the effort to make me a satisfied customer. I would whole heartedly recommend this location as well as Jimmy John's locations in Madison in general, now knowing that if a mistake does get made, they will take the time to make it right.“
“It's a subway. Everyone's had it before and it's routinely decent at least. Sometimes you don't get the ratios of toppings you want but this one has always gotten it right for me. I love a subway that has friendly people who know how to make a good sub. If you want a subway that doesn't skimp on your food, then this is the one for you“
“I grew up in IL, so I'm fully on the JJ train.I'm still sad that the cut out the sprouts years ago, but this spot is everything you'd expect: fast and on-point.My only disappointments have been that they have run out of iced tea and the jalapeño chips on a couple of occasions. And since COVID, it seems like they never anticipate that anyone will actually sit down to eat (which I'm sure is often true). There's sometimes things like napkin inventory out on the customer tables.Either way, go JJ!“
“This location is the best! Filled with kind and welcoming employees. They were all smiling and so happy to be there and thanked every customer who gave a tip. They prepared my gluten free sandwich in the back to minimize cross contamination. They all deserve a raise! Great experience, I had to write a review.“
“Oh my gosh, I was just at your restaurant and got the #12 Californian, chips and pickle. I have to tell you this is the best sandwich I have ever eaten. So well made, so fresh and well-balanced with flavor. And the pickle is so fresh, no nasty taste, it's crisp and tasty. Thank you for being so nice a d keeping your store so presentable and clean!“
“We had the French dip and gyros sandwiches, which were both quite good. A nice lunch. The restaurant interior is less funky than dumpy. We suggest a paint job, new furniture and clean up the terrazzo floor. The food is more important though. Very good!“
“Eating on campus is you know... don't get me wrong, that's any campus, institutional food is just soul-crushing on most days. So to have something like this around, a stone's throw from most buildings on the UW, fresh, consistent, flavorful, and balancing between crunchy, spicy, satisfying and wholesome, and always quick, is just bliss. The menu is very limited but there is a vegetarian option and thus might just be the best Bahn Mi-like sandwich in this our town of Madison. Perfectly complemented with a packet of simple Lays I hope this place doesn't go away any time soon and that this review doesn't make it crowded and spoil my fun. He does accept EatStreet orders so you could pre-order rush in from class or work. My favorite is the Vietnamese Meatball but you mostly can't go wrong with any of them.“
“We tried a little bit of everything and loved it all. Great bread, perfectly paired ingredients and a cool atmosphere.Vegetarian options: Great options for vegetarians. Not just one or two items but rather a section with 5 different subs and a number of sides as well.“
“The person behind the counter, whose name I didn't get unfortunately, did an amazing job making the sandwich I ordered. Many places, including JM locations just like to slap the sandwich together quickly. She took the time to make sure it was well distributed and on the sandwich, best sub I've gotten from a JM to date.“