Sandwich Shops near Middleton

“They were extremely busy with their "Day of Giving" but even still, I was able to walk in, have barely any wait and get my sub made quickly. When I got the sub it was well put together with good proportion of toppings on the Club Sub. Even tho the girl at the register seem less than interested in anything going on, it was still a great service experience and the food was good line I'd expect from Jersey Mike's.“

“Great customer service at this location in recent weeks. Clean store, and a sense of awareness that slow sandwich turnover makes a difference. In the past 3-4 weeks I've been to 3 area Subways. Two were commendable. One failed. The Stoughton Rd. store. Slow and inept. The food appeared fresh, but the young lady seemingly the senior staff of the two, couldn't grasp the Club sandwich concept. Because the company dropped the roast beef, The Club, no longer was listed on the menu. So I'm her view, it couldn't be made. All three other stores I'm mentioning made the sandwich effortlessly adding bacon. Which traditionally is and has been a default item. Since forever. Except in Subway speak. When this worker wrapped her head around this alteration, she pulled it together. This store isn't on my map moving forward. The mazomanie store gets kudos. I've been there 5-6 times just since early last week. In fact I took a chance and gave the steak and cheese a try. Ages ago I didn't like this at all. But when built with a decidedly proper array of items, adding the chipotle mayo, OMG. I Returned that evening for a foot long version. This is the same sandwich today I'm referring to which I picked up earlier (yesterday actually) that I'm following up on. The build: meat and pepper jack cheese. Toasted. Jalapeño, red onion, pepperoncini, pickles,black olives, black pepper and the chipotle Mayo. Stellar. Tomatoes were tried once, didn't work any magic. Perhaps super fresh ones could've performed well. I want to give five stars, but can't. The subway bread isn't up to snuff. Maybe before, but either it's changed or my expectations are too high. I still hold the coveted top rank for the new kid. That Jersey Mike punk being my current top sub stop.“

“I thought Superbowl Sunday would be a perfect day for the $5 footlong cookie, but they didn't have any. Thank goodness for the amazing service, and plethora of coupons that come in the mail. We didn't need the extra calories anyway. :)“

“To Mike, the manager at Jimmy Johns in Middleton Wisconsin. Thank you for your amazing service and delicious food.I recently catered two different conferences using Jimmy Johns in Middleton. The customer service Mike offered was amazing. It was clear he wanted to get my order correct and he took the time to assure that. At both events, the food arrived on time, it was accurate and delicious!!I'm very happy I decided to reach out to Jimmy John's for our catering needs.Very satisfied.Karen SBaha’i Faith conference team.“

“The person behind the counter, whose name I didn't get unfortunately, did an amazing job making the sandwich I ordered. Many places, including JM locations just like to slap the sandwich together quickly. She took the time to make sure it was well distributed and on the sandwich, best sub I've gotten from a JM to date.“

“Oh my gosh, I was just at your restaurant and got the #12 Californian, chips and pickle. I have to tell you this is the best sandwich I have ever eaten. So well made, so fresh and well-balanced with flavor. And the pickle is so fresh, no nasty taste, it's crisp and tasty. Thank you for being so nice a d keeping your store so presentable and clean!“

“Friendly! Delicious! Preordering online seems to be the preferred method, but as spontaneous first timers, in-person worked fine. We hung around with the many students who obviously make this a routine stop on their way to class. Loved our Bahn Mi sandwiches ($8.50) and Vietnamese Ice Coffee ($5). We will be making this food truck part of our routine.“

“Being a big fan of Jimmy John’s has made me not venture to trying new sandwiches places, but this sandwich shop will not disappoint! The service was super fast and the sandwich was amazing! I tried the focaccia bread and I hope it sticks around! It’s amazing! I may have found my new go-to sandwich place!“

“Shannon usually works at a different location, but I am so glad she was helping out here today! She was the kindest, most personable “fast food” associate I’ve ever come across. She greeted everyone with a big smile and was so positive. My boyfriend and I decided to eat in the restaurant and I’m glad we did because we were able to hear her say to someone “I like to make people smile because you just never know what someone is going to through”. She’s just so sweet and made our day!“

“This is a great location! The staff are polite, friendly, and great to chat with! I work nearby, and so am I frequent customer, and have never had an instance where I didn’t fully enjoy the experience from start to finish. 10/10, 11/10 if I could “