New American Restaurants near Plymouth, WI

City Club Tavern & Grill Bar • $
228 E Mill St, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Cod Dinner with Fries and Slaw
Shrimp and Perch Dinner
Chicken Tenders Dinner
Double Cheese Burger
Cheese Curds
Fried Chicken
Hamburger
Fish

“Food, drinks, and atmosphere are always great here!“

4.4 Superb36 Reviews
Paddock Club American • $$
61 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake - 6.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Panacotta with Fresh Berries
Mushroom Risotto Fritters
Eggplant Caprese Salad
Rock Shrimp Linguine
Grilled Hanger Steak
Roasted Duck Breast
Spaghetti Carbonara
Spaghetti Bolognese
Grilled Broccoli
Potato Gnocchi

“We few friends of mine and I drove from out of town to try this place based off a recommendation. We were blown away!!! The service was incredible. All the food was delicious. The hanger steak was the most tender steak I've ever tasted. More than worth the drive.“

4.8 Superb68 Reviews
Brown Baer Bar • $
181 E Rhine St, Elkhart Lake - 6.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Baer Burger and Kettle Chips
Giant Pretzel

“We stopped in for a Friday night dinner with our two children. There was some seating available since it was the off-season for tourism. The giant pretzel, served with beer cheese and brown mustard for dipping, was crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Delicious! Buffalo cauliflower was roasted to perfection with just enough spice. My daughter and I had the build-your-own chicken sandwich which was just great, too. I especially liked it’s toasted ciabatta bun. My husband enjoyed his southwest chicken sandwich, and my son loved his cheeseburger. I would add that the staff were super friendly, and the blueberry cider was awesome, too. We love the variety of food options here. A wonderful dinner all around!“

4.5 Superb40 Reviews

Plymouth’s Other Flavors