48 Best American Restaurants in Key West

“Andrea T., our server, was amazing. Very attentive and provided great suggestions for food, which was also delicious. Can’t beat the views, especially the sunset. All around fantastic culinary experience. A special evening celebrating our bro-in-law’s 55th birthday.“

“The place is just wonderful. I haven't eaten at all the restaurants in Key West, but this one has to be one of the best if not the best. For example it was vastly better than Louie's Backyard. Just make sure to get reservations first!“

“Cool place w excellent food! We had the Beef Stroganoff & it was delicious. Our friend had the Yellow Tail & he said it was amazing. Don"t skip dessert!Waiter was attentive & had a nice visit w the owner. Put this down as a must try on your trip to Key West!“

“The food is awesome. We had octopus and calamari as a starter which was already filling. As a main course, filet mignon and fettucine. Both super tasty and great quality. Last but not least, the key lime tart. But there was absolutely nothing to complain about. We decided to make a reservation at very short notice and only got a seat at the counter, but it was super comfortable. Sylvia our bar tender was super super friendly and served excellently. A more than successful evening with an excellent meal. Danger! Very modern and not Key West style. If you're looking for something like that, you shouldn't go here, but if you're looking for great quality, this is the place for you.“

“I made a reservation here for a bachelorette dinner and it was a great choice. This restaurant is big with different areas. There is patio with live music, a karaoke room, a game area and a quieter seating room. The staff took care of our table well. The food was great with good portions. I had the coconut shrimp and the grilled mahi mahi tacos. All of it tasted fresh and flavorful. For dessert had some key lime pie and the hula girl pie with an oreo cookie crust and ice cream on top. We sat on the patio and that was a nice atmosphere with live music.“

“It would be nice if they would cook their food separately from their seafood for people with seafood/fish allergies. I was very restricted to the sides that I could eat last night because they fry everything together. You would think for this type of five star restaurant they could at least fry their food separately“

“Incredible dining experience! Service was on point, thanks to our server, Wilson. We ordered 3 appetizers, 2 entrees and 3 desserts. Everything was paced out perfectly. The food was phenomenal! Crab “cakes”, scallops (with possibly the best pork belly I’ve had), and bisque to start. Miso glazed grouper and veal chop for entree’s and a mix of desserts. Everything was remarkable. My compliments to Chef Laurence.“

“My top pick for key lime pie, as the massive meringue makes it the best place in Key West; however the rest of the food, while good, is subpar. Supposedly, one should go for breakfast but I found their lunch menu to be lacking in options.I had the Mahi Mahi sandwich and some of the fried potatoes were burnt, but otherwise, it had good flavor. Other than lettuce, pickles, and their house sauce, the sandwich didn't have any other toppings.The space itself is quite spacious with a lovely outdoor space with plenty of fans. The house is also quite historic with a former cockfighting arena.It is first come first serve, but it's usually not too crowded. If it is, they have a nice waiting area across the street.“

“The flavor of the Key West Lobster Roll was explosive and absolutely delicious. Perfectly toasted bun, the right amount of butter, plenty of Lobster. Amazing. $29 too steep in my opinion for the small size. Should be much bigger but all the same. Amazing, definitely going back.“

“Patrick and his staff are amazing! They are churning out the most incredible barbecue items anywhere with a friendly attitude. The pulled pork, the chicken, etc are all fantastic and don’t miss the brisket on Saturdays! The sides that are available are beyond creative and flavorful. Eaton Good is a must visit when in Key West. Great staff! Great food! Great vibes!! Just awesome!!!“

“I am a sucker for a good croissant sandwich and this place did not disappoint. The croissant was sizeable and soft, the eggs were made fantastic, the bacon wasn't too hard or too soft. Just all around perfection. The key lime pie French toast blew my friends socks off, picture included which could be confused as art haha. Mimosas were yummy and the staff was friendly and attentive!“

“This was our favorite spot we ate at while visiting Key West. I had the blackened fish tacos, which were the best I've ever had. The food here had great flavor, the service was excellent, and the outdoor seating on Duval Street was fun to take in. I would definitely recommend eating here while visiting Duval Street.“

“Not sure how I haven't wrote a review here yet! A must stop while in Key West. I highly recommend the Korean BBQ beef tacos or the Yum Yum shrimp tacos. Pictured is the lobster roll and the key lime pineapple drink. The lobster roll was good (still prefer the Korean BBQ or Yum Yum shrimp) and the drink was super tasty! Seemed more like a yummy treat than an actual cocktail, but in the best way possible.“

“My fiancé and I came to Azur with a friend who recommended it while visiting the keys.The first recommendation is their special eggplant chips. They were very good, baked and drizzled with honey & sea salt.The entrees were yummy too and generously portioned. We look forward visiting again when we come back!“

“Fun, weird quirky place. Star Wars X-wing fighters hanging from the ceiling. X-men comic book and a Wolverine action figure hanging on the wall. Yet this place still pulls off a romantic vibe.Not easy to find the place I think that might be intentional. It’s almost like they dare you to eat there, if you can find it.Key west is loaded with great restaurants. This was our favorite of them all.A party of two, I couldn’t decide between the snapper and the tasting trio. They were nice enough to swap out the grouper with the snapper. My date had the tasting trio with the grouper and we shared the appetizer tasting trio. Everything was delicious. Don’t miss out on the lobster Mac and cheese it is the way of the Jedi.“

“Went with friends for an afternoon bite before their flight and it was perfect. Had the grouper shrimp cakes as an appetizer for the 4 of us then individual hamburgers for lunch. Had a wonderful young lady make us a ‘Painkiller’ and a Golden Margarita that was delicious. Domestic beer only $5, a true find on KW. Between the view, the vibe and the prices you can’t go wrong.“

“Every things was amazing! The guy when I got there show me the restroom because I was looking, the waiter was really friend and nice, he try speak a little Portuguese and I loved it, the food was fresh, taste and the atmosphere was incredible…I really recommend“

“This is a beautiful place to chill and enjoy the sunset! The margaritas were delicious. Likewise the food! We had the mahi sandwich which was really delicious. The service was exceptionally quick and the prices were surprisingly quite reasonable. The live music was also very good ?“

“I have been here twice and each time the service has been the same, exceptional! The atmosphere is always fun, I mean it is Key West afterall. The food is always amazing and staff are always attentive. The restaurant always stays very busy so it is not quiet and there is a lot of movement. However, with them being busy the wait for a table is never usually very long. No matter, just get a drink and enjoy the atmosphere. I will definitely be returning on my next trip to the keys. Thanks for the great service from all the staff.“

“I was looking for a nice restaurant at a pretty good price in Key West and this place was perfect. Got some happy hour drinks and the Mahi mahi bites which were cooked perfectly. I’ve worked at the top seafood restaurant in my home state for 8 years and the Tuna Nachos and Tuna dinner platter were right on par with my home restaurant!! Great place and a great value! Would have preferred Caribbean music rather than country but that just a personal preference ?“

“This place is very very good. The fish and chips is a huge portion and the fish is mahi mahi, not some cheap cod or haddock. The portion size was large. The pretzel stick appetizers were great as was the cheese dipping sauce. I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention this is actually a sports bar, so there are tv’s everywhere and it is sports themed. We were seated quickly and the service was fantastic. Great spot.“

“Stopped in after 8 on a Thursday hoping to get a drink and bite at the bar. It was packed with a fun combination of locals and visitors and the host went out of his way to ensure we had drinks and watched over us until two seats opened up. Then we met Eric, who continued to provide the best service in town and did his best to make sure everyone at the bar knew each other. We shared a flavorful mushroom quesadilla and Caesar salad with mahi. The mahi mahi was so beautifully prepared it flaked apart with a fork, and the dressing was much lighter than the creamy version too many restaurants serve these days. Even with the wait at the beginning (get those reservations in!), it was a leisurely hour and a half of good food and wonderful company.“

“The best chicken strips you will ever put in your mouth. Everything here is delicious. The bacon mac n cheese is so GOOD!Parking: There are 2 paid parking lots directly across the street.Wheelchair accessibility: The order window is on the sidewalk, so you can roll right up.“

“Evening was ideal for sitting outside. The sunset this time of year is not directly in view but the sky was beautiful. The charter boats come in shortly after sunset and are enjoyable to watch. The service was attentive and the food was good. Everyone was pleased with the menu. I would dine again upon return.“

“First off let me say that I love good bar and grills. I found this place with Google maps search and saw that is had great reviews. I made my way there and it is on the dock right in front of the boats. It was nice to sit in the open room and see the water. The service was great, and the food and drinks were very good as well. Definitely would stop here if like me you like good bar and grill.“

“The food was really good here. I definitely recommend the chicken nachos. We pretty much got pull and peel shrimp everywhere once we realized on good they were. We brought some fish we had caught that morning and had them do the taco setup with it which came with 6 sides and we had our yellowtail and bonito fried and blackened. A nice outdoor space on the water with plenty of shade and they have a store upstairs if you’re low on sunscreen.“

“Hands down one of the BEST places in Old Key West!! Friendly people working here, very dog friendly, food is amazing! I loved the selections on the menu so much that I could have eaten half the menu. I opted for the Cuban Rueben and it was the best!! We will be going back to try all the other awesome stuff on the menu!“

“We chose Fisherman's Cafe based on previous reviews which mentioned having some Gluten Free (GF) options. Admittedly, I misjudged the weathered, physical appearance as I approached, but one bite of the food immediately had me mentally adding this to my list of Key West favorites! We timed our visit perfectly just after the peak lunch time and had the entire place to ourselves with only a few minutes to wait until our food came to our table hot and fresh. Once we began eating, we quickly adapted to the no frills, picnic style dining arrangement. The owner was low key (no pun intended) and soft spoken, but when I mentioned my wife's gluten allergy, he said "that sounds like celiac disease right? My best friend's wife suffers from the same thing." He then went on to list the menu items he could offer without worry, as well as what we should avoid. If you or someone in your dining party has celiac, you know what a relief it is when the person at the grill gets it! We are so thankful to whomever previously mentioned Fisherman's Cafe having GF options. I surprised myself by ordering the pulled pork sandwich rather than the Mahi Mahi tacos, but I was not disappointed with my choice. It came out in a few minutes piping hot and so delicious. The fries were similar to boardwalk type fries served hot and not too hard. My wife had the Island Bowl which she thoroughly enjoyed. Although the selections are limited, you are guaranteed a great meal fresh off the grill at the Fisherman's Cafe. We will be back one day!“

“This place is small with a little inside seating and more outside seating. The food is delicious! The orange juice is fresh squeezed and delicious! I had the steak egg and cheese wrap with hasbrown inside it was so good. I like to eat and I got through half and was stuffed out of my mind! Fresh avocado steak cheese eggs hashbrowns all wrapped and grilled! Don't miss this place for the best breakfast!“

“Music was super nice, area was good- service was awful- bar backs were rude, slow and I was going to leave an additional cash tip even tho the bar tender gave me the wrong drink the second time I asked for a different drink and another bar tender got rude with me for leaving a tip on my card that was lower due to me going to give additional cash instead- instead I “fixed my tip” on the card and gave less than the cash amount I planned on- never had such an awful experience- ruined my trip to the keys - won’t be back. They were the rudest bar tenders I’ve ever had.“

“Excellent sandwiches, made to order, and they will let you customize them (I like extra meat). The ice cream is top notch, you don't expect good ice cream at a "fast food" place like this, but they have it. Family owned, they recognize their regular customers and you are always greeted with a smile when you walk in, whether or not you are a regular. I highly recommend.“

“Omg omg omg don't sleep on this spot, seafood was SO fresh, staff very friendly and helpful, mixed drinks were fantastic. We were too excited for the desserts to remember a picture but the chocolate thunder cake and the key lime pie (of course) were amazingTotally recommend“

“We had a wonderful experience at Sarabeth’s while visiting Key West. Service was hospitable and fast. We went for weekday brunch - there was no wait and the food was delectable with great portions at very reasonable prices. There are so many awesome restaurants in Key West but you must put Sarabeth's on your list!“

“Amazing Amazing, Amazing ! There was not one thing about our dinner that wasn't absolutely perfect and delicious. Our server was attentive and so knowledgeable about everything on the menu. Our appetizer, our salads, the conch chowder just so delicious. The yellow snapper with mango and cucumber salsa, was so fresh and light, I never clean my plate and I didn't leave a crumb for my husband! We are usually in Key West once or twice a year and we will be back the atmosphere is fantastic too!“

“The BEST food truck ever! The best staff, the most delicious food, everything about them is amazing. They are all so sweet and even make me a meal off the menu, its just so amazing. I go at least twice a week for lunch. I can't recommend their spot to anyone else more!!“

“Great hidden gem in key west. Perfect atmosphere with a great sunset view and a little tucked away from the typically key west commotion. Service was excellent and food was great too. This is the perfect spot if you are looking for a quiet place to watch some boats go by and feel like you have a little slice of paradise all to yourself.“

“While staying at the Hyatt Centric, my wife and I took full advantage of the bar, spa, and pool. There was a server walking the pool area taking orders, and she was very timely and on top of our orders.We loved our experience. I also loved the roosters, personally.On our first night from the Hyatt, we ordered room service from here, and the order was quick, accurate, and tasty. Also, they didn't skimp on the to-go wine! Awesome service.It was so good that we ate there again 2 days later and took in the views.“

“A bar and restaurant known only to locals!The portions were really generous and served in large bowls, the owner was very sweet, the food was delicious, the prices were reasonable, and it was the most profitable restaurant I've ever eaten in the US.It may be difficult to find, but you can just follow Google Maps, so go in and try it without doubting whether it's right ❤️“

“Is a cool place to watch the sunset with your friends while having a drink and chill. I didn’t try any coctails, but the draft IPA is ????.The service is friendly, you have to order yourself at the bar, and be patient:)The majority around, was elderly people, drinking, chilling on the beach chairs….No one was screaming or clowning around (something you see a lot in KW), very civilized. Oh! And they have live music on a normal volume:))) I had a good time!“

“We have enjoyed breakfast here at the Yellowfin twice. Andrei and Jean were more than attentive and professional making sure that our visit was five stars. While we are still getting used to slowing down from our fast-paced experiences back at home, Andrei was there when we needed him....checking in at the right times and not when we had bites in our mouths. That speaks to someone who understands service. Tremendous time at the resort, and will be back again soon.“

“Michelle is the most happy friendly bar tender ever! It’s our first stop everyday while on vacation! You have to visit and enjoy this dollar bill filled bar!! It’s a must! The food is so good! We have been coming to Willy ts for years! Bring a marked up dollar bill for a one of a kind memory left behind!“

“We went for lunch. Great open air dining experienceOur server was pleasant and efficient and staff were very accommodating.Everything we ordered, conch fritters, dolphin fingers and Mahi mahi sandwich ( Even the lettuce and tomato on the wonderful roll) were fresh and very tasty.Would definitely recommend for casual fun day“

“White table cloths and a menu that matches. Had lunch with my wife and we shared two dishes - Salade Salmon Nicoise - the perfect amount of dressing, fresh vegetables, and salmon was cooked perfect.Flat bread was great - rustic, authentic.Key Lime Pie for dessert- gooey graham cracker crust, punching key lime flavor.“

“Was very disappointed. I was there 2 years ago and had the most delicious shrimp and grits I think I have had. I was told tonight the no longer had it.Crabby tots and jerk steak flat bread were amazing but they were not shrimp and grits. Hope they bring it back before next time we come down.“

“We've gone to 915 2 years in a row on our vacation and will continue you go there for as long as we visit and they exist. The food is always excellent and creative from apps to desert. Whole fried snapper- loved it Butternut squash ravioli- so tasty Ceviche- fresh and citrusy Dessert was some almond creamy semifrozen thing with rum poured over it, damn that's good! The bar menu is as good as the food. This place isn't cheap but it's reasonably for what you get. Highly recommend.“

“When we arrived, the host was having a hard time finding our reservation. He seated us outside but when we requested to be moved to a table near the water, he said let me check (never actually did) and said those tables are reserved. Once we were seated and other customers came in, he asked inside or outside and when they said outside and requested a table by the water, they were given a table that they requested. We were very upset about it, and just wanted to enjoy a nice dinner. Our waiter was very nice and the food was good. It's just too bad our night got off to a bad start! The sunset was beautiful but the ambience at the restaurant was just so so.“

“You never know what to expect from an on property restaurant, so it is with pleasure I can recommend Jimi's. Today's fresh catch was grouper. The grouper taco was excellent. A great cocktail list and great service from Suzy and Jamie. Tables overlooking the dock and Gulf of Mexico waters make for a nice setting. Be sure to have a meal there when staying at the Hyatt Beach House!“

“We had just gotten into Key West after a seven hour ride. We were hungry and it was late. Stopped by here and found amazing food.The Chef is on point! We had Ahi Tuna it was amazing with a glass of CAB:-) and it was a great portion, unlike some high-end restaurants that serve you micro amounts.“