What are you looking for?

Pizza Restaurants in New Albany

4.6 - 138 votes

Hours: 3 - 10PM

5170 Charlestown Rd, New Albany
(812) 949-3000

Tony Impellizzeri's

This is our new favorite pizza place! Kind of a small family run place but they have the best pizza outside of Chicago! Lived in Chicago for 30 years- tr... More reviews

4.4 - 164 votes

Hours: 11AM - 10PM

3312 Plaza Dr, New Albany
(812) 944-2577

The New Albanian Brewing Company Pizzeria & Public House

Second time here and I brought my husband because the first visit was great. We ordered a basic cheese medium pizza and it took almost an hour to get it.... More reviews

4.7 - 99 votes

Hours: 11AM - 12AM

411 E Spring St, New Albany
(502) 645-6974

8th Street Pizza

Read online that the calzone was one of the best in Louisville area and I was not disappointed It was delivered on time and still hot . I like the fact y... More reviews

4.8 - 74 votes

Hours: 12 - 9PM

1001 Vincennes St Suite 100, New Albany
(812) 725-0021

Legacy Pizza & Bakery

Well... the pizza was awesome and the loaf of sourdough bread we brought home was huge. What's not to love. Yummmmmmmmmm! More reviews

4.5 - 91 votes

Hours: 11AM - 10PM

412 W Daisy Ln, New Albany
(812) 913-4081

Rapid Fired Pizza

I treated my grandson to lunch. He and I both loved it. First time I had eaten there. He had the buffalo ck in personal pan crust. I had pepperoni ... More reviews

4.2 - 124 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

379 Professional Ct, New Albany
(812) 725-8891

topp't Handcrafted Pizzas + Chopped Salads

The workers don’t communicate good or speak clearly. My toppings were thrown on my pizza. I got the classic lemonade, it tasted weird so I got sweet tea,... More reviews

4.5 - 86 votes

Hours: 11:30AM - 9PM

2601 Charlestown Rd, New Albany
(812) 725-8407

Chicago City Pizza

We had a really great first experience with Chicago City Pizza. The service was fantastic, the pizza excellent, and the salad with ranch well worth the $... More reviews

4 - 147 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

1208 State St, New Albany
(812) 945-1149

Arni's New Albany

Arnis on State st in New Albany Indiana needs a new evening manager or needs to send the evening manager to a school where she can learn how to interact ... More reviews

4 - 144 votes

Hours: 11AM - 10PM

3825 Charlestown Rd, New Albany
(812) 945-4405

Pizza King

What a joke this pizza is! Like school pizza is better than this. Cheap cheap cheap ingredients. And it shows More reviews

4.1 - 122 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

2708 Paoli Pike, New Albany
(812) 945-7711

Mimo's Pizzeria

The only reason I gave 2 stars is because the food is very good. I ordered my food to go, when I picked up my order the service was horrible, he comes of... More reviews

4.2 - 98 votes

Hours: 11AM - 11PM

2868 Charlestown Rd, New Albany
(812) 542-6500

Little Caesars Pizza

I'm not sure what they have changed in the past month or 2 but its definitely not as good as it used to be and sometimes when there busy I guess the... More reviews

4.5 - 52 votes

Hours: 11AM - 11PM

225 State St, New Albany
(812) 920-6400

Parlour New Albany

Garlic bread sticks are killer with the 3 dipping. Also ordered big 4 meats pizza. Delicious ? Awesome. Best pizza I've eaten in a long time.. An... More reviews

3.7 - 120 votes

Hours: 11AM - 12AM

2011 Charlestown Rd, New Albany
(812) 941-1144

Marco's Pizza

Honestly one of the best tasting pizzas places around here. However I've ordered two deliveries that were just mia for 2 hours and then wound up get... More reviews

4 - 49 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

2221 State St Suite C, New Albany
(812) 945-7272

Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza

The shared parking lot with Chick Fillet was a disaster and the service time was slow. The pizza was less than mediocre. Ive had better from Kroger and W... More reviews

View on map