10 Best American Restaurants near New Carlisle

“I was here with family and it is the best place around! Better than Chicago pizza and the best drinks! Lauren was awesome ! This place is a family owned business and everything is made from scratch , down to the craft beers! Yall made us feel right at home and we were from Nashville, Tn and “

“I love this place. I placed an order for 4 extra large pizzas for the Career Academy Robotics club. I knew it was a tall order for a small kitchen but I just love their pizza so much Especially the Sharon their buffalo chicken pizza which I highly recommend. There was a little hiccup but the owner was extremely kind and compensating and we got our pizzas to the event on time and the kids gobbled them up. I told everyone there you have to try the perch and the Walleye .It's a down home regular friendly place that I love to visit. Fantastic food great value and friendly service“

“The food is absolutely delicious. We stumbled in one day looking for a good place to eat not far from home and also a place that was locally owned, not a chain. We were pleased to find that the owner is a chef who bought the pub so he could spend more time with family. He is there and does prep and cooking of many made in the kitchen items such as homemade ketchup,pickles,soups and one of the best pork tenderloin sandwiches I've ever had , bluegill fish. Well the list goes on. It kinda has that cheers ambiance. Staff is great and don't be surprised if you see the chef who is delightful. This is definitely a favorite. You should try it . It will be one of your favorites too.“

“Service was amazing. We were throwing several drinks at the server and she was picking the one she thought we'd like. All the cocktails were super interesting.Food was incredible. Burger had the perfect amount of sweet and savory. French fries were perfect. Detroit style pizza was well done.All of the house liquors were great.“

“This was my first time here. This is a quaint hometown breakfast and lunch restaurant in New Carlisle, Indiana. Our booth had comfortable seats and it was situated right over one of the heat ducts which made itnice and warm the entire time we were there!. Our server was polite and checked on us often enough to keep our drinks filled. I had the BLT club sandwich which was a triple decker! It was grilled with butter on the outside slices of bread and the tomatoes were nice and ripe and it had ample bacon slices. It was actually the best BTL I’ve ever had! My husband had the BBQ pork sandwich and said it was very delicious. I highly recommend Jennie Rae’s for hometown good cooking!“

“I couldn't believe how crowded it was. But the service was good and the food tremendous!Wheelchair accessibility: Don't see how you could get a wheelchair in here. It's too tight when people are seated. Might suggest a take out and have someone deliver. Food is that good.“

“Passing through to go back home to mn and very quick, and easy. We have a camper so it is a descent size gravel off the road spot for the parking lot,it wasn't crazy busy so enough room to park. We have 2 dogs, so a little spot of grass for them to go potty. Food was good, I did ask for no tomato and still got tomato but nothing I couldn't work around. They have a descent beer selection as well, considering being a small town“

“Went on Saturday to give the Prime Rib a try… we were not disappointed. The waitress was GREAT, considering she waited on the entire room by herself! We all worked thru it and had a good time while waiting… I even tried the Blueberry Manhattan!“

“One of our local favorites, I don't know why we keep trying other places. Cameron's has never disappointed. Love to sit on the back patio. Food is very good and you can tell that they really care about service.Kid-friendliness: We have had multiple trips with large group and several kids and they are very accommodating to what ever we needed.“

“There a lot of word on the street about froelich's on both sides of the argument. Bottom line is the food for me has been consistently decent. Never once has it been bad and frankly my only complaint has been when the entire establishment is overwhelmed with patrons. I've had some very good meals here with friends, great cookies, and fun nick knacks around the huge store. The building was once a pharmacy and its large with tall ceilings giving it a good open feel that can make it loud but keeps it from feeling claustrophobic when it gets so crowded.“