6 Best Mexican Restaurants near Sheridan

Check out these Sheridan Mexican dining hotspots.

Los Cotorros Mexican restaurant Mexican • $
3901 IN-47, Sheridan

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Steak and Shrimp
24 Oz Margarita Special
Shrimp Quesadilla
Grilled Chicken
Chips and Salsa
Burritos Deluxe
Burrito Bomba
Wet Burrito
Taco Salad
Choriqueso

“Sunday, 4 pm dinner. Everything was delicious! It’s rare that I say that! Their salsa had just the right amount of spice. The Pollo Poblano was a delicious marinated and grilled chicken breast, covered in cheese, onions, and sliced poblano peppers! I had to force myself to stop eating!“

3.7 Good53 Reviews
Verde Zionsville Mexican • $$
3091 US-421, Zionsville - 9.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brochetas De Camaron
Pastel de 3 Leches
Chimichanga Dinner
Chicken Fajitas
Frozen Margarita
Margarita Flight
Street Tacos
Steak Fajitas
Chicken Mole
Carne Asada

“Meh. It was okay. The spicy jalapeno margarita was really tasty, but a little pricey for the size and quality of the restaurant. The steak in the fajitas was burned on the outside, and super raw (rare at best) on the inside of the big chunks. I wasn't too impressed by that dish. The other guests had fish, quesadilla, and tacos and said they were pretty good. Overall, it was okay, just a little more expensive than it needs to be. I'll stick to my chain-restaurant Mexican locals.“

4.2 Good162 Reviews
Taqueria Mexicana Tacos • $
3132 IN-32, Westfield - 8.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

1 Taco Carne Asada & Chorizo 1 Tacos Al Pastor
Campechano Steak Chorizo Nachos
Chips Salsa and Gaucamole
Steak Quesadilla Plate
Chips and Salsa
Al Pastor Tacos
Tortillas

“Papusas and tacos were amazing. We tried the mixed papusas-all were delicious and the curtido was nice. Chicken, steak and poel tacos were fantastic. Staff was very attentive, friendly and prices were very reasonable. They also serve beer and wine.“

4.3 Superb65 Reviews
Los Agaves Caterers • $
17471 Wheeler Rd, Westfield - 7.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Margarita Flights
Mole Enchiladas
Del Mar Burrito
Chips and Salsa
Tequila Flight
Burrito Bowl
Carne Asada
Queso Dip
Taco Salad
Carnitas

“This place is really good but it gets kind of expensive to me. The quesos are really good. They have an incredible salsa. Their hot sauce is very good too flavorful & very spicy. I find that the ground beef usually has a strange taste. Horchata is usually good. But I don’t care for the street corn it’s too watery and not enough flavor. The employees are always super nice!!“

3.9 Good106 Reviews
The Toros Mexican • $
14639 North Gray Rd, Carmel - 11.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

House Frozen Margarita
Nachos Super Toro
Chicken Rice Soup
Rice and Beans
Texas Fajitas
Steak Fajitas
Fajita Nachos
La Ensalada
Burrito Loco
Quesadilla

“Service was fantastic. It was quick and the server was friendly and as attentive as we wanted. The food also arrived very promptly and was pipping HOT! The outside and inside of the restaurant was very clean, which impressed me. It was spacious enough you definitely didn't feel like you were sitting on the other tables laps. The Arroz con Pollo was a huge portion and tasted great. The fajitas were really good too. The chicken tasted great and love when it comes out with some "sizzle!" The chips and salsa were okay. The chips tasted a little hard, not sure if stale or not. Also, I ordered a Ultimate Marg and honestly, it want the best. That's the reason for the , & not the 5. For a $13.00 Marg, I'd expect better. Just didn't taste good and not too much flavor.“

4 Good53 Reviews
Cabos Mexican Restaurant Mexican • $
202 W 161st St, Westfield - 8.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken and Steak Fajitas
Chicken Fajitas
Grilled Chicken
Chips & Salsa
Fajita Shrimp
Steak Tacos
Chimichanga
Carne Asada
Molcajete
Quesadilla

“Had lunch here today, another good place to stop in and get lunch. There is plenty of seating, and the service is excellent. The waitress went above and beyond for us. The food was fantastic. There is plenty of parking spaces. I tried a different arroz con Pollo, and it was very delicious!“

3.9 Good36 Reviews