33 Best Pizza Restaurants near East Amwell

“Lovely spot under a house. They’ve been making pizzas there for 48 years! The founders son made our pizza and was funny and sweet to us. The pizza was delicious- thin crust, sweet sauce, seasoned right, creamy mozzarella, and basil from their garden.“

“Just had the best meal and wine! First time at this restaurant since we only moved to the area a year ago but we will be back - many times! Pappardelle Al Cinghiale was incredible as well as the Cavoletti Bruxelles! Lastly, the Nutella Mousse ❤️ - so delicious!Giovanni is an absolute GEM!Give this place a go and support local!“

“My first time here. We got a bacon chicken ranch pizza, wings, and mozzarella sticks to go. They were all great! The pizza has a great crust and a ton of flavor. the mozzarella sticks were crispy and melted inside. The wings have a great crunch to them and mild sauce hit the spot - Came with chunky blue cheese which was a surprise. I also got a slice of pepperoni and a slice of meatball. Great sauce, cheese and crust! My new spot! I can't wait to try a meatball pizza.“

“We had an amazing meal at AMA tonight. Sat at the bar and was able to chat with the owner. He told us about growing up in Italy and how he worked to renovate the restaurant himself.Everything we had was delicious. Arancini, Parma pizza, Cacio e Pepe, and homemade lemon gelato.The outside seating is gorgeous in the warm weather. Highly recommended!“

“10/10 service guy at the counter who goes by Brian/Boj very personable and all around people person, always brightens my day to get my order taken by him, Pizza is amazing, sauce is prestine and cheese is just right, anyone I talk to is nice, and those delivery guys are quick, nice and easy on eyes. There cheesteaks are just as good and salads are huge! Overall my favorite restaurant in Flemington, and Portnoy would rate this place high 8 and 9’s I’m sure. True 100% Italians! How ya doinnnnn“

“Was absolutely delicious and the menu was incredible, we chose a few pizzas. Highly addictive and recommend. Loved it so much and the service was amazing, really appreciated talking with the owner and staff. Was also thrilled that they had Gluten Free options. Sat inside with the sun shining through the windows, Ambiance was relaxing and peaceful. @mikenkatonthetown Instagram @cancer_myjourneywithmikeyv it's so pleasurable“

“I visited Marinelli's for dinner with a friend this weekend and it was OH-SO-GOOD! I had the delectable Chicken Kristine and my friend ordered the Eggplant Tower and we shared. What an absolutely delicious dinner! The lemon blueberry cake we shared for dessert also did not disappoint. The next time I'm in the Flemington area I will definitely make a stop at Marinelli's. : )“

“I'm thrilled to share our wonderful experience at Campania Pizza & Deli! Their calamari, veal, and pizza are clearly top-notch. It's always great to find a place that consistently delivers excellent Italian cuisine. Thanks for your hard work!!!“

“Piccolo Trattoria offers superb Italian cuisine paired with excellent service. My second visit reaffirmed my positive impression, especially the delectable sauce accompanying the bread basket. We savored dishes like eggplant parmigiana, Milanese, and a delightful cappuccino. The red sauce with the eggplant parmigiana was particularly divine, striking the perfect balance of acidity and sweetness. You can't go wrong here—I highly recommend paying them a visit!“

“Cuz, I was in town visiting relatives over the holidays and stopped in next door to pick up a birthday cake. I walked back to the car behind the building and the aroma of bread baking was too much for me to take in, so I had to come in to your shop. I had the meatball sandwich on a home made bun that was so delicious and the meatballs were so big and juicy smothered in cheese. So good! I had to buy a loaf of that marvelous bread for home. Next time through, I want try the lasagna with meatballs with six layers. Great little Italian restaurant that is a must try in New Hope!“

“Amazing food, amazing people. We came here and had such an amazing time with the owners (Gerson and Ana) who made us feel so loved, welcome, and right at home. I had the Lobster Ravioli special and it was delicious. Bread was warm, we were attended to frequently and honestly I felt like royalty. I never leave reviews, but this business and family deserve every bit of business.“

“This past Saturday, I met up with cousins I have not seen in over 40 years. While being in their company and meeting their husbands was very enjoyable.......the meal at this unassuming restaurant was absolutely spectacular! I had the Pollo Caterina, one of my favorite dishes. Every part of the dish was done to perfection and the Marsala sauce was a perfect compliment. Well done! It's just a shame I'm 700 miles away.“

“We regularly get food and have done catering a few times now, everything is always fantastic. Joe, his family and team are great. You really get what you pay for and quality is number one here. Good food makes a good party and they nailed it. Thanks!“

“This place is absolutely amazing! We booked them to host our engagement party and everything was super easy and seamless. The owner assisted us in setting up, they made the food and pizzas fresh for us. The ambiance is amazing and the food is DELICIOUS! We are very picky about our pizza but they fully exceeded our expectations. We had such an amazing time and will continue to go to this place. Thank you all for hosting our event we loved it all!PS. the variety and specials they offer is unmatched!“

“I had ordered a tray of rigatoni Bolognese and a tray of subs for Christmas Eve. Everything was outstanding.I can't say enough how good the food is here.Yes..the pizza is good but expand your horizons and try their dinners and subs!!!Great staff too!!!No wonder this place is always busy!!!“

“Am amazing pizza place and so much more! Great daily specials! We like the Italian hoagie and their cheese steak. But they have many many other menu items! Great dinners, great salads, amazing appetizers too! Everyone will find something to eat here, even the kids. Pizza is darn good too!Vegetarian options: They will make anything you like!Kid-friendliness: Lots of menu items for the kids!Parking: It get busy at times, but there is always a place to park!Wheelchair accessibility: Easy in easy out!Dietary restrictions: They will make it any way you please!“

“Very good New Jersey style pizza with excellent customer service and with a charming atmosphere. Competitive prices. The building must be 200 years old or older and reminds you over being in an old roadside tavern. Wood burning fire place in the dining area. Highly recommend!“

“I've been going to this restaurant for over 5 or 6 years. The atmosphere has definitely gotten better, but thier service in the restaurant isn't great. I visited last week 1/29/24. There were four of us with no one but another couple in the restaurant. We saw the waitress 2 times. Too busy talking and hanging with management . She looked like his daughter and she was not minding the table. Bar service is nuch better with John.“

“The owner is a real nice gentleman that cares about the community. We started ordering from Bella Pizza during COVID, and saw all the kind, quiet acts of serving food to families that needed food, and our First responders, and Hospital staff. The food is always delicious and the owner keeps us a loyal customers. God bless and thank you for being a good human.“

“trattoria uno....my favorite place, every time I go... I order seafood combo omg...I can't wait, I already want to come back from Miami to enjoy my pasta with seafood again...the cooks know exactly what They do...the owner Angelo is super friendly, the best thing of all is that he is Chivas de Guadalajara “

“Great pizza, friendly staff. BYOB is a nice available option. Ordered the large plain pie, which was perfectly done. Crispy bottom, tasty crust and generously slathered in molten mozzarella and a tasty sauce.My friend found the booths a bit too tight to fit in comfortably (He's 6'2" and a larger gentleman) but besides that I highly recommend this place for a amazing pie.“

“When it comes to Nomad I always seem to be the last juror to come around to the group consensus. Basically, they'll put anything on a pizza you can dream of, call themselves artisans and wait for the applause. I'm sorry but Kale is barely a vegetable and is not a legitimate topping. Otherwise, the pizza is fine if you're into doughy crust at a premium price. Four stars for the outstanding service and not being their Princeton location which is a madhouse.“

“Three families went here for dinner celebrate my son’s birthday. The food was so good, but honestly it was the staff that overshined everything! They were so friendly, so accommodating, and so kind to all of our kids. The owner was so accommodating and so warm to all of us. I can’t speak highly enough about how great the staff was. We don’t live nearby but when we are here we will for sure go there for dinner.“

“In New Jersey it's easy to be a pizza snob with authentic goodness being spun on virtually every street corner. Yet, the chain pizza joints who have captive audiences in flyover country continue to inexplicably thrive and prosper within the east coast pizzaria mecca. Inconceivable. That said, Marco's ain't bad. No, it's not quite up to the bespoke goodness of a foldable Neapolitan but it had taste and was downright lavish with the pepperoni. Not only was I surprised but more than a little impressed. So, if your goal is to procure a Eucharist wafer slathered in pizza chain indifference there's always Dominos. However, if you want a real pizza and the Giuseppe Brothers aren't available you could do far worse than Marco's. A surprising four stars in Jersey. Five stars in Iowa.“

“Love, love, love the food here. I'm a pizza snob and I haven't found a better pizza in the area. It doesn't stop there, though. The sandwiches are fabulous, namely the Buffalo chicken wrap and the appetizers have been great as well.“

“Antonio's is great, I did take out. I ordered 3 meals and 3 sides. I got more than enough food to feed 5-6 people. The prices are fair, and I personally recommend the meat lasagna. Great fries, especially for take out. The whole cheese steak is enormous, and also very tasty. Spaghetti was ordered light on the sauce, and it was served light on the sauce. Overall, I really recommend Antonio's as a family dinner spot!“

“I was visiting NJ for work and was looking for a good pizza spot. I went to a different place the week before but it was not good.Today I found Dominics and as soon as I took the first bite, I knew I found a hidden gem. If you are visiting this area I highly recommend this place.“

“3/27/24 - my 1st visit to this fabulous gem Italian Restaurant: Antimo’s. So worth the short trip from Flemington on a Wednesday evening! Max the server — sweet and charismatic, kudos to Antimo the chef. The eggplant parm was a huge hit with very large portion (took over half home) and the margharita pizza was divine. (two meals worth from the “individual” size). Staff surprised friend with a candle in a cannoli for a special birthday. Cannoli was the best birthday cake! Dined in but also ordered steak stromboli and meatballs to bring home. They both smell Devine in car on way home! Highly recommend and I will be back! Definitely recommend checking this place out for a fabulous meal — dine in or take-out (cute, quaint dinning room has a humorous surprise parked in the corner!)“

“Delicious food and outstanding customer service. I moved here and it was the very first restaurant I visited and since then I didn't look for any better place to eat dinner salad or have pizza because there is NO BETTER PLACE THAN DELIZIA PIZZA KITCHEN IN TOWN . Thank you“

“Got some pizza and mozzarella sticks to go. Special ordered a chicken Parm pizza with vodka sauce. Both pizzas were great! Also a nice place, it looks like, to sit down and eat. Liquor store right next door so that's good. I will order pizza from here again!“

“Not a bad pizza but nothing to write home about. 10 times better than Chimney Rock across the street. I moved to Flemington in 1984 and there was only one place to get a good pizza pie and now there's at least a half dozen places for great pies (though there are more than that in number of pizzerias). Sinatra ranks up there with one of my favorites. The cheese on our pie was a little off in colors which made it obvious that it was from two different lots, perhaps different manufacturers. Part of it was super yellow and the other was super white. Odd. I will continue to eat here but my all time favorite is still Taste of Naples mainly for their quality of cheese.“

“We were a party of 11 for the Easter brunch at 10 a.m. (in 2024). We had a wonderful time. From the first greeting by the host/hostess, to the servers, and the buffet workers, to the good bye ~ everyone we dealt with was pleasant and professional.The food selection was varied, delicious, plentiful, and temperature appropriate. Matt, our server, kept on top of monitoring our drinks; mimosas, coffee, soda etc., empty plates were taken away and not thank you for making our Easter brunch a wonderful family gathering left on our table for very long.We could not have been more pleased to come to Amalfi's, our first visit, but definitely not our last.The ONLY negative was it was a bit chilly in the room.I'm sure for the next seating it was a little warmer.Highly recommend Amalfi's. We thank them all fees for making our family gathering a wonderful memory.“

“Great place, and my son loved it. However, when I went, they were extremely short staffed. Had to wait 5 min for someone to let us in/out , as well as only 1 person behind the prize counter, so wait was 10+ min. Also, the birthday watches that were timed play kept malfunctioning and would take 3 to 4 times scanning against the game to work. Other than that, it was a good time... I normally don't complain about wait times , however, when you're with an excited 3 year old, 5 to 10 minutes becomes an eternity as they don't want to stand still or wait and literally are climbing out of your arms so excited to play or pick a prize. However, I completely understand that being short staffed happens. Hopefully, this was an isolated incident, and it will be better staffed on our next visit!Kid-friendliness: This is a kid friendly environment. I also love that kids can not leave without their parents as hands are stamped upon entry. As my 3 year old was so excited, he kept running off. Gives parents a little peace of mind in the crazy world we live in.“