Custom Cakes near Rutherford, NJ

“My fingers and hands are still sticky from the overflowing hot fudge I asked for extra-soft twist, hot fudge, whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles! HEAVEN!! Staff is nice, prices are normal ice cream prices and of course sitting outside eating is the best! So grab a friend and go grab some DQ (go soon before they close for the winter).“

“They did an amazing job on my daughter’s unicorn birthday cake, it literally took my breath away when I saw it! My 4 year old had the same reaction! My daughter is allergic to sesame and tree nuts, so I’m thrilled to have found this bakery for all of her celebration cakes!“

“Really impressed! We asked Stuff by SJ to make a custom cake for a pizza-themed birthday party. Working with them (Drew) was super easy and stress free. They were helpful, responsive, well priced and even delivered our cake to the restaurant ahead of the party. Everyone complimented the design and taste of the cake so it was a big hit. I’d definitely go back to them for our next cake.“

“First time ordering with goldelicouscakes and wont be my last!! Jennifer is super thorough and professional, great with communication- she created exactly what I had in mind for a bridal shower cake. Her cake was super delicious too!! :) Highly recommend“

“Quaint little spot with a great front counter delicious selection of all types of empanadas from sweet to savory and another section with beautiful desserts that taste as good as they look. I wasn’t expecting much and assumed it was probably cuter in atmosphere than food was tasty but I was so suprised. Everything I’ve ordered from the Mangu breakfast, empanadas, tiramisu, cappuccinos, chicken soups- grilled chicken w rice and beans- it’s all been so good. Even their house salad is dressed perfectly - simple, old school and delicious- little gold nugget in North Arlington. Not to mention the women at the counter are so sweet and kind. Genuinely go out of their way to be helpful.“

“Delicious cakes and treats and they taste as good as they look! My family, friends and I have been getting custom cakes from Stephanie for many years. Her work never disappoints. I just give her a picture or a concept and she nails it every time! Some of my personal favs are the tres leche, funfetti carrot and champagne cake.“

“This is quite, cozy and very “clean” cafe. People here are very sweet and friendly. We had a piece of carrot Cake with nuts and the flavor was really great.you can definitely stop by to spend quality time with friends and family! Happy to be here.Parking: Street parking availablePrice: Affordable“

“The Hudson Cakery exceeded all expectations for my wedding cake. Jennifer and her team crafted cake that was not only stunning but also incredibly delicious. The flavors were a hit with all our guests, and the design perfectly matched my vision. Jennifer's attention to detail and passion for her craft made the entire process a joy. If you want a wedding cake that will leave a lasting impression, look no further than The Hudson Cakery.“

“Dulce DE-LICIOUS strikes again. Food is always amazing, packaged beautifully, completely accurate order. They even use compostable sandwich containers. Driver was the most courteous and professional delivery person. Pleasure all around!As an aside, perfect hangover cure: egg sandwich, coffee, morning sunshine smoothie.“

“I had an amazing experience this past weekend. I went to a cake baking class with a few women in my ministry. Ashley, the owner, was professional, patient and very knowledgeable. I would most certainly recommend her business to everyone!“

“Excellent place!!! Everything is top- notch!!! Highly recommended!“

“I wish they would ship items!!! This is the best dairy and gluten-free bakery I have found!!! I have a serve dairy allergy. Their food isn't dry at all very moist. The coconut cake and brownie cookies are the best!!!!Vegetarian options: Dairy and gluten freeDietary restrictions: I have a serve dairy allergy, and it was nice to get really good baked goods!!!“

“Absolutely amazing. Menu changes daily so you're never bored with their options. They have great desserts and their savory pastries are to die for.“

“***4 1/2 stars**I'm not sure how crazy I am about this place being a few blocks from where I live, but I suppose that's not Mo & Jay's fault. I've been aware of this bakery/pastry establishment for a few years (I think it showed up in this relatively new apartment building on Main Street two or three years ago), but hadn't actually thought to go inside until yesterday morning. I was entrusted with obtaining a dessert for a weekend BBQ, and it occurred to me that this was at least the easiest spot to quickly grab something. The fact that the desserts were extremely good ended up being a pleasant accident/bonus.I brought one of my top tier chums to assist with the purchase. From very brief research, it seemed like the eclairs were the big selling point here. I thought it would also be a little wily on my part to get them because I tend to not enjoy eating food that has stuff in it, and figured I'd be unlikely to do anything too naughty with that. That turned out not to be accurate, but I digress. We got the five for $25 éclair deal, and procured a raspberry, a lemon meringue, a nutella, a pistachio and a cookies & cream. Just as we were about to wrap up, I also impulsively grabbed a cheddar/bacon scone, which was humongous and understandably caught my eye.The eclairs were definitely a hit. My personal favorite was the cookies & cream. The flavor was incredibly on point, and it was almost like a meta ice cream experience. The only issue with that one specifically was that the cream inside was runnier than the other pastries, which made it a little messy. Not a huge deal. The runner-up was probably the raspberry for me. Again, extremely flavorful, almost to a fault - it was overwhelmingly tart, which is obviously kind of a calling card for raspberries but if you're not into that, I'd stay away. The nutella was actually a little on the bland side for me but not bad. The lemon meringue was a big hit for everyone else, but I'm not a huge fan of that flavor to begin with - I don't think that's a mark against this place by any means. In hindsight, we probably wouldn't have gotten the pistachio, but none of us are hardcore pistachio fans. The cream consistency and dough for all of these was very high quality, and understandably a lot of this is going to come down to how you feel about specific flavors.In a final twist later on, I sampled the scone around dinner time and was very pleasantly surprised - the scone was very moist and tasty, and was reminiscent of a Red Lobster cheddar bay biscuit, though probably at least twice the size and with actual pieces of bacon in it. Very strong recommend on that front.The service was very good. We had a pleasant female cashier assisting us as my chum was literally squatting on the ground eagerly peering into the display case squealing out flavors to get. Zero issues there, and we were in and out within a few minutes uneventfully. There were also a lot of cakes and other types of pastries, so I expect I'll be returning shortly to obtain their assistance with another BBQ.“

“Cristal created a beautiful cake for my wife’s birthday. We had a party of 30 and everybody was commenting about how delicious the cake was. Cristal is easy to work with. The entire experience of ordering a cake from Its Delicious was seamless and ideal.Dietary restrictions: The cake was gluten-free and delicious.“

“I can't be more impressed with the owner herself ie Christina and her beautiful creation of a yacht cake that she made for me at the very last moment. The cake was perfect and it was melting in the mouth and really yum. I will surely return for any future orders.“

“carrie made a beautiful and delicious cake for my daughter's bridal shower. the theme was Pearls & Prosecco and the cake had sprays of edible pearls on an elegant background of light taupe icing. chocolate cake and filling. A+ in deliciousness and presentation. pure artistry!“

“Rose at Rispoli’s is a delight! Best service and pastries in Bergen County! The lobster tails are to die for. Just ordered a birthday cake and Easter dessert. Not to mention the fresh bread baked all day long. You cannot go wrong with this gem in our backyard!“

“Bebe Bakes does it again! Beth Bennett is my go-to gal for custom cakes and cookies. She did not disappoint for the twins’ 17th birthday…a Shiba Inu in a red Formula One Ferrari! Vanilla cake with chocolate mousse filling! Gorgeous and delicious!“

“I ordered a custom cake from Lyndhurst Pastry Shop and it was perfect! They walked me through everything over the phone. They went above and beyond by adding flowers to the cake, just beautifully decorated. So delicious, too. The person on the phone was lovely, and the customer service in store when I went to pickup was amazing as well! Just super<3“

“Staff is super nice. I got the carrot cake and vanilla cupcake. Vanilla cupcake was good nothing crazy. I didn’t really like the frosting of the carrot cake, however I’m sure you will. But damn bruh that carrot cake itself was bomb. I could eat a tub of it.“

“I had went to three different bakery trying to get a specific design a cake and was turned away . Finally I was recommended by a friend to to see Emily at Bella Vida pastry . Im glad I did ,I have to say my goddaughter sweet 16 turned out so beautiful it was more then we expected we sent her a picture and she matched it to the tee, and it tasted amazing. And let me not forget to mention their very reasonable in their prices They will definitely get my business again.“

“This place is beyond especially if you are gluten free. I really wish more places had this quality of gluten free goods as well as such great options. There are also so many sugar free options as well (keto) which is excellent. My husband is not gluten free nor super sugar conscious and also loves everything from here!A few things that would make this place better to consider: being closed Sunday and Monday is tough if that was mid week it would make my purchases probably 2x in frequency, can you sell mini sized cookies or cookies in 12 packs? Thats definitely one of the best items I would buy that weekly.“

“Love the friendliness inside!!“

“I am incredibly grateful to Karla for going above and beyond on Mother's Day. Despite being closed, she still baked and beautifully decorated a cake for us. Her kindness and dedication truly made our day special. The cake was not only visually stunning but also incredibly delicious. Thank you for your exceptional service and delicious cake! “

“Their pastries are amazing. The service is amazing. Sweet sugary goodness. Got addicted after a coworker brought a box of the pecan danish's and I will never go anywhere else. What's nice is that you can place an order before hand for pick up since those go out super fast by high demand. They are closed on Mondays and Tuesdays which is a bummer but definitely give them a try. Small bakery but big impact on your taste buds! Love it!“

“This was my first time visiting Mattarello bakery and I will definitely come back!When I walked in - I was welcomed by smiling and happy barista.It was hard to choose what I wanted to try,they have a lot off different cookies,pastries and cakes,the lady who was working there helped me to choose the perfect pastries to try.I had bombolone donut with custard cream, lobster tail with chantilly cream and a large cappuccino.Everything tasted amazing.Fresh,a lot(!!!)of filling which made me really happy.For coffee lovers - they have different types of milk to choose for your cappuccino,latte or matcha latte.I had a cappuccino with almond milk and look at the cute bear!I can’t wait to come back another time to try something new!?☕️ “

“Cake was Absolutely Beautiful?The Cake was So Delicious?So Awesome & Amazing❣️Thank You So Much for the Very Pretty & Very Tasty Cake❤️My Daughter’s Sweet 16 Cake was Perfect w/the Lavender & Pink Colors & Beautiful Butterflies??3 Tiers & 3 Flavors Top was Red Velvet, Middle was Chocolate & Bottom was Vanilla❣️The Filling was Buttered Cream Cheese w/Chocolate Chips?“

“Ordered breakfast from Cafe Quetzal next door. They are the operated by the same family. Tried all three breakfast dishes and they were all three great. Really enjoyed the brunch tostadas and would recommend to anyone. The El Guatemalteco is great too. Will be back as soon as i can. The staff is outstanding and reasonable prices. Very good foot.“

“So much thought goes into each one of these cake pops. Each singular work is a piece of art in its own... and the best part... they taste geat. I have used them for several occasions and I have yet to be dissapointed.“

“Red Gate Bakery is an experience that brings me back to loving life when it gets me down, when a hangover breaks me and/or when i want to experience heaven on earth. These unique concoctions are a once in a lifetime experience, unless you visit them weekly, which is recommended. While other bakeries get a lot of fame, these desserts are perfectly balanced so that you can eat them without feeling over-sugared. Go here. Be happy. You're welcome.“

“Wow wow wow! I ordered 3 dozen Minecraft themed cupcakes for my son's sixth birthday, and they were amazing! The cupcakes looked amazing and tasted even better! So soft and fluffy. And the buttercream topping was so smooth and not too sweet. Jason will not disappoint if you need a baked cake for an event. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!“

“We LOVE Chic Sugars! It's fully kosher with a great hashgacha and the sweets are the best you'll find in the tristate! Our family's birthday and holiday cakes ALL come from here. They are next-level beautiful and delicious -- a whole different kettle of buttercream that's superior to any other bakery around. Note for Uber Eats users: Chic Sugars is available there but is not listed under kosher eateries. Just search the name and it will pop up.“

“We ordered a custom cake for my wife's birthday celebration and it was perfect, as tasty as it was beautiful. Colleen worked with us on finding the perfect design, and helped us choose a great filling. Highly recommend Rudy's for a special occasion.“

“I love bills, Milanese samwish and more. It is a place that has been giving us the delicious taste of Argentina for 35 or more years, bringing memories and a piece of South America to New Jersey. Thank you for still keeping your Argentina alive...“

“STOP STOP STOP RIGHT HERE... you gotta have some of this.Everything prepared here is tasty and satisfying to the mind, body and soul.The service is like going to your grandma's house for dessert. She makes sure your dessert is made just the way you want it... SATISFYING!Old school ice cream shop perfect for recalling great memories and creating new memories. Her welcoming smile and hospitality warms the heart then the ice cream cools it down.“

“We had a custom Ups truck made for our wedding on September 30th, 2023. They did an amazing job!!! The cake was magnificent. There wasn't a person who wasn't blow away when they saw the cake. It tasted good, too. We will always use David's Custom Cakes when we have an event. Their communication and delivery were also perfect.“

“My favorite little Bakery in Newark. The ladies are always so pleasant. I usually get the pan sobao con mantequilla y cafe. Deliciousness!!! Ive ordered the morcilla from here. It comes frozen and you have to cook it at home. It is so good. My mother loves the Rice pudding they make for Christmas and the Budín. Honestly, I haven't had anything and been disappointed.“

“We strolled in here at like 3 am after deciding we wanted ice cream and while it was cool we found ice cream at 3am in times square it wasn't cool the chick served me dairy free ice cream with out telling me. My son in law ordered the cookies and cream after me and they guy that was now doing the serving said it was dairy free then my son in law started making fun of me for ordering dairy free ice cream. I ate it, but I felt it had to have been much better tasting if it was real ice cream. It's really hard for me to leave a review because I feel I ate fake ice cream.“