Restaurants near Baiting Hollow

“My husband and I have dined at the Cooperage Inn for many, many years. It literally is our favorite, and most definitely our go -to restaurant when friends from Queens and Nassau visit, as it never disappoints!! The food is absolutely delicious and always fresh; I had the lamb, which is the best and most tender I’ve ever had - the short rib pot pie awesome ? The staff makes you feel like family every visit. A shout out to Scott, who is always accommodating; a real sweetheart, and attentive to all his guests. Bella, our most recent waitress, was delightful and made the evening so enjoyable with her superior service and comedic charm. A perfect evening!”

“Great day and the flowers were gorgeous 🌻”

“I’m just finishing an entire box of their almond raspberry cookie. This is going to be an issue for my waistline. Worth it though!”

“Amazing atmosphere. Real and delicious fresh food made to order. Friendly staff and very attentive.”

“Ice cream is out of this world, great staff and always nice people on line”

“Very kind customer service ! Very clean on the inside”

“The best vegan/gluten-free desserts I've ever had! Thank you for existing!”

“What a delicious meal. Drinks were strong, service was superb. We can’t wait to come back.”

“Absolutely perfect for our Wedding Lunch🥳❤️🍹”

“May 30, 2024. I had a delicious prime rib dinner at lunch. It is so hard these days to. find one that is tender and juicy but this fit the bill. Friendly staff and friendly patrons.”

“Excellent casual seafood spot! Fresh, delicious and great selection! Service was excellent! Staff were outstanding! Loved this place! Well done, Jerry, Nicole et Al!!”

“The manger Sydney cares so much about her clients and the food is always great and well stocked! Tons of options and you walk in to not an employee but a friend!”

“Staff was great and the atmosphere was awesome. The buger I had was one of the best I've had in a while. their house burger sauce is could have drank out of a glass it was so good but even without it the burger would have stood out on its own. Juicy and perfectly cooked. With a nice cold Jetty 4, it was definitely a Cheeseburger in paradise.”

“BEST WINGS (simplest way to put it) Discovered them out East and now they're in Islip. Anthony's wings will ruin everybody else's. Crispy without being greasy and sauces are A+++. Go there.”

“Just had their food truck for an office meeting with lunch. Can't recommend them enough for the quality of the food and drinks. Everyone loved having them as part of our event.”

“Best iced caramel macchiato !!”

“GREAT food...friendly and inviting... ALL FIVE STARS from me!”

“Lolly’s is a North Fork staple and I would highly recommend eating here at least once. Lolly herself has been cooking up a storm and Paula is cooking up amazing plates on the regular. Chrissy is one of the most hospitable servers I’ve experienced. Great home cooking for breakfast and lunch every day. 10/10”

“The Doxie Derby was by far the most fun I had with my dog and all the participants, dog and human alike!!
The weather was perfect and so was the winery for this being the first time they had this event.It was so nice to see all different types of Dachshunds and their people!It was worth the registration fee to let my dog and I enjoy the fun filled event!
We'll be back next year!”

“A great staff…If you want to relax, this is the place ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”

“I love having the diner local. However, we ordered the Greek salad. There is no Greek dressing offered and did not send withTzatziki. This is a Greek restaurant and was not a Greek salad.”

“Great place to visit awesome food great owners amazing service order your delivery from Uber or doordash and not GrubHub you'll get faster service from those two delivery apps”

“First visit. Brian and Beth were very welcoming drinks food and atmosphere great will return soon”

“Most authentic polish food in NY and east end of Long Island. Great owners and staff. Beautiful deli inside.”

“Great day in Riverhead we stopped in for lunch. Very cool place the bartender was so nice”

“I highly recommend Long Island farm brewery great place for beers and good time with friends. Make sure you ask for Nick.”

“My family of 5 had brunch and sat out side on the picnic table. The serving staff was phenomenal. Highly responsive and so friendly. The food was over the top delicious. Clearly Homemade and so fresh. I had the Olga toast and LOVED it!
Olga's is located in a pretty tree'd alleyway, very peaceful.
Highly recommend.”

“Saw this place on the map while passing through Brookhaven State Park and I think the stars aligned. Have been missing a good torta place since my last spot closed and omg this is a sensational torta. The woman at the counter was very kind and helpful as she helped me with my order. Torta milanesa de pollo was just as beautiful as I last met it. Savored every bite. The relleno guayaba was delicious and fluffy. Would come back again!”

“We just celebration my 2 granddaughters birthday this weekend at The Shoppes. Started at Bella Anima, lunch at Ruggero and the perfect ending at Pinch of Sprinkles The bakery is beautifully decorated! Meli prepared a delicious cookie cake for us We were all able to sing, blow out candles and enjoy our and coffee! The girls absolutely loved the Labubu decor!! And of course we took home an assortment of delicious donuts and coffee!! Thank you all!!!”

“Doing such a nice buy one get one free for Mother’s Day!”