Restaurants in Bay Shore

Best Restaurants

1

Zest

Zest 298 W Main St, Bay Shore American • $$

“Vegetarian options: Chef is always so wonderful when we ask to adjust popular apps to be vegan friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: My MIL is in a wheelchair and they always go above and beyond to make her happy and always find a place for her chair.”

4.8 Superb124 Reviews

“What a wonderful place !!!! Just tried for the first time this week and will definitely be back… the food was beyond delicious , service was great and atmosphere was perfect .. everyone should try the pizzeria you won’t be ”

4.7 Superb156 Reviews
Butera's - Bay Shore 8 Third Ave, Bay Shore Italian • $$

“First time visiting from Brooklyn NY. It was a family gathering. We loved it ❤Dietary restrictions: People can request their choices.Kid-friendliness: Children are welcome.”

4.6 Superb222 Reviews

“The wife and I stopped in for date night during Bayshore restaurant week. It's a nice spot, cozy environment, table spread is a good distance away from the next, it's clean and comfortable. They do get busy so get there early or make a reservation. We had the seasonal spread and shoshito pepper appetizers which were both very good, lots of flavor. I ordered the Shrimp and grits and even though I've never been a grits eater, I was pleasantly surprised. The shrimp and grits was incredibly good and had a ton of flavor. I ordered a classic margarita which was executed perfectly and the wife enjoyed her salad and mocktails as well. I would highly recommend this place and am certainly going back! Give them a shot, you won't be disappointed. Thank you Linwood!”

4.6 Superb168 Reviews

“I think was absolutely great food but portions are on the smaller side and there is other locations closer for more reasonable price. I spent 80 on sushi and I was still hungry:/ . For that I will be going somewhere else. Not exactly pocket friendly. Cool spot to hang in patchogue ”

4.6 Superb128 Reviews
Lakehouse 135 Maple Ave, Bay Shore New American • $$$

“The roast duck was tender and tasty, but the confit was too rich for me.They charge for a bread basket.The cocktails are strong, not watered down.Service is top notch.There is not a thing that I do not like about the LakeHouse.”

4.4 Superb341 Reviews

Restaurants by Cuisine

Sweet Jane 64 E Main St, Bay Shore Cocktail Bar • $$

“Absolutely loved Sweet Jane. The drinks are amazing and the food is delicious. Just wished the music (great 70’s playlist) was just a bit lower. I highly recommend the Deuce Deuce cocktail (pictured). Cheers ?”

4.7 Superb55 Reviews

“We recently hosted a fantastic party at this brewery, and it exceeded all expectations! The beer selection was top-notch. The party space was aesthetically pleasing, offering a great blend of indoor and outdoor areas that created a perfect atmosphere for our event. The service was impeccable, with staff going above and beyond to accommodate our needs. Special kudos to owner David, who ensured everything ran smoothly. The dog-friendly environment added a delightful touch, and being able to bring our own snacks and desserts was a plus. The on-site food truck served up delicious meals, making it a truly memorable experience! I highly recommend and will definitely be using this space again.”

5 Superb30 Reviews
KTO Cuisine 1754 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, Bay Shore Latin American • $

“My first experience with Birria tacos and pupusas, AMAZING! Food was fresh and well prepared. The strawberry chan drink was delicious as well. I will definitely be coming back, I wish I took a picture I will next time. 5/5 stars, wish the best of luck to this establishment !”

4.6 Superb64 Reviews

Restaurants with Delivery

Zest 298 W Main St, Bay Shore American • $$

“Vegetarian options: Chef is always so wonderful when we ask to adjust popular apps to be vegan friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: My MIL is in a wheelchair and they always go above and beyond to make her happy and always find a place for her chair.”

4.8 Superb124 Reviews

“What a wonderful place !!!! Just tried for the first time this week and will definitely be back… the food was beyond delicious , service was great and atmosphere was perfect .. everyone should try the pizzeria you won’t be ”

4.7 Superb156 Reviews
Butera's - Bay Shore 8 Third Ave, Bay Shore Italian • $$

“First time visiting from Brooklyn NY. It was a family gathering. We loved it ❤Dietary restrictions: People can request their choices.Kid-friendliness: Children are welcome.”

4.6 Superb222 Reviews

“The wife and I stopped in for date night during Bayshore restaurant week. It's a nice spot, cozy environment, table spread is a good distance away from the next, it's clean and comfortable. They do get busy so get there early or make a reservation. We had the seasonal spread and shoshito pepper appetizers which were both very good, lots of flavor. I ordered the Shrimp and grits and even though I've never been a grits eater, I was pleasantly surprised. The shrimp and grits was incredibly good and had a ton of flavor. I ordered a classic margarita which was executed perfectly and the wife enjoyed her salad and mocktails as well. I would highly recommend this place and am certainly going back! Give them a shot, you won't be disappointed. Thank you Linwood!”

4.6 Superb168 Reviews

“I think was absolutely great food but portions are on the smaller side and there is other locations closer for more reasonable price. I spent 80 on sushi and I was still hungry:/ . For that I will be going somewhere else. Not exactly pocket friendly. Cool spot to hang in patchogue ”

4.6 Superb128 Reviews
Lakehouse 135 Maple Ave, Bay Shore New American • $$$

“The roast duck was tender and tasty, but the confit was too rich for me.They charge for a bread basket.The cocktails are strong, not watered down.Service is top notch.There is not a thing that I do not like about the LakeHouse.”

4.4 Superb341 Reviews
Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream 75 Howells Rd, Bay Shore Ice Cream Shop • $

“BEST ICE CREAM IN TOWN!! I recently discovered this gem. The ice cream is so delicious. You can tell it is made with quality ingredients. Prices are so reasonable. The sticky fingers cake is my fav!!”

4.7 Superb61 Reviews
Sweet Jane 64 E Main St, Bay Shore Cocktail Bar • $$

“Absolutely loved Sweet Jane. The drinks are amazing and the food is delicious. Just wished the music (great 70’s playlist) was just a bit lower. I highly recommend the Deuce Deuce cocktail (pictured). Cheers ?”

4.7 Superb55 Reviews
KTO Cuisine 1754 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, Bay Shore Latin American • $

“My first experience with Birria tacos and pupusas, AMAZING! Food was fresh and well prepared. The strawberry chan drink was delicious as well. I will definitely be coming back, I wish I took a picture I will next time. 5/5 stars, wish the best of luck to this establishment !”

4.6 Superb64 Reviews
Milano Bean Cafe 6 E Main St, Bay Shore Coffee Shops • $

“It was the most happenin' place on the block. Good gelato and a DJ playing Fri and Sat night! Go have a coffee and something sweet. Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya!”

4.5 Superb90 Reviews
Rock City Dogs 3 E Main St, Bay Shore American • $$

“We ALWAYS LOVE dining at RCD. The ambiance is awesome. The food flavors are masterfully paired. The service is friendly.I get the strawberry fields salad with chicken. My husband got The Who; I wanted to eat his too lol! The Truffle fries are everything good and more.The owner is pleasant. She has a passion for RCD and it shows. I enjoy our conversations.I continue to bring new guests and all leave happy and well-fed.You will love this place. I do!!!”

4.6 Superb63 Reviews
Cornerstone Deli 228 E Main St, Bay Shore Deli • $

“Great old school deli I always try to stop at when I'm working in Bay Shore. I've never had anything that wasn't outstanding..BEC. cmon, had an unbelievable omlette today. Lunch is always fantastic with lots of specialty sandwiches. Best part is the people, so friendly and helpful, you leave happier than when you walk in! Great place, give it a try!”

4.9 Superb30 Reviews
JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ 11 E Main St, Bay Shore Japanese • $$

“My name is Rashawn and this was my second coming to here and the experience was once again amazing. My 2 buddies came here for the first time and they were speechless about what they had experienced last night. Nothing fresh food, great vibes, and outstanding service. I must say our Server Ellie went above and beyond for us in every way customer service wise , JBBQ you should be blessed ans thankful to have a server like her. She is awesome”

4.4 Superb110 Reviews
Tullulah's 12 4th Ave, Bay Shore American • $$

“We went for my Mom's birthday dinner and we had a good time. Our server Spencer was lovely and the place had a nice atmosphere despite the lighting. It was very empty this Sunday evening but it took quite a while for our meals to come. The food was great with decent portions for the price. The chicken meatballs were filling and the passion fizz drink was tasty.My mom got an orange and vanilla creme brulee for her birthday on the house that she absolutely enjoyed. Just wish they had more non pork options and meals more kid friendly on the menu (we weren't the only party with children while we were there so definitely considered a family friendly establishment).”

4.5 Superb69 Reviews
QDOBA Mexican Eats 331 E Main St, Bay Shore Mexican • $

“I decided to give this place a try. I was surprised how much I enjoyed it. I chose a custom salad with adobo chicken and a slew of toppings and even a decent portion of guacamole on it for no extra cost. Their Chicken quesadilla was huge and well balance with my choice ingredients. There's absolutely nothing wrong with Qdoba, they do everything right. I believe prices to portion ration is fair. The only downside I think is that possibly they just don't stand out enough vs the competition. I definitely recommend this place.”

4.5 Superb58 Reviews
Rock City Dogs 3 E Main St, Bay Shore American • $$

“We ALWAYS LOVE dining at RCD. The ambiance is awesome. The food flavors are masterfully paired. The service is friendly.I get the strawberry fields salad with chicken. My husband got The Who; I wanted to eat his too lol! The Truffle fries are everything good and more.The owner is pleasant. She has a passion for RCD and it shows. I enjoy our conversations.I continue to bring new guests and all leave happy and well-fed.You will love this place. I do!!!”

4.6 Superb63 Reviews
Cornerstone Deli 228 E Main St, Bay Shore Deli • $

“Great old school deli I always try to stop at when I'm working in Bay Shore. I've never had anything that wasn't outstanding..BEC. cmon, had an unbelievable omlette today. Lunch is always fantastic with lots of specialty sandwiches. Best part is the people, so friendly and helpful, you leave happier than when you walk in! Great place, give it a try!”

4.9 Superb30 Reviews
JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ 11 E Main St, Bay Shore Japanese • $$

“My name is Rashawn and this was my second coming to here and the experience was once again amazing. My 2 buddies came here for the first time and they were speechless about what they had experienced last night. Nothing fresh food, great vibes, and outstanding service. I must say our Server Ellie went above and beyond for us in every way customer service wise , JBBQ you should be blessed ans thankful to have a server like her. She is awesome”

4.4 Superb110 Reviews

Online Reservation Available

Whalers 124 Maple Ave, Bay Shore New American • $$$

“i don’t know how this is not 5 stars. the service and the food is best i’ve ever come across over the hundreds of restaurants i’ve gone to even from top rated michelins in nyc. the best accommodation and food.”

4.3 Superb212 Reviews
Pecado Mexican 49 W Main St, Bay Shore Mexican • $$

“My boyfriend took me here for my birthday and it’s was incredible. The food was so delicious. The atmosphere was beautiful. I got a chicken burrito and he got the skirt steak and we both loved our meals. The guacamole was outstanding. I highly recommend this place.”

4.3 Superb192 Reviews
Salt & Barrel 61 W Main St, Bay Shore Seafood • $$$

“Tasty oysters, world class cocktails, great ambiance. Always a treat. Oysters in particular are well done and the staff is knowledgeable. Try the tiger oysters for a unique treat!”

4.3 Superb161 Reviews

“Recently went here for a date night with friends. This place is tucked away off the beaten place but truly a hidden gem. Our food was delicious, we had some appetizers which we loved. Lobster roll was to die for. Tacos were flavorful. And drinks were AWESOME!! Live music during dinner was a plus. Can't wait to visit during the warmer months.”

4.4 Superb74 Reviews

“Husband had seafood platter and was disappointed that it didn't come with pasta.He thought it did last time he ordered.Was celebrating friend's b-day and poor man found it very hard to go up and down steps!!!!!No handicap ♿️ ramp???really?Wheelchair accessibility: Didn't see one!!”

4.2 Good302 Reviews

“Busy Saturday night wife and I sat at the bar to avoid a wait, the bartenders Katie and Sarah were very Friendly and excellent in attentiveness and service. The drinks were delicious and the food came out right away. We will be seeing them again sooner then ”

4.2 Good118 Reviews
Toast Coffeehouse 9 S Pk Ave, Bay Shore Breakfast • $$

“Stopped in on Sunday around 1pm and it was packed! But we were seated within minutes and served within minutes. The Tennessee chicken and waffles are my new favorite. Atmosphere was incredible.”

4.2 Good93 Reviews
Bella Vie 240 W Main St, Bay Shore Italian • $$$

“What an absolutely wonderful Valentine's Day dinner we had!! The service was impeccable, the food was delicious and the drinks were out of this world!! The romantic ambience is definitely one to go for and the owner is a sweetheart!!! Will definitely be back!”

4.2 Good88 Reviews

“My wife and I had a late lunch here yesterday; Kay was our delightful server, and she was friendly and attentive.The gumbo was maybe the best I’ve ever had outside of New Orleans! Excellent roux! The wings in habanero sauce tasted fresh and not fried. My wife’s shrimp roll was excellent.We found our new happy place.The ONLY comment is that the space was a bit “dark” during the afternoon. Our eyes had to adjust to the outside, but better low light than bright light.The team behind Coastal and Verde have done it again!!! Bravo!!”

4.2 Good69 Reviews
Corks and Taps 53 W Main St, Bay Shore American • $$

“Food was excellent, beer was ice cold. The owners Luigi and Tara were excellent. Staff was very attentive and beautiful atmosphere. Highly recommend this restaurant.”

4.2 Good49 Reviews
Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar 12 E Main St, Bay Shore Cocktail Bar • $$

“Very nice place. Just went there for lunch ordered the steak tacos and jerk chicken quesadillas. Everything was very good. Wasn’t able to get drinks. Will definitely be back.”

4.1 Good62 Reviews

“We had a lot of fun blessing. People yesterday at Olive Garden.Our server Abbey was excellent. The manager was beautiful. The food was top-notch love going to Olive Garden.”

4 Good109 Reviews
Napper Tandy’s 60 E Main St, Bay Shore Irish Pub • $$

“1st time at this place. We were party of 3 and Jess was our waitress. She was so great! She was very attentive to my sister's allergies and always checking on us..Fries, mozzarella sticks, and steak quesedilla were so good.. Drinks were great too! Definitely will be coming back!!”

4 Good66 Reviews
Galanga 25 W Main St, Bay Shore Thai • $

“We love this place and eat here about every other week. The combination of the food, service and the laid-back atmosphere makes this place a home run. (I've had better Thai food, but not around here!) Their entrees are VERY reasonably priced and the servings are nice portions. My daughter loves the Drunken Noodles and my wife's favorite is the Pad Thai. I prefer the curry's and also love the spicy shrimp with string beans and jasmine rice. The waiter is so nice and attentive. We never feel rushed or ignored.We've had most of the appetizers and really loved the fried calamari with the Thai sauce. The spring rolls are also excellent.The duck pancakes were good as are ALL the dumplings! The chicken satay was dry and I just wasn't a fan of the Indian bread.And don't forget the green tea or one of the special Thai teas to go along with your meals.”

4 Good56 Reviews
Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge 33 E Main St, Bay Shore Asian Fusion • $$

“This place is great. It used to be called kumos and it was great. Then this whole experience was divine. The staff is very friendly and the food is so so good and they don't food. Shame you so they just keep the food coming. Everything was delicious. Tip your sushi guy and they send little special appetizers to your table ?”

4 Good56 Reviews
Tullulah's 12 4th Ave, Bay Shore American • $$

“We went for my Mom's birthday dinner and we had a good time. Our server Spencer was lovely and the place had a nice atmosphere despite the lighting. It was very empty this Sunday evening but it took quite a while for our meals to come. The food was great with decent portions for the price. The chicken meatballs were filling and the passion fizz drink was tasty.My mom got an orange and vanilla creme brulee for her birthday on the house that she absolutely enjoyed. Just wish they had more non pork options and meals more kid friendly on the menu (we weren't the only party with children while we were there so definitely considered a family friendly establishment).”

4.5 Superb69 Reviews
14

Whalers

Whalers 124 Maple Ave, Bay Shore New American • $$$

“i don’t know how this is not 5 stars. the service and the food is best i’ve ever come across over the hundreds of restaurants i’ve gone to even from top rated michelins in nyc. the best accommodation and food.”

4.3 Superb212 Reviews
Pecado Mexican 49 W Main St, Bay Shore Mexican • $$

“My boyfriend took me here for my birthday and it’s was incredible. The food was so delicious. The atmosphere was beautiful. I got a chicken burrito and he got the skirt steak and we both loved our meals. The guacamole was outstanding. I highly recommend this place.”

4.3 Superb192 Reviews

24 Hour Restaurants

Baskin-Robbins 529 E Main St, Bay Shore Ice Cream Shop • $

“Visited at almost midnight for an after dinner desert and the employee was very nice!! I feel bad bc it’s a 24/7 Baskin Robins, I can’t imagine working these hours for just ice cream… she doesn’t deserve that :( regardless, Ice cream was very affordable and tasty! Thank you ”

5 Superb2 Reviews
Dunkin' 529 E Main St, Bay Shore Coffee Shops • $

“Was Excellent service!?❤️The People very Polite becauseI have trouble to walk I have my caneand I have only one handavailable the other no!And the guys help me to go to the table!And serve my food!Thanks A LOT ?❤️?”

3.3 Good25 Reviews
Subway 1735 Union Blvd, Bay Shore Sandwich Shop • $

“Fire service, fire quality food, clean clean clean atmosphere. I always come here with no issues. I just left the subway on Main Street in bay shore because they were so rude and disgusting but here??!! I come here all the time and they never let me down. Always kind and sweet and get me in and out in no time. Highly recommend this location.”

2.6 Average13 Reviews
McDonald's 1484 5th Ave, Bay Shore Fast Food • $

“It's a nice McDonald's. It's clean. There isn't much customer interaction anymore, but the computers are working well. Keep in mind that it's fast food, so please don't expect high nutrition. It's McDonald's.”

3 Average78 Reviews
Taco Bell 490 E Main St, Bay Shore Fast Food • $

“App is wierd wanted just those red fiesta crunchies removed from my dbl beef burrito and it removed everyting but the beef. Had them make me a new one with everything but the crunchy things...??”

2.6 Average63 Reviews
Salt & Barrel 61 W Main St, Bay Shore Seafood • $$$

“Tasty oysters, world class cocktails, great ambiance. Always a treat. Oysters in particular are well done and the staff is knowledgeable. Try the tiger oysters for a unique treat!”

4.3 Superb161 Reviews
QDOBA Mexican Eats 331 E Main St, Bay Shore Mexican • $

“I decided to give this place a try. I was surprised how much I enjoyed it. I chose a custom salad with adobo chicken and a slew of toppings and even a decent portion of guacamole on it for no extra cost. Their Chicken quesadilla was huge and well balance with my choice ingredients. There's absolutely nothing wrong with Qdoba, they do everything right. I believe prices to portion ration is fair. The only downside I think is that possibly they just don't stand out enough vs the competition. I definitely recommend this place.”

4.5 Superb58 Reviews
Sumou Sushi & Hibachi 551 E Main St, Bay Shore Japanese • $$

“We were looking for somewhere to eat dinner on Christmas Eve and came across Sumou. The rolls tasted fresh and were great quality.Inside was nicely dim and there's two dining areas, one for hibachi which we will be back for!Service was excellent, yelp check-ins even got me a free glass of house wine! The rolls were beautifully made, and came out super fast.Pricing was perfect for a sushi restaurant, $8-$18 a roll and the appetizers were in the same range.”

4.7 Superb34 Reviews

Takeout Restaurants

Sumou Sushi & Hibachi 551 E Main St, Bay Shore Japanese • $$

“We were looking for somewhere to eat dinner on Christmas Eve and came across Sumou. The rolls tasted fresh and were great quality.Inside was nicely dim and there's two dining areas, one for hibachi which we will be back for!Service was excellent, yelp check-ins even got me a free glass of house wine! The rolls were beautifully made, and came out super fast.Pricing was perfect for a sushi restaurant, $8-$18 a roll and the appetizers were in the same range.”

4.7 Superb34 Reviews
Peter Pan Diner 999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore American • $

“Had a very pleasant experience. Great dinner food. Had the turkey club panini and the veggie burger. I'd recommend both.The turkey club panini was a fresh take on turkey club. The tomato was still a bit cold which was odd, I thought it would be warm, but I had no issue with that. Good flavor.”

4.3 Superb128 Reviews

“A group of us came here on a Sunday around 12:30 after some time in Hecksher Park 10 minute ride away close and convenient for the ride home. The bartender let us try anything on the board, and one of our friends was part of the Hidden Treasure Secret Society, he got a free flight (hiddentreasureli.com). We were definitely an eclectic crew in terms of drinks and not one person was disappointed. I had the Dub Club 2023 a hazy IPA most delicious. Another a pink looking sour, super sour for my taste but my bestie loved it. No food truck a little disappointing as it listed it on the website and this was literally my first time here in years, what luck with a hangry wife. Needless to say we had 3 and left. But for future they do allow you to bring food which is pretty amazing nowadays.”

4.9 Superb23 Reviews
Chowder Bar 123 Maple Ave, Bay Shore Seafood • $$

“Seafood Bisque is supreme!!! Great little place near the water! Perfect for a bite before or after the ferry! Favorites include the spinach salad and pecan crusted talapia!!!”

4.4 Superb53 Reviews
Tula Kitchen 41 E Main St, Bay Shore Fine Dining • $$$

“WOWZA. Tula’s was truly an experience that we will repeat! We were there for date night and my husband and I ordered the Mezza to share. OMG! It was fabulous-I loved the variety and tastes of this vegetarian platter. We had dinner and drinks and coffee and not 1 negative thing to say. Roman, our server was wonderful! They made our evening even more fun! Thank you!! Can’t wait to come back!!!Vegetarian options: I love the vegetarian and vegan options. I am mainly plant based but enjoy a fish when I go out. But knowing Tula’s has such an expansive vegan menu I will definitely be dining here more often.”

4.2 Good96 Reviews
Lasaka House of Noodles 1701 Sunrise Hwy F5, Bay Shore Sandwich Shop • $

“I always get their Bourbon Chicken, it's the best around. I'm only sad I can't order it through any of the apps, they would def get more business this way. But I'll take the 7min drive there when necessary.”

4.8 Superb17 Reviews
Bay Shore Bean 47 E Main St, Bay Shore Coffee Shops • $$

“Great coffee shop with great coffee and good eats. The Bay Shore Bean has a relaxed vibe that is perfect for any occasion. Whether it's your morning coffee run or you want a place to do some work for a few hours the Bay Shore Bean will fit your needs.Not to mention they have good prices for high quality beans!”

4.2 Good76 Reviews
Peking Kitchen 1387 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore Chinese • $

“It's my favorite place for Chinese takeout! Best Wonton Soup and BBQ boneless spare ribs! My son only eats chicken and broccoli, and he eats all the broccoli on us! The owners are super nice and are neighborhood locals. Portions are always big, and everything we order is always delicious. Cash Only.. but it's so worth the little hassle to have cash on hand!”

4.6 Superb21 Reviews
La Cubanita Deli 1827 5th Ave, Bay Shore Deli • $

“Amazing Cuban sandwich. The pernil by the pound and the moro are authentic and delicious. Definitely a place to get food to go but once you get home what a feast.”

4.3 Superb45 Reviews
Bright Bay 180 Howells Rd, Bay Shore Deli • $

“This is your classic Long Island deli with bagels. I grew up about 7 minutes away. I love it so much! Bright Bay definitely has the best egg sandwich in Bay Shore! Their poppy seed rolls are so fresh and their eggs are always cooked to order. The quality of their bacon and cheese complement the eggs so eloquently to make this BEC sandwich the best tasting in Suffolk County. My mom says their chicken salad is very tasty too and their lunch sandwich options are banging! The workers are very kind and make your order just the way you like it without any flaws. They have a large fridge with plenty of beverage options and a coffee station to brew up the Joe prepared to your liking! The vibe inside reminds you of home if you're from the island.”

4.4 Superb32 Reviews
Carvel 188 Howells Rd, Bay Shore Ice Cream Shop • $

“CARVEL is the most ultimate thing that is better than ice cream or any other desert as a matter of fact, if it wasn't so fattening, I would have it 3-4 times a week, I kid you not. ?????I JUST LOVE IT. ?”

4.5 Superb24 Reviews

“Napoleon. I mean it was good yes, but did they take one piece of basil and tear it up? I was expecting a little more from such a nice place. I'll have to ask for extra toppings next time.”

4.3 Superb42 Reviews

“We almost purchased a home in what was once a decayed and depressed Bay Shore in 1988. Wish we had because, like Patchogue, this sea side town is quite beautiful. As was, and still is, Bay Shore is a destination day trip or night venue so similar to Huntington!OUR destination for the best beef I ever tasted is curated and aged well under the careful and kind eyes of Frank, owner with beloved Maria. ( Their ground beef melts in your mouth!, homemade sausage for which to die. I am not a huge fan of meat.) Carnivores, listen up!Last holiday season, I was coming down with what turned out to be RSV. Thank G-d that Christina turned around an overnight order to ensure we had a roast chicken, mashed potatoes, and almond topped with olive -oil drizzled broccoli for the first night of Chanukah's meal!!! My husband made his GF. latkes, I opened the lids of applesauce and sour cream to top them off...a bottle of Kedem wine and voila! We happily spun our dreidels!Fast forward to last night. My husbandordered our "Grinch roast beast" for Christmas Eve dinner, picked up the delicious chicken sausage ring, cutlets.I did a supermarket sweep of salt-free mozzarella ball , jam, Baci chocolate, and amaretto cookies for our last night of Chanukah meal 5 minutes to 5 pm closing time. No rush, but we did as lovely Samantha and Giovanna needed to get home to their families. Our Italian infused Chanukah fete was good to go!I need to stay GF and Giovanna took the time to read the cookies's ingredients aloud to me as I never carry my readers! NO FLOUR, YEAH! Grabbed the magazine ,LIST. on the way out the door withour heavy bag of groceries. WE WERE NOT RUSHED. We cut back our use of Hello Fresh to deliver meals as the omicron virus has waned but still morphing! PICK UP AT Frank and Maria'sis best for one pan cooking, fresher, too!Shop downtown Bay Shore NOW! Check out Willy Nilly's Christmas Shoppe. I rivals Germany's Christmas markets at this time of year. Say hi to Frank and staff ! So warm and welcoming as they greet you with an immediate smile and ask, " What can I get you?"You will be glad you did stop in. This kind grocer family establishment goes the extra mileto meet all needs of many families all year round, not just Fire Island summer residents! Older, younger people living in the new apartments , latter pushing strollers , as their new homes near completion in beautiful again, restored to its former glory of Gatsby's 1920s , iconic Bay Shore!SHOP AT FRANK AND MARIA'S ITALIANGROCER. YOU ARE TRULYTREATEDLIKE FAMIGLIA”

4.6 Superb18 Reviews
Amore Pizza 2110 Union Blvd, Bay Shore Italian • $

“If I could give 10 stars I would. The whole staff here is beyond amazing. They make my mother in law feel so special every time we come in, and the food is always hot and fresh. Full of flavor but not grease.Wheelchair accessibility: My Mother in Law is in a wheelchair after having a stroke, and the Men there all rally around here whenever we're there. They move tables, constantly check if she needs anything, will do table service for her, hold the door when going in or out, even helping her into an Uber.”

4.2 Good53 Reviews
Kitty Mulligans Irish Pub 615 E Main St, Bay Shore Irish Pub • $$

“Amazing Saturday night with DJ Ron playing 80s dance and hits non stop. My friends and I had the time of our life laughing and dancing with Mel the bartender. We will definitely be back !!”

4.2 Good51 Reviews
Ditch Kitchen & Surf Bar 25 Bayview Ave, Bay Shore Seafood • $$

“Recently went here for a date night with friends. This place is tucked away off the beaten place but truly a hidden gem. Our food was delicious, we had some appetizers which we loved. Lobster roll was to die for. Tacos were flavorful. And drinks were AWESOME!! Live music during dinner was a plus. Can't wait to visit during the warmer months.”

4.4 Superb74 Reviews
Peter Pan Diner 999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore American • $

“Had a very pleasant experience. Great dinner food. Had the turkey club panini and the veggie burger. I'd recommend both.The turkey club panini was a fresh take on turkey club. The tomato was still a bit cold which was odd, I thought it would be warm, but I had no issue with that. Good flavor.”

4.3 Superb128 Reviews

“The service and the ambiance were nice. The music was amazing we were dancing having a great time. We had a few shots and drinks and it wasn't that expensive. It was $135 for the 4 of us. The wings were okay I would I have to try them when it's not late night as it was only bar food but the fries were pretty good.”

4.5 Superb51 Reviews

Drive-Thru Restaurants

Burger King 335 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore Burgers • $

“Probably my favorite location in my general area. The refurbished dining room area makes you feel if you are dining at a Four Seasons style restaurante. The staff are very helpful and friendly.”

3.8 Good47 Reviews
Taco Bell 1701 Sunrise Hwy FC-6, Bay Shore Tacos • $

“If you order tacos you better read the fine print. I ordered the deluxe craving box assuming it was ground beef. Shame on me for not reading the fine print. Chicken anyone?”

3 Average11 Reviews
Pollo Campero 1665 5th Ave, Bay Shore Chicken • $

“The chicken is delicious!!! Sides are ok - nothing special. Never ate in. Service is fine though a bit slow. But the way they season the chicken is sooo yummy. Highly recommended Just picked up dinner for tonight. I had ordered online and it was ready when I got there. So I take back the comment that they're slow. They're awesome! Thank you”

3.5 Good50 Reviews

KFC

KFC 210 E Main St, Bay Shore Chicken • $

“I would recommend coming to this place it was excellent service and the food was really good. When I placed my order I accidentally put original chicken instead of extra crispy and they changed it for me in the store. That was so nice of them I will be coming back to this place for sure. Thank you so much for your excellent service.”

3.1 Average26 Reviews

“A group of us came here on a Sunday around 12:30 after some time in Hecksher Park 10 minute ride away close and convenient for the ride home. The bartender let us try anything on the board, and one of our friends was part of the Hidden Treasure Secret Society, he got a free flight (hiddentreasureli.com). We were definitely an eclectic crew in terms of drinks and not one person was disappointed. I had the Dub Club 2023 a hazy IPA most delicious. Another a pink looking sour, super sour for my taste but my bestie loved it. No food truck a little disappointing as it listed it on the website and this was literally my first time here in years, what luck with a hangry wife. Needless to say we had 3 and left. But for future they do allow you to bring food which is pretty amazing nowadays.”

4.9 Superb23 Reviews

“Recently held a surprise 60th birthday party for my mother in-law and honestly had a great experience. I’ve been a regular patron of Goldy’s for since their rebirth; however, recently I inquired about their party services. The process was simple. Even doing homework, price-wise they were competitive with the going rate per person.The staff was tremendous in making the event a hit! They were accommodating, attentive - overall made the experience a pleasure! Again, I would highly recommend and will continue to frequent Goldy’s as a regular patron!”

4.6 Superb38 Reviews

“Husband had seafood platter and was disappointed that it didn't come with pasta.He thought it did last time he ordered.Was celebrating friend's b-day and poor man found it very hard to go up and down steps!!!!!No handicap ♿️ ramp???really?Wheelchair accessibility: Didn't see one!!”

4.2 Good302 Reviews

Cheap Eats

Ghost Brewing Company 25 Drexel Dr, Bay Shore Brewery • $

“Always on point. My ONLY gripe (please don't be mad) are the flight holders. They wobble, aren't labeled, and I wind up spilling stuff. I'll give you $5 (because I'm slightly broke) to change the flight holders. A coffin-shaped one would be awesome!”

4.7 Superb27 Reviews
Union Blvd Deli 2116 Union Blvd, Bay Shore Spanish • $

“The Grilled chicken they make here is amazing! I ordered the medium size combo and came with rice and salad which were also fantastic. All for the price of $9.50. Great service, great people. Plenty of parking.”

4.4 Superb34 Reviews

“Low-key place right on the water serving delicious NY-style slices. They are tossing the dough right in front of you. Try the regular & Buffalo chicken slices & enjoy the gorgeous water view at the nearby picnic tables.”

4.5 Superb14 Reviews
The Shack 245 Central Walk, Bay Shore Seafood • $

“Heaven on earth. Live music, fast food that tastes home cooked. Beer & cocktails. Friendly happy people. The beautiful sun & surf. No automobiles or trucks or buses. Only fresh clean air & good times.”

4.3 Superb22 Reviews
Victorio II Pizza 20 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore Pizza • $

“Highly recommend Victorio’s. Great service and great food. If you just want to come in for a slice(can’t go wrong with any of the varieties) or an eggplant parmigiana hero(shown below) your in good hands.”

4.2 Good28 Reviews

“Never disappointed by TBC. I love the variety on their menu - often different styles of beer from anything else I typically run into at a craft brewery. The space is super roomy, industrial yet comfortable, with plants everywhere, video games, darts, fooseball and other activities. Staff is quirky and fun - we usually go to visit Ashley on Wednesdays and it’s always a great time. There’s often a killer food truck parked outside, and we always make it a point to attend Sundaze at the brewery, the last Sunday of every month - such an awesome weed-friendly event. Don’t sleep on this place - the down-to-earth atmosphere and delicious brews will keep you coming back for more.And to the male Karen (would that be a Chad?) whining about them closing for private events down below - grow up. The world doesn’t revolve around you.”

4.7 Superb9 Reviews
Sabor Latino Bakery 1549 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore Colombian • $

“I love this place. It’s bakery but they also serve fruit juices, a few soups and sandwiches that me and wife love :) ask for an Arepa con todo and you’ll get a slamming breakfast sandwich.”

4.2 Good24 Reviews
Bono's Pizzeria 1397 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore Pizza • $

“The most authentic New York pizza you will ever get! Then owners energy are amazing, humorous and very polite! The food is outstanding! In my opinion best pizza on Long Island by ”

4.1 Good35 Reviews
11 Hundred Deli 1100 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore Deli • $

“The workers make this a very comfy place to play QuickDraw and enjoy a great meal at the same time. As far as delis on Long Island, 11 Hundred Deli would be my #1 choice and that's a #FACT !!!Kid-friendliness: Staff is super friendly creating a family oriented environment!!!”

4.5 Superb10 Reviews

“I have to give this place a review simply because during the pandemic, they were one of the only places where I could actually get something healthy to nourish my body not to mention for instance, the great customer service has been provided by a Miss lady! Her kindness and exceptional service is always been greatly appreciated! Plus the fact that they’re open onto a day like today when we’re having very inclement weather. I highly suggest you stop in, their cleanliness as well as customer service is something you should definitely come check out for yourself.”

4.2 Good20 Reviews

“Stopped here to try. It wasn't bad but it wasn't great. Good if you're in for a quick bite but I think there's better pizza options close-by.”

4 Good68 Reviews
Khyber Grill & Gyro 270 Spur Dr S, Bay Shore Indian • $

“The food is excellent and the service is kind and thorough. This is not a place you go for ambience. This is a place you go for really great food that is full of flavor and fresh.”

4.1 Good24 Reviews
Deli los Olivos 1179 Sunrise Hwy North Service Rd, Bay Shore Latin American • $

“Came into Los Olivos Deli and indulged in their Tacos de Res, and it was a delightful experience. The homemade tortillas were a pleasant touch - compared to the usual packaged ones, other places use. The meat was impeccably seasoned, and the accompanying spicy sauce and lemon wedge elevated the flavors to a whole new level.There's a lot of place to sit and extensive menu options. Overall, my experience was so enjoyable that I'm already anticipating my next visit.Can't wait to go back for more delicious food at Los Olivos Deli!”

4.3 Superb11 Reviews
Takeshi Sushi Teriyaki 1225 Sunrise Hwy North Service Rd, Bay Shore Japanese • $

“One of my go-to sushi spots for a few reasons. The price is a huge driving factor, especially in this economy sheesh! I'll keep it brief though, this sushi spot is right off the service road on the I-27. It may look a bit awkward on the inside because they share the location with a chinese take-out spot so both establishments are essentially connected at the hip. I love their lunch special here: Any 3 classic rolls & either soup, salad, or soda for under $15. They stuff these rolls too so I can never finish my meal in one sitting. I will say you pay for what you get however, this sushi is tasty but it definitely isn't the best sushi available. It is the most convenient and affordable though and for those reasons I will continue coming here when I need a quick sushi fix.”

4.2 Good14 Reviews

“One of my favorite places, not only for the food but the kindness of Amy, Claudia and the whole crew. BEST refried beans, DELICIOUS fish, always on point with the cooked zucchini too. You'll be glad you stopped by. Tell them Ramona sent you :-)”

4.2 Good13 Reviews
Ghost Brewing Company 25 Drexel Dr, Bay Shore Brewery • $

“Always on point. My ONLY gripe (please don't be mad) are the flight holders. They wobble, aren't labeled, and I wind up spilling stuff. I'll give you $5 (because I'm slightly broke) to change the flight holders. A coffin-shaped one would be awesome!”

4.7 Superb27 Reviews
Chowder Bar 123 Maple Ave, Bay Shore Seafood • $$

“Seafood Bisque is supreme!!! Great little place near the water! Perfect for a bite before or after the ferry! Favorites include the spinach salad and pecan crusted talapia!!!”

4.4 Superb53 Reviews
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails 70 E Main St, Bay Shore Mexican • $$

“Busy Saturday night wife and I sat at the bar to avoid a wait, the bartenders Katie and Sarah were very Friendly and excellent in attentiveness and service. The drinks were delicious and the food came out right away. We will be seeing them again sooner then ”

4.2 Good118 Reviews
Tula Kitchen 41 E Main St, Bay Shore Fine Dining • $$$

“WOWZA. Tula’s was truly an experience that we will repeat! We were there for date night and my husband and I ordered the Mezza to share. OMG! It was fabulous-I loved the variety and tastes of this vegetarian platter. We had dinner and drinks and coffee and not 1 negative thing to say. Roman, our server was wonderful! They made our evening even more fun! Thank you!! Can’t wait to come back!!!Vegetarian options: I love the vegetarian and vegan options. I am mainly plant based but enjoy a fish when I go out. But knowing Tula’s has such an expansive vegan menu I will definitely be dining here more often.”

4.2 Good96 Reviews
Toast Coffeehouse 9 S Pk Ave, Bay Shore Breakfast • $$

“Stopped in on Sunday around 1pm and it was packed! But we were seated within minutes and served within minutes. The Tennessee chicken and waffles are my new favorite. Atmosphere was incredible.”

4.2 Good93 Reviews
Lasaka House of Noodles 1701 Sunrise Hwy F5, Bay Shore Sandwich Shop • $

“I always get their Bourbon Chicken, it's the best around. I'm only sad I can't order it through any of the apps, they would def get more business this way. But I'll take the 7min drive there when necessary.”

4.8 Superb17 Reviews

Latest Reviews

Chili's Grill & Bar 2020 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore Tex-Mex • $

“Your employee, Samantha in Bayshore was exceptional. She manages more tables than i usually see one waitress handle and did so without seeming rushed. She was personable snd efficient..”

3.9 Good80 Reviews
Victorian Room 36 W Main St, Bay Shore Caterers • $$$

“Gina was absolutely amazing with going above and beyond for my sister’s baby shower!! The attentiveness, atmosphere, and the food were all incredible. I would highly recommend coming here if you have an event coming up”

4.5 Superb51 Reviews
Cornerstone Deli 228 E Main St, Bay Shore Deli • $

“Great old school deli I always try to stop at when I'm working in Bay Shore. I've never had anything that wasn't outstanding..BEC. cmon, had an unbelievable omlette today. Lunch is always fantastic with lots of specialty sandwiches. Best part is the people, so friendly and helpful, you leave happier than when you walk in! Great place, give it a try!”

4.9 Superb30 Reviews
JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ 11 E Main St, Bay Shore Restaurant • $$

“My name is Rashawn and this was my second coming to here and the experience was once again amazing. My 2 buddies came here for the first time and they were speechless about what they had experienced last night. Nothing fresh food, great vibes, and outstanding service. I must say our Server Ellie went above and beyond for us in every way customer service wise , JBBQ you should be blessed ans thankful to have a server like her. She is awesome”

4.4 Superb110 Reviews
Rock City Dogs 3 E Main St, Bay Shore Restaurant • $$

“We ALWAYS LOVE dining at RCD. The ambiance is awesome. The food flavors are masterfully paired. The service is friendly.I get the strawberry fields salad with chicken. My husband got The Who; I wanted to eat his too lol! The Truffle fries are everything good and more.The owner is pleasant. She has a passion for RCD and it shows. I enjoy our conversations.I continue to bring new guests and all leave happy and well-fed.You will love this place. I do!!!”

4.6 Superb63 Reviews

“The food was great, tasty with good-sized portions. I was pleasantly surprised with this place. Fanny was a great server. I will definitely be going back. We had the marsicada the grilled octopus and Pescado chicharones. This was our first time, but it was definitely not our last.”

2.8 Average38 Reviews

“I dont even know how to express the deliciousness I just experienced. I will admit, I was skeptical about ordering from a food truck but I love Halal food and my favorite places are a bit of a drive so I tried this place and WOW. First of all the Gentleman who served me my food was genuinely friendly and Professional. The quality of the food was outstanding and the taste well I was so impressed I ordered dinner 2 nites In a row. The Chicken Paratha rolls were amazing, honestly one of the best things I have ever eaten, ever!! The chicken over rice was also delicious and there rice is cooked perfectly as well as the chicken. I don't often leave detailed reviews but felt compelled to share my experience. Do yourself a favor and try this place out, you will not be disappointed.”

4.9 Superb30 Reviews

“What a wonderful place !!!! Just tried for the first time this week and will definitely be back… the food was beyond delicious , service was great and atmosphere was perfect .. everyone should try the pizzeria you won’t be ”

4.7 Superb156 Reviews
Zest 298 W Main St, Bay Shore Restaurant • $$

“Vegetarian options: Chef is always so wonderful when we ask to adjust popular apps to be vegan friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: My MIL is in a wheelchair and they always go above and beyond to make her happy and always find a place for her chair.”

4.8 Superb124 Reviews
Flour Shoppe Cafe 19 W Main St, Bay Shore Cafe • $$

“My new favorite breakfast place. The deluxe breakfast sandwich can't be beat and their coffee is excellent. I feel like I'm away on vacation when I'm there. Thankfully, it's right in my own home town!”

4 Good115 Reviews

“Stopped here to try. It wasn't bad but it wasn't great. Good if you're in for a quick bite but I think there's better pizza options close-by.”

4 Good68 Reviews

Most Popular Restaurants

ITA Kitchen 45 W Main St, Bay Shore Italian • $$$

“Love ITA kitchen little small this location compared to the Garden city location but still great food great chicken and veal and table side mozzarella was outstanding definitely will try and get to the other locations too just especially the one on the water definitely looking forward to that in the ”

3.7 Good235 Reviews
Flour Shoppe Cafe 19 W Main St, Bay Shore Cafe • $$

“My new favorite breakfast place. The deluxe breakfast sandwich can't be beat and their coffee is excellent. I feel like I'm away on vacation when I'm there. Thankfully, it's right in my own home town!”

4 Good115 Reviews

“We had a lot of fun blessing. People yesterday at Olive Garden.Our server Abbey was excellent. The manager was beautiful. The food was top-notch love going to Olive Garden.”

4 Good109 Reviews
Tap Room 44-46 E Main St, Bay Shore American • $$

“For a Monday night, the food hit just right . We were immediately seated and served drinks immediately. We did arrive on the later side so that may have affected how quickly we got our main dishes. Appetizers were immediate and the Mac and cheese bites hit the spot! The place inside is gigantic- we’d love to come back on a night when it’s more packed and have the option to be seated on the upper floorParking: Parking lot down the block”

4.1 Good96 Reviews
Milano Bean Cafe 6 E Main St, Bay Shore Coffee Shops • $

“It was the most happenin' place on the block. Good gelato and a DJ playing Fri and Sat night! Go have a coffee and something sweet. Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya!”

4.5 Superb90 Reviews
Bella Vie 240 W Main St, Bay Shore Italian • $$$

“What an absolutely wonderful Valentine's Day dinner we had!! The service was impeccable, the food was delicious and the drinks were out of this world!! The romantic ambience is definitely one to go for and the owner is a sweetheart!!! Will definitely be back!”

4.2 Good88 Reviews
Chili's Grill & Bar 2020 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore Tex-Mex • $

“Your employee, Samantha in Bayshore was exceptional. She manages more tables than i usually see one waitress handle and did so without seeming rushed. She was personable snd efficient..”

3.9 Good80 Reviews
McDonald's 1484 5th Ave, Bay Shore Fast Food • $

“It's a nice McDonald's. It's clean. There isn't much customer interaction anymore, but the computers are working well. Keep in mind that it's fast food, so please don't expect high nutrition. It's McDonald's.”

3 Average78 Reviews
Bay Shore Bean 47 E Main St, Bay Shore Coffee Shops • $$

“Great coffee shop with great coffee and good eats. The Bay Shore Bean has a relaxed vibe that is perfect for any occasion. Whether it's your morning coffee run or you want a place to do some work for a few hours the Bay Shore Bean will fit your needs.Not to mention they have good prices for high quality beans!”

4.2 Good76 Reviews

“My band played a show there small place but great staff,fun and good night out . There is plenty to do there video games,jukebox and drink specials . Bands play all the time”

1.8 Poor76 Reviews
IHOP 1701 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore Breakfast • $

“It gets crowded here, you have to leave early, the service from 1 to 10 is an 8, since I ordered spicy and the cost is that they will deliver it since it was so full, there were a lot of ”

3.2 Average75 Reviews
King's Chophouse 52 E Main St, Bay Shore Steak House • $$$$

“I went there last night with some friends. the ambiance & food was great! My only issue was that after two hours they where pushing out. Just as an FYI our bill was well over $700+ and finishing our second bottle of wine. Side note a table was empty near us.”

3.8 Good74 Reviews
Great South Bay Brewery 25 Drexel Dr, Bay Shore Brewery • $$

“I wanted to share a positive experience for a great location for an event/shower/wedding.Great South Bay Brewery in Bayshore was absolutely amazing from start to finish. Dani, the events coordinator was outstanding, efficient and always quick to answer any questions. Our gathering of 70 people in their party room with golf simulators, a pool table and darts, was such a fun vibe to our special day. Members of the team; Cole, James & Debbie, went above & beyond to make sure everyone was enjoying drinks and food was nicely served. The service was outstanding, food was delicious and a great variety of drink options. I highly recommend great South Bay brewery, especially if you are looking for a fun & relaxed atmosphere for an event.”

4.1 Good72 Reviews

“Me and my friend ordered one fruit tea and one milk tea. My friends said his milk tea was creamy with a nice black tea flavor. My mango tea had real fruits in it surprisingly, with the fragrance of the tea which I am not sure what kind but I like it. We are definitely coming ”

3.7 Good72 Reviews

“My wife and I had a late lunch here yesterday; Kay was our delightful server, and she was friendly and attentive.The gumbo was maybe the best I’ve ever had outside of New Orleans! Excellent roux! The wings in habanero sauce tasted fresh and not fried. My wife’s shrimp roll was excellent.We found our new happy place.The ONLY comment is that the space was a bit “dark” during the afternoon. Our eyes had to adjust to the outside, but better low light than bright light.The team behind Coastal and Verde have done it again!!! Bravo!!”

4.2 Good69 Reviews

Quick-service Chains

Find More Tastes In Bay Shore

Nearest Cities

Frequently Asked Questions about Bay Shore

What are the best dog friendly restaurants in Bay Shore?

- Here are some popular restaurants where you could enjoy a meal with your furry friend:

What are the most popular restaurants in Bay Shore?

- The most popular and well-regarded restaurants in Bay Shore include:

What are the best restaurants that deliver in Bay Shore?

- Popular restaurants in Bay Shore that is known for their delivery services:

What are the best takeout restaurants in Bay Shore?

- Here are some excellent takeout restaurants in Bay Shore: