50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Old Bethpage

“Such a wonderful Southern Italian local restaurant. Highly recommend their Eggplant Parmesan. It's so light and not breaded, and never greasy.The service is always great, but we had a young man as our waiter and thought he was so wonderful that we left him a 40% tip!“

“Had a great time here last night! The calamari was so light and crispy. We got the personal white pizza and it was perfect sharing size for two people as well as a small Caesar salad. Tried the creme brûlée for dessert and it was delicious! The waitress was great and the owner even came to our table to check in!“

“Great food and the nicest owners ever!“

“We hosted our daughter's first birthday here with 40 people on a Sunday afternoon. Working with Ervis and Gabriella was fantastic -- great communication and very flexible. The event turned out better than we could have expected. The food is AMAZING. Everybody is still raving about it and a few of our family members have already been back! Would definitely recommend hosting a small event here!“

“Incredible pizza, the friendliest of staff and just top notch all around. I like my pizza well done and they follow that request perfectly...zero flop ladies and gentlemen. Everything I've tried thus far has been delicious. The wings are crispy and tasty, not that soft, sloppy and gelatinous mess you get from most pizzerias, the chicken cutlets are tasty and thin cut (there should be no other way), the salads always have fresh veggies and are nicely chopped; you can tell ALL the food is made fresh and with love. The hot honey square slice is crispy and thick, yet still light and airy; I'm not sure what sorcery it takes to achieve that, but it delivers lol. The owner is a great guy and this establishment is a gift to the community.“

“The Pizza here is some of the best on LongIsland“

“I just came back from a trip to the Amalfi coast and was dying to find something similar on Long Island and Vico was exactly that! The waiter was so genuine and nice, gave really good service and the food was very good. Pizza and the croquet were the highlights and the only note I could make is the gnocchi sorrento could have had more seasoning but I know in Italy they let the ingredients shine without a lot of seasoning so maybe that’s why. Definitely check Vico out!“

“Please order the Prosciutto Focaccia you won’t regret it. Amazing dish. Service is amazing. All staff very attentive and friendly. Drinks are really good too. I discovered this place after picking up pizza kits from my daughter’s school and thanks to that this will be my new favorite pizzeria. Thanks all for your hard work. You are doing an amazing job.“

“Every time we go it is better than the last. Scarpiello wings and the penne alla vodka - hands down best around! Not to mention how nice the staff and owner is. Always a great experience.Kid-friendliness: I go with my 3 kids, they all have a great time, and enjoy the food. It is extremly kid friendly.“

“Amazing food and service. Would definitely recommend. Was my first time here and it was phenomenal. Drinks amazing as well.“

“This place let me tell you. Best pizza i ever had. Thought i knew NY pizza, Not till you come here!If you dont eat here you're not eating pizza. Staff was amazing and accommodating. Especially the youngest son.A must eat placeI almost had to order one of everything they make you feel like family!“

“Ate at this establishment in Farmingdale yesterday evening! Best pizza we have ever had! Fast friendly service will definitely be returning when I come back area“

“family's and single adults alike this is a place not to be ignored. Apon entering the dining room I was approached by not one but two waitresses. Destin to make me comfortable and welcomed. the food and wine were excellent. cleanliness top notch. Decor was warm inviting and classy. Not to forget the owner . He is a natural with business, quality of food taste and presentation. Between my two favorite servers and he I personally found it very hard to leave the Bar tonight . I will certainly be back.“

“DELICIOUS!! The crust is so crispy, the sauce is fantastic! The hot honey pepperoni burrata slice is amazing!!“

“Best spot in the Huntington area to get a good Greek Salad. I always order their Greek Salad Lunch Special with Chicken Souvlaki - comes with a can of soda or water and half a pita. I usually order online or through their app for convenience.“

“Great vibe and friendly staff. Counter service for ordering food and drinks. The margaritas came out super fast! Tony's had a wide variety of gourmet tacos. The surf and turf was my favorite. The shrimp mango was unique and tasty. The churros were outstanding!“

“Love this place. I live right across the street. I'm in love with their grandma's pizza. The food is delicious. Shrimp scampi is my favorite. And their garlic knots are so garlicky. I usually get a dozen and eat them all myself in way under 2 days. It is my go to place for pizza and pasta. Check it out. You won't be disappointed.“

“Finally, a place where you don't break the bank 5-6 dollar happy hr and the drinks are great and bonus you front have to sit at the bar. Really enjoyed my first time there will be back for sure........“

“Wonderful lunch ! Delicious food and very reasonable. Moses our waiter was so kind an attentive. He made our visit extra special. Booking my birthday lunch , can’t wait.“

“Amazingly flavorful pizza with fresh ingredients! I loved the Metro East, cant wait to try some of the others!!!“

“I got the spinach and artichoke pizza slice and the chicken marsala slice they were both delicious. im gonna be getting from here when I'm in the mood for pizza since it's close to my job. It's a part of a gas station, so it was kinda surprising that it was so good !“

“The Grandma pie. Best ever. But everything else here is great too- all pizza, chicken rolls, the knots are like pillows. Service is so fast and friendly- Joseph is so warm and inviting. This is my family’s favorite place!Kid-friendliness: Preemptively offers to cut slices for kids, so thoughtful!“

“A big Shout out to GUSTOSO’s Pizzeria for hosting my sister’s 29th birthday celebration. I absolutely adored the family vibe that you feel as soon as you walk in. This is my absolute favorite restaurant in Huntington now :blush:. Owners allowed us to bring our own décor. The food was fantastic and no matter what we ordered we were delighted with our meal! But if you ask me the Chicken Alla Vodka was DELICIOUS! Special thanks to Jasmine our server, she was such a pleasure to be around, very efficient, happy, and polite. Can’t wait to return and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend to anyone looking for a small friendly place that will make it a memorable experience to the ones you love.“

“My job takes me from Manhattan to the Hamptons and this is consistently one of the very best Italian Pizzeria experiences on Long Island; not just for the food which is top-notch but also for the always friendly service.“

“At Sardo's Pizzeria, the Chicken Bruschetta and Calzone Special are a real treat! They're so fresh and tasty. And let's not forget about the awesome service – super friendly and attentive. Definitely a must-try for anyone craving delicious Italian eats in a cozy family friendly atmosphere!“

“My husband and I had Chicken franchese, Gnocchi sorrentino, Sides of caesar salad and penne ala vodka. Everything was delicious. Even the oil to dip the bread in was amazing. I loved everything! We can’t wait to go back and try the family style dinner.“

“Amazing team of people! My family has gotten their catering for a long time for different gatherings and events. I couldn’t imagine getting any other caterer for mine & my fiancés engagement party. The food is always amazing, the team is always so helpful and get everything done. Everyone at our party was raving about how delicious the food was & how great the drinks were! I will always recommend Felicos!“

“AWESOME“

“My wife and I recently hosted a baby shower for our daughter. To say the party was excellent wouldn’t be accurate. It was more than excellent. The food, the service, the staff could not have been better. All of the 55 guests raved about every aspect of the gathering. Many of these guests had never been to Bacaro before but now said they would definitely be coming back. If I had to come up with one negative… I couldn’t. Thanks for making a special day everything we could have hoped for.“

“We adore this restaurant! A hidden gem with excellent food (four cheese pie and lasagna were incredible as are salads). Brandon the manager is incredibly welcoming as are owners and staff. You feel like you're eating at a relative's stunning home. Absolutely recommend and can't wait to return!!!!!“

“Love this place ! Always a great meal ! Thanks Daniella !“

“The pizzette I ordered was phenomenal! Wow! Drivers were very friendly too“

“My sister ordered 20 Pizzas for the nurses in ICU at LIJ that are taking care of the Covid patients. Roma generously gave them at half price! Please please give them your business! They gave back to our community!“

“Went here recently with friends, we were a group of 6 and 2 have allergy’s. Luigi personally helped us make good selections for the table with respect to the allergens and was so attentive throughout the meal. He has a great personality and has lots of great vision for the restaurant. It’s a small place so we got there early to secure our group table. Very fun atmosphere and lively and the food was absolutely delicious!!! Creative menu! Come with an appetite for drinks, pizza and pasta!! ???❤️Dietary restrictions: Accommodating to all allergies“

“Papa’s pizza is literally one of the best pizzerias around!! The meatball hero, vodka slice, sicilian, and chicken bacon ranch slices are always made to PERFECTION (*insert chef’s kiss here*)The chicken francese and chicken parm dinners are also some of my family’s favorites!This pizzeria is definitely worth stopping at; the food is wonderful, and the customer service is excellent! Thank you to everyone at Papa’s for always ensuring we have a great experience!“

“Cauliflower pizza was surprisingly delicious! I’d love to come back for falafel and sushi.“

“Always such a great experience. The owner Frank always is accommodating. It’s a family owned business and the food is phenomenal!“

“Mike put on a great show for our scouts and then we enjoyed amazing pizza. I highly recommend them!“

“It was 5:15 pm on a Saturday night, and it was freezing outside and very windy. Upon walking into Babylon Village, the cold winds hit my face as I was looking for a place to have dinner at. I then came across Bella Pazza. From the moment I walked into the store, I was greeted with a very warm welcome from the owner, Aldo. Aldo was very friendly and answered thoroughly any questions I had about the menu. Aldo treated me like family.I ordered the mini rice balls, sicilian style rice balls, mozzarella sticks, a garlic knot slice, and a cheese slice, and let me say, everything that I had ordered was amazing. The decor in the restaurant really enhanced the dining experience and led it to be the true and ideal Saturday Night Dining Experience.I strongly recommend this restaurant to anyone who is looking for incredible Italian food and a breathtaking ambience for when it comes to dining. Excellent job Aldo & Bella Pazza!“

“Great pizza and hero’s. Fast delivery. The Vista Family“

“Where is the Best Pizza in the world? It's in Syosset NY. Owner Luca brings his passion for Great Pizza and more directly from Italy. They are right across the street from 7-11 on Berry Hill Rd. Eat in or takeout you wont be disappointed!“

“We booked Marciano’s Pizza truck for our baby’s first birthday. It’s a Wonderful family run business who takes so much pride in all they do. They went above and beyond to make sure the day was perfect and exceeded all my expectations. Food was delicious and high quality as was the service. I cannot recommend them more especially if you want to do something a little different for a celebration. We can’t wait for our next celebration with them!“

“Uncle Frank's in Wantagh is a great place for Drinks and Food. Hosts and Staff are very professional and friendly. The Mixologist are creative and knowledgeable and will answer any questions you have for them. Menu is excellent with a number of pizza, pasta and app choices that are all excellent. They are conveniently located off Sunrise Highway as well as walking distance to the LIRR Wantagh Station.“

“The best thin crust margarita!“

“Such a great restaurant! Amazing food and everyone was so friendly and kind and attentive. It’s so nice to eat in a restaurant that offers vegan option so everyone is able to enjoy a delicious dinner. Tip extra if you can, they deserve it!!“

“We had a very enjoyable luncheon and celebratory birthday party for one of our members, Wednesday, 11/8/23 for 21 member. The food and service was excellent. The staff is very pleasant and easy to work with and the owner is very thoughtful and generous. This is the third time we have had a luncheon there and will definitely return.“

“Food always on point! Served by friendly staff and prepared in a timely fashion. Many different options for our weekly go to!“

“The place is amazing. The best part about it is the fact that a full animatronic 1-stage is there and it’s the best one of its kind. The 2.0 remodels are absolutely horrendous. Replacing the beautiful stage with 5% of it (Video wall) and that dance floor is the least the community wants. I suggest this store should keep the stage as its condition is the full opposite of beyond repair. The store is nice itself but the Animatronics make it a fan favorite. (Photos shown are outdated)“

“Real people. Real food. Real hospitality. Pizanos. Kin.“

“BEST FOOD IN THE AREA!!!“