46 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carroll

“First off, not that Shirky's is the worst name ever, but I'd much rather eat at a place called Sharky's. ?There are multiple dining areas here. Since the weather was nice, we sat inside the room which is partially open to the outside patio. On the patio there was a rowdy Christian baseball team reading Bible verses, but we didn't need Jesus at that particular moment, we needed a refill.The pizza, which is what is important, was good. The pepperoni was crisp as was the crust, and while thin, it wasn't overly thin.I would definitely stop in again when in the area.“

“My husband and I went for a bowling tournament this weekend. First time bowling here. House is clean, staff friendly, beverage, and food costs reasonable. Only downfall was the tackiness of the approaches. Suggest using a slide cover on your shoe. Overall nice enviroment.“

“To be a small establishment, the food should be worldwide. Excellent food that the following week we went back and ordered again five stars is not enough of this place. Excellent food I recommended to All.Parking: It’s just a small establishment, so not a lot of parking for the food there. They need more parking because it’s excellent food“

“Isabelle was terrific!! She was on top of it the entire visit. Pleasant, knowledgeable, friendly, fast and efficient! Food was very good and hot. Drinks were cold. Kingys has always been great pizza and other foods for YEARSParking: Always busy so parking can be a bit hard. Just drive around until one opens!“

“This is my favorite pizza place in town. Love the fact they use old world pepperoni so hard to find a pizza shop using that. Staff is always nice and courteous a rarity these days. Will be returning.Dietary restrictions: They do offer gluten free pizza“

“This was recommended by a friend,and it did not disappoint! I've never been to Italy but this is the most authentic Italian food I've ever had.we enjoyed salad with fresh mozzarella and tomatoes,homemade dressing and fresh made Italian bread that was so crispy and delicious! Then ravioli and fresh pasta with marinara sauce and mushrooms.and for dessert tiramisu and espresso cappuccino. From start to finish this meal was amazing. Everything tasted so fresh and delicious.now based on location and interior of restaurant I was thinking the prices were a little high,but I'm telling you the food will not disappoint....we were 2 couples and total meal with tip was $200.and they do not accept credit cards so plan ahead for that .(Though I did see an ATM there). The owner is a character full of great information and stories....we were the only ones in the restaurant (in middle of day) so we had his full attention and it was just an overall great experience.“

“Came into MOD pizza on pickerington tonight at 8pm and had the best experience I've ever had in "fast food" the place was clean, and the staff were all amazing ! Jaz made our pizzas with so much love. She explained the process of making my pizza, offered all Toppings and I didn't feel rushed. I also want to shout out the rest of the staff ! You could tell every person cared about their job and put their all in their task. Everyone I interacted with was polite. Thank you for the positive interactions and making my night smooth and my belly full.“

“So,... don't just drive by this one over and over again thinking its just another pizza joint... this is delicious and straight-forward pizza (with LOTS of toppings)! Give it a go!!! Yummy! PS. Flat pricing regardless of toppings selected.“

“This was my first time at this restaurant and I absolutely loved it. I had the lobster, ravioli and I could have licked the plate.It was so good. It is very small inside so it is an intimate setting and the staff and the chef are all very friendly impersonable. Definitely going back there again“

“Just heard about the new Burger special that was recently added to the Lunch menu. Well I gotta tell you, Josh the owner cooked that Burger to perfection. Anyway I guess the burgers are only available during lunch hours for now, as Grapevine is mainly known for their outstanding pizza and subs. keep up the good work Grapevine.“

“Just came to say the customer service here is wonderful. I had a small issue with a charge on my credit card and the owner of the business gave me her personal cell phone number, told me to message her the details, and even replied to my texts when she was on vacation out of the country!!“

“We dined outside on the patio tonight! This is our first time here and will absolutely come back. I am not a fan of deviled eggs at all but their “Demon Eggs” are AMAZING and a must get! All of the food we ate was delicious and the multiple different beers we tried were just as delicious. Our server was Cynthia and she was amazing as well!“

“Got chicken and JoJo's... Pizza.. Italian sub.. and wings ?? all ranged from pretty good to killer... My kids approved, it's going to be added to the rotation!!! Kinda wish they had a proper dining space, but I don't hold it against em!!“

“INCREDIBLE pizza. The smell alone does you in, but the food is just such a cut above. From the biggest pizza connoisseur I know who grew up with Mom at her own pizza place, my husband says it's one of the top 5 pizza places in Ohio. I must agree.“

“Our go-to pizza place for Friday night. They began a drive up pizza pick up service that is ideal for grab and go, for you are home while the pizza is still piping hot. Very competitive prices for the area and some of the best pizza + crusts in town“

“We may be slightly biased because our oldest son works here but honestly, we love the food, too! The pizza crust is a great middle ground between thin and traditional, not too dry/crispy, not too doughy. Our boys also love the subs and wings! We hear compliments from the community all the time on the friendliness of the high school staff members and are proud that ours is included in that group. It says a lot about the owners/management. Keep up the great work!“

“1st time there. The food is great. Good portions. Willing to substitute menu side. Arnold-Palmer beverage required simple syrup. Service was a bit slow. (It's like that just about everywhere anymore, unfortunately.) However, staff were friendly and accommodating. Clean facility. Even the laminated menus were clean. YES, real menus a huge plus! Will return.Vegetarian options: Bean burger“

“Stopped in after an exhausting hour at the trampoline park tonight. Beth was such a great waitress. My 9yr old and her complimented each other and joked together. The food was soooooooo good. Very clean inside and very comfortable. I love the size of their booths “

“I’m obsessed with this place. I came on an extremely difficult day for me, and the server (maybe the owner?) was so caring, it made a very emotional day much better for me. The coffee is very well made, and the food is AMAZING. The chicken is to die to for, and my boyfriend said his chicken bacon ranch pizza was the best one he’s ever had. Thank you, Kumbha-Yah!!“

“Used an online deal Ordered and when I went to pick up the order it got changed but they were SO nice to help me get it fixed bc of course it was just before they were to close for Christmas Eve. So Thank you VERY much for helping fix it so we had dinner!!! ??“

“I love me some Marco's Pizza. The subs are absolutely my favorite. I haven't had a bad pizza from here at all. Marco's provide quick service and my food is always hot and fresh every time. Hands down my one of my favorite spots. You will not be “

“I decided to give the updated/new version of "The Pump House" a try on 12/29/23 since I saw so many reviews that mentioned everything was updated/different/refreshed. I was NOT disappointed. My girlfriend and I decided to eat lunch there. She had the chili with garlic knots and I had the classic burger and fries. Absolutely delicious all the way around. The burger had so much flavor including a fresh bun. The chili flavors dazzled my girlfriend's tastebuds. I only got to try one spoonful, but I can agree!We both decided that we wanted to get a couple of the new versions of their pizza to take home for dinner in the evening. We were very impressed in this respect too. The crust was JUST right. Nothing burnt, it's NOT cracker crust (THANK YOU!) and the topping flavors all came through in each bite.Finally, service was fantastic, friendly, and timely. We are both thrilled to have another quality place to dine close to home for VERY reasonable prices, especially considering the portions and quality received.Thank you Pump House!“

“Had dinner at Omezzo. Very homely and excellent food. Lobster ravioli (we took the appetizer version) was amazing! Lobster bisque was good. We also had Trio Omezzo which is a selection of three types of pastas on one plate (better to share as the portion is quite big). Overall delicious!“

“Awesome & reasonably priced. Reminds me of Cassanos, for my fellow Dayton natives - just without salt on the crust. Nice little char on it if you’re into that sorta thing. Dangerous thing to have so close by ?Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza is available.“

“This place is simply amazing!The owner is a good buddy and the pizza is fantastic! And to that Christopher dude, I talked to the owner about that and he showed me his order receipt, he made that pizza and gave it to the dasher. If you didn’t get your pizza complain to DoorDash, not Il Forno. Oh and you didn’t leave a $10 tip for him ?I tell the owner ever time I get a pizza that it’s the best in Ohio, and as a pizza lover I don’t make comments like that lightly. This place is phenomenal, keep up the good work man!“

“This Is The Best Pizza In Town, Down In Lancaster..I Love That It's Family Oriented & Get Your Bang For Your Bucks..My Favorites That I Order Are..The Meat Lovers Pizza, The Banana Peppers With Italian Saugage, With Pepperoni & Chesse..Another Favorite IsThe BQ Buffalo Wings, The Italian Subs & The Chicken Salad Very Very Good & So Many Others I Have Purchased For Me & My Family..If Your In Lancaster Don't Forget To Stop Here & Grab A Box Of Pizza, Salad Or A Sub..Shout Out To The Staff As Well❤️❤️I Be Back Again...This Is My Go To Spot Pizza Place In Lancaster..They Never Miss“

“They have a great lunch special 9.99 entree side and drink. Fresh salad,hot fries,pizza is fabulous and boneless tenders are great. Me and my husband get a different one and share for a variety. Lancaster is great.been to one in another City wasn't as good. But Lancaster is always good.“

“Today stopped in for lunch ordered a Pepperoni Pizza they accidentally forgot the pepperonis which I was OK with ,I get things happen. The pizza was really good! When I went to leave they gave me a pepperoni pizza which I really appreciated! It’s means a lot to me to make something right. I will definitely be back. Staff is great and kind and food is great! I will be back!“

“My first experience with Christy's was the chicken sandwich my son brought home. I was fresh & delicious. This weekend I chose a Christy's classic calzone, OH Man, it was fabulous! Thank you.I am so glad I live near the East location.“

“This place is totally a cute, divey corner bar. Definitely not the place that has the hottest new IPA on tap, but the regulars know your name. Very endearing, and super cheap. Also worth a visit just for the super hot smokeshow bartender Nate.“

“My wife and I stumbled upon this place as we were driving through the area. Now I’ll warn you, it is off the beaten path and just when you’re about to give up and turn around, just keep going haha!When we arrived we were seated promptly. The hostess and server were very friendly and quick.My wife ordered the chopped steak and I had the Ribeye. Both were cooked correctly and had a good flavor. The ribeye did have a little gristle and some tough spots to it but overall it wasn’t bad. We both got salad, and green beans which were good as well.We really enjoyed the atmosphere and will plan to come back and try something different.“

“Of course I'm going to say great things about Cristy's pizza. It's one of my favorites! Especially the classic, which if you don't know is their supreme.Kid-friendliness: Environment for anyone and everyone!Wheelchair accessibility: There are no steps. All one level.“

“Great evening of live music by "Off The Grid"! Very pleasant atmosphere and great service! The servers and I'm sure the kitchen as well were energetic, friendly and definitely on top of everything and on the ball. The bar and restaurant itself inside was very cozy and inviting and the outside back patio was just as nice. Seemed like all the patron's were just as nice and respectful of one another. Definitely will be going back ?“

“This is possibly the best pizza out I've had in a long time. The toppings are delicious and fresh, the sauce is nicely seasoned, the cheese is stretchy and melts well, and the crust while it is premade, it is high quality. The owner is incredibly nice, even under pressure, and is beyond polite. Please, if you want a fantastic pizza from a local vender and to support the only local food vender in the River Valley Mall, come to Glass City Pizza!“

“Massey's Pizza in canal Winchester is a great place. Atmosphere is great. The food is good. You got a great bartender. Her name is Sandy. If you want to have a lot of fun, go in and see her and you can have all kinds of laughs with her being “

“We went to Romans last night for some pizza. We've never been there and knew they had some mixed reviews. This is not a fancy building, I would classify this as a hole in the wall. The pizza was great! We met the new owner and he was very nice, even turned the hockey game on for us. Don't go here expecting anything fancy. This is a laid back place with good pizza. Simple as that.“

“The pizza was great, reminded me of back home Northwest Ohio Pizza, but that wasn't the best part of experience. I had my 3 year old son with me and I was focused on carrying the pizza and getting him to the sidewalk and dropped my wallet. I got home and they gave me a call that someone had found it outside and brought it in. Everything was still intact and they held onto it until I got back! We will definitely be back for the pizza along with the great service!“

“We order from this place all the time it is delicious and hot. I always ask for my pizza to be well done and it is so good that way I highly recommend you ask for your pizzas that way! But I do put a side note on there... well done but not burnt please ? I get the grilled chicken salad with bacon and some extra vegetables added to it it's very delicious with some cheesy flatbread it's awesome it's a nice little place to have here locally instead of running to a bigger place like Lancaster or Pickerington“

“We went here for my nephews 4th birthday! He loves donatos pizza. They had a private room that you could reserve free of charge. The room had a door to close off from the rest of the dining area with a TV equipped with cable. We ordered 5 large pizzas watched TV and even cut a cake that they allowed us to bring in. Will do this again. Nice intimate but casual setting to enjoy food and family.“

“Solid food, always timely, kind customer service. Spaghetti is way better than olive gardens, and they're meatballs taste good. Only complaint is that sometimes the wings maybe aren't cooked at a high enough temp and the skin is a bit chewy vs nice and crispy. This place is always are go to pizza place.“

“If you are looking for a fancy place with a big menu full or fine dining foods and pinkies-out cocktails, this is not it.If you are looking for a corner bar where everyone knows each other by name, plays pool and darts together, shares pizza, and does shots until closing time, Twins is definitely worth checking out.“

“There is a fabulous deal going on with Jets and the Columbus Blue Jackets hockey team. 50% off on only the pizzas the next day when the team scores 2 or more goals. I do online orders for pick up. Note there is NO place online to put in a tip for the kitchen folks. I always tip cash (at a percentage as if there were no discount) when I pick up the pizzas. I asked the last time I went why tipping isn't on the website and the employee said that option was removed from the website. They do 4 kinds of pizza - Detroit, New York, hand tossed and thin (cracker crust).Parking: Lots of space“

“Some of the best Columbus style pizza you can buy.If you don't know what it is try it, get a thin crust pepperoni, well done. The meatball subs are also fantastic.Wheelchair accessibility: The main level is accessible, But it does have stairs to a basement and upper level. Which are usually reserved for parties..“

“Had dinner here with family craving for pizza, and it's so good.. atmosphere was so clean and nice.. waitresses are also nice.. we loved their French fries too (I know it's just fries, but there's is so crispy and well cooked. Liking their new location. Just kinda hard to find a parking spot when it's their busy hour, but other than that, we all loved it.“

“Great food! They have an extra party room you can reserve for family functions and huge party pizzas to feed a group of kids!Sometimes the service can be a little slow but with some patience we always have a great time!Parking: Plenty of parking!Kid-friendliness: Kid and family friendlyWheelchair accessibility: Open space tables“