14 Best Italian Restaurants near New Middletown

“The Fish Dinner here is really good one of the Best I've ever had tried the Beer battered Haddock and the Next time I went the Parmesan crusted it's a toss up both were amazing. Next time I went I got the stuffed Italian meatloaf stuffed with Italian greens and ricotta cheese it was delicious the only thing about here is you wait awhile for your meal because they are understaffed but it's worth the wait in my opinion really good food.“

“The staff was courteous and very accommodating especially when asked to modify a certain dish on the menu. The only disappointment was that they didn't have sausage or veal on their menu. I usually opt for sausage with pasta and my husband likes veal Parmesan. The restaurant is clean and comfortable.Dietary restrictions: Let your waitress/waiter know of your allergies. They will accommodate you.“

“Looking for a hidden gem of a scratch made Italian restaurant please run to Aqua Pazzo. The dishes we had were delicious and great portions! They have an extensive wine list and a room of wine I believe you can reserve for a large party. 2 distinct dining rooms that were both beautiful. Please try them, you won't be disappointed!“

“This was my First time here. I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS PLACE!!! Alex came to our table!!! I went to grade school with his Uncle!! He was VERY FRIENDLY!! Food was DELICIOUS and Reasonably priced!! I love the fact that the house that is the restaurant was his Grandparents!!! I WILL DEFINITELY BE BACK, to try something else!! By the way, the Hot Peppers and oil were FANTASTIC!!!“

“Was near our hotel. Good Buffalo Trace Manhattan, a beer I hadn't seen before (Birdfish Too Hip To Sip), and a whiskey I hadn't seen (Burning Chair). All good. Langostinos, mussels, and shrimp scampi hit the spot after a long day of driving.“

“1st visit was 4/15! Nice decor and quaint! Server was SUPERB ...between being attentive and friendly she was the only server there and she just rocked! Food was excellent only reason why I gave 4 stars is because the stuffed hot peppers had spaghetti sauce all over it and apparently I missed that in the menu...hot sausage sandwich was huge also!! Will be back again!“

“The food here is phenomenal! The service is wonderful, as well. Portions and prices are decent. The only reason that this has a four star instead of a five is because they offer very minimal gluten-free options. I wish that they offered a gluten-free pasta option!“

“Stopped here for dinner with a friend on the way back from a road trip. It was a very pleasant surprise. The waiter and hostess were very friendly, the atmosphere was pleasant, and most importantly the food was great. We had the olives and the mussels as an appetizer and the linguini with clams and carbonara for entrees. The carbonara was exceptional, full of flavor but not the usual goopiness you find at many places. Also the tiramisu for dessert was great. Everything was also very reasonably priced, including a decent bottle of wine. Highly recommend!“

“We went here for my birthday yesterday because we were referred here by relatives and wanted to try it. The food was excellent- generous portions, served hot, and a ton of variety on the menu. I like the option of either butter or herbed olive oil for the bread- a true authentic Italian way of doing it. They may do a bit more business if they offered alcohol. The server was pleasant, although we felt a bit rushed by her and she seemed as though she did not want to be there, but the food and atmosphere make up for it. Perhaps she was just out of her element that day or was having an off day- we all do. It is said this place used to be an Antone's restaurant back in the day, however I was not reminded of it when I stepped inside. I had the Sausage Diablo and it was wonderful. We each ended up taking half our orders home. They were not busy that day, however we put in a reservation just to be safe. I am glad we tried Paul's and look forward to returning!“

“I have never tried Uptown pizza before, but kept hearing good reviews. I ordered a pepperoni and a deluxe pizza. The owner told me it would knock my socks off. ? And here they are. I could not get over the crispness of the outer crust and the flavor and texture of the dough. The sauce was so mellow and rich, the cheese pull really stretched! It was not too thick nor too thin...just perfect I am so glad this place is down the road from work...I will be ordering often!“

“We are never disappointed when we eat here! My favorite meal was a pork tenderloin with fruit chutney that you could've cut with a feather. I still remember how sublime it was! Their chicken Capri is my husband's favorite. I've had the bracciole and it was excellent. Always a friendly waitstaff also.“

“Small Italian spot in Lowville, Ohio. Family friendly restaurant. The food was delicious and fresh. We enjoyed lunch there on a Friday. The meals are the perfect size. I loved the pasta and garlic bread. Give this place a try. Loved “

“Ate out with my brother, and we were treated very well by the staff. The restaurant was super busy, but I never had to try to get the waitresses attention for anything, she was very attentive about refilling drinks. The food was amazing, it came hot and delicious.“

“Nick and Linda, thank you for perfection! We order the potatoes and greens pizza, the briar hill pizza, and the pepperoni pizza every time and you deliver flavor and quality with each bite! Thank you for sharing with us and blessing us with your delicious recipes!“