40 Best American Restaurants near New Middletown

“We stopped in for breakfast while we were in town for a family function.The restaurant is located in New Middletown. It is very clean inside and the servers were friendly and efficient. The breakfast menu had a lot of variety.I ordered the breakfast biscuit sandwich with home fries. The home fries were okay they could have been seasoned a little bit more. The biscuit sandwich was very good.Someone at our table ordered the pancakes and they were huge and delicious.My wife ordered the eggs and toast and The breakfast was well prepared and tasty.A little off the beaten path but if you're looking for someplace to go for a nice morning drive and meal I would recommend it.“

“Had dinner here last night and the food and service and price were excellent! We both had the Huli Huli Tomahawk Pork.... It was the best pork chop I have ever had! Every bite, including salads and sides was perfectly presented, excellent quality and deliscious. The wait staff were friendly, knowledgeable and attentive. The price was great, $52 for 2 and that included craft beer!The atmosphere is that of a neighborhood pub and I got the impression this is where the locals go. I am not a fan of televisions in restaurants, and they had 4 over the bar, volumes were low or off, but why? Maybe turn them off when there is not a game event, did not enhance the vibe. The lighting in the dinning room is weird. Canned ceiling lights shinning directly on the table made me feel like we were in a spotlight, but at least we could read the menu! With a few small tweaks in atmosphere, they are getting close to perfection. For an upscale healthy meal at a reasonable price, I highly recommend Sabi's, it is a hidden gem and worth the drive!“

“Had a standard breakfast of eggs, potatoes, bacon, toast, side of sausage gravy and coffee. Food was very good especially with the price. Lots of waffles and pancakes options I want to try another time. Waitress was very friendly and engaging, and kept my coffee mug full.Parking: Standard parking lot.“

“This place is a gem! Great healthy choices very clean. I love how Melissa makes all of her own dressing. Everything is fabulous great attitudes And the establishment is always clean. when I picked up my food today I only seen one thing that stood out to me, in the staff members in the back don’t wear gloves when handling food. I do know human behavior and sometimes no matter how clean we want to be with our hands sometimes that isn’t the case and with so many viruses and colds going around. I really like seeing establishments I eat at that is working with my food have gloves on there hands when maintaining or touching any type of food that Hass to go into my mouth. so for me that is the main thing that stands out to me and has me a little bit more cautious. however overall this establishment has four stars Melissa is doing a great job her staff is amazing in the environment is calm and chilled! However the members not having gloves in their hands definitely is a big deal to me and that is a personal observation .“

“I must have driven by Five Branches many times without noticing it, but thankfully an online search introduced me to it today, and we stopped by for lunch. I ordered the Amber attack-best burger I can recall having. My husband loved his pulled pork sammich and sweet potato fries. The decor that paid tribute to veterans and the military and was inspiring. The server was competent and the owner was attentive. Can't wait to stop by for lunch next week when I have occasion to meet a friend in North Lima. What a find!!!“

“Despite hearing bad experiences from peers, I tried eating here for the first time and was blown away. The Galley Boy is by far one of the greatest burgers I've ever had, and the milkshakes were thick to perfection. Service was also excellent, and the people serving were very polite and professional. I'll definitely be visiting this place again soon!Parking: Just pull into a spot and they will wait to take your order immediately.“

“Our wedding at The Lake Club was everything we could have dreamed of and more! Natalie and all the other staff members were so kind and easy to work with and made the whole planning process so smooth. The food was incredible and so was the whole ambience. The lake views made it feel so magical!“

“Irie was awesome. For anyone who judges this place based on gimmick, SHAME. I understand there is a gimmick illustrated here, but I'll tell ya, there are many of the workers who go beyond the gimmick and can also demonstrate the inner beauty of their God-given customer service gifts to also compliment the outer as well; Irie by FAR fits that bill. Quick, friendly and efficient, I can honestly say she's one of the best waitresses my girl and I have had yet. We love the food and we absolutely love the people. It's a friendly environment and the food never misses. Ever. Give Twin Peaks a try, and ask for Irie. You WILL NOT be disappointed. The prices for the portions are phenomenal too! Twin Peaks is a vibe.Vegetarian options: They do have an impossible patty and plenty of salads you can order without meat on them.“

“This place is like a Dutch Cracker Barrel except kind of better and priced accordingly. The Dutch taters and the cheese sauce … YUM! The soup and salad bar with pastries were so delicious and plentiful. I ordered the fried chicken which was enough to take home. All the portions were large, so come hungry or get a to go box. The staff were all very friendly and had good recommendations. I saw some comments about things not being seasoned and I can say I might agree with that on some things but it’s also taste preferences too. Definitely would go back if I was in the area again.“

“If you’re looking for a great place to dine, be sure to try the Riser Tavern! We went to the one on W Western Reserve Rd and enjoyed it immensely. We shared a hot pretzel appetizer, which came with 3 sauces and was great. We both had the breaded and fried fish sandwich which looked exactly like the pictures on their menu! And it tasted better than its picture! We were there in midafternoon, and the place was more than half full, which tells you others feel the same way we do about it. I can guarantee we will be back!Parking: There is plenty“

“Annie is an outstanding bartender that makes everyone feel welcome when she works . She's always getting people to laugh when they're having a bad day & she cares about others more than herself especially her patrons . She cooks too & The food menu is also super good & their drink menu is the biggest I've seen at any of the local bars !!“

“We had a very nice evening out with friends. Our waitress Angela was fantastic. She was so personable and friendly. If you’re going there for dinner ask for Angela. My husband ordered the steak and cake while I ordered the Zin Chicken which was excellent. The steak my husband ordered was so tender, however, the “jumbo” crab cake was a joke. It literally looked like a pancake. I think the chef needs to go up to the New England states or Baltimore for lessons in how a crab cake should look. The Caesar salad I ordered was a little dry also.“

“The food here is phenomenal! The service is wonderful, as well. Portions and prices are decent. The only reason that this has a four star instead of a five is because they offer very minimal gluten-free options. I wish that they offered a gluten-free pasta option!“

“Allex was an amazing server with outstanding service!! She paid for my entire meal, told me about her passion for helping out the elderly, and is even working to adopt a couple less fortunate children in hopes of giving them better life opportunities. Such an inspiration!!! I will definitely be back!!!“

“Loved it. The buffet was amazing, and reminded me so much of home. The service was extremely accommodating and professional. I love the market right beside the restaurant inside, too.I got all the favorites… Pancit, Adobo, Menudo, Pinakbet, etc… And paired it with the banana sauce I got next door ? I haven’t had Filipino food in years, and not regularly since my dad passed. I felt so welcomed to be here.“

“One of the oldest, longest-operating maennerchors (German men's singing choirs originally) in the country!! FANTASTIC food and low prices, great bar and service, awesome atmosphere. Run by mature, respectable people who put their customers first, and it shows! In an 1863 house, definitely one of the coolest and most unique restaurant/bars in Youngstown.Kid-friendliness: Many families come here for lunch and dinner.Wheelchair accessibility: Front lower entrance is the main level.“

“Recently attended a concert (Jim Brickman) on this smaller auditorium side. We've attended sold out concerts from this same artist on the larger orchestra side of Powers Auditorium. Definitely a different experience as it was a more intimate concert this time, especially due to the close proximity of basically all the seats on this smaller auditorium side. He said he had used this side for rehearsing during concerts he performed on the Powers Auditorium side, saying he loved performing on the larger, "orchestra " side, but wanted to return to have a concert one day on this stage that he also enjoyed for the close experience he could share with his audience.“

“Love this place. I live in Bessemer so not only is it close to home but once you've got your membership it's very inexpensive.Staff is awesome, food is fairly price with large portions; served by awesome waitresses...most notably Sherri.Also the one bartender, Maryann, will make specialties like rocket fuel and mainly in the summer frozen margaritas and daquaris. She's also not afraid to try new recipes or whip up something that not on the "menu".“

“I had the special Friday fish with coleslaw and perogies.Wife had Fish and haluski. The haluski was very good, Fish was very good, maybe the best I've had since moving here, we both had fried, maybe a lemon half would have made it perfect. Our waitress was very nice and the kitchen was very busy. Great place for a weeknight dinner.“

“I eat here all the time, it's a very surprising find in the back of a gas station/convenience store, but the food is amazing. The gyros are absolutely packed full, and the chicken over rice is one of my favorites. The prices are also very good for what you are getting.“

“We went there on a Friday night and got seated quickly. We had burgers, seafood, and I had the 12 oz. rib-eye with a salad and a baked potato. I ended up finishing the steak and potato for dinner the next day. All of our meals were excellent!“

“The speed of the service depends on how busy they are but they're normally pretty fast. The staff is really nice and very cooperative. It's a nice quiet place with a picture wall, a tv for the games, and has more spots like a place where you can play some board games, buy snacks and a little shop. I normally go there for the wings they're kind of pricey but definitely worth it.“

“The best food here and not far from the Ohio and Pa line near Darlington. The biggest fish sandwich I ever ate and taste so ? good.Plus big steak sandwiches and there roast beef and mashed potatoes is my favorite!Kid-friendliness: Lots of family's bring there children here to eat. The place where you sit down to eat is very spaces and there booths or. Tables settings.“

“Decent burger, very pricey. 14 bucks for a burger in Lowellville, OH a bit high. Nice atmosphere, excellent waitress. Update...if you use your credit card, prepare to pay more. If you want cheese on your cheeseburger..add 1 dollar. If you need salad dressing beyond the tiny amount they give you, $1.25 for a thimble full.“

“In from out of town for the Easter Holiday weekend. Met family there Friday and had to have the Battered Fish and Crab Tacos. Absolutely fantastic!! Have not been here in a few years, and was great then, still great now! Service was typical spot on. We sat outside and lots of room. If you have not been here, come!!Parking: Plenty of parking, several open areas even on a Friday Fish Night!Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp, wheelchair accessible but probably requires some effort due to angle and door on the side lot. Didn't checkout the accessibility on the other entrance areas.“

“My new favorite hang out! The wings are amazing, the prices are great. Service is wonderful. Plus it's a historic building in Youngstown so why not stop and visit. It's cozy with a laid back atmosphere where you can just relax with friends.“

“The only thing that was left out to be mentioned on the website that it was inside the Doubletree by Hilton, and that was little bit confusing since that was my first time in Ohio but overall it was a very beautiful placeVegetarian options: There were options for vegetarian dishes like spaghetti, squash, and eggplantParking: Parking was easy once we located the restaurant since it was inside the Doubletree by Hilton, the parking garage, and the parking lot were within a short distance of the hotel and they were free“

“This was our first time at this place. First impression was that the place was a bit dated and could use a renovation or remodel. I have to say the food was pretty good and portion sizes were large. The prices were also good. The service was really good with only a limited staff. Fair warning they do not have a liquor license. We will return to try other plates.“

“Today was my first time getting anything here, and I chose to go with the crispy chicken salad that I always see and hear great things about. I asked for extra Italian dressing and I got just that! They understood the assignment and whatever it is and however they make it is so good. The lady who I’m assuming made my food was very nice so I gave her a decent tip. I will be coming back here again for sure!!“

“The sandwiches are out of this world. Plenty of meat loaded on the sandwiches. I had the roast beef sandwich. The sandwiches come fries and coleslaw on them. They were really tasty and big. The bread was nice and thick Italian bread. It was my 2nd time at Primante Bros and I have every intention on going back.“

“This Cafe and eatery is a cool spot in downtown Youngstown by YNG ST. The pastries are awesome, fresh and delicious! There’s something there for everyone’s sweet tooth. I had the cherry turnover and baklava- wow! The best I’ve ever had without a doubt. I also had the coffee which was smooth to the last drop. The coffee station has some funny signs at it lol. My friends actually ate and loved it. The Cafe has a large indoor seating area and small outdoor seating area. The bathrooms were clean too. Parking available on the street. The staff was friendly, smiling and hardworking. This place was clean, very clean! Loved it!“

“I love the subtle ambiance of place like this not to loud can enjoy a conversation a nice meal and a couple drinks to really set up the night. Great place to go never had any problem. The food really isn't 5 star but what really is in this area?“

“My Besty and I haven't been here since the Remodel.......ing has been done and looks like they're finishing up a few odds n ends but for the most part it was very NICE and the sandwich (Tony's sub) my daughter and I shared was very yummy.. And it comes with fries ?..and the staff was very NICE... Great job on the remodeling and thanks for a NICE environment for us to gather for a party and run into friends ?“

“Its 2024 and BJs Brewhouse is still my go to for the gluten free options which are incredible! I have been waited on twice now by Samantha (Sam) and I just love her!!! If you’re in Boardman Ohio - swing by Bjs and ask for Sam!!! Great dining experience ❤️ Sam is extremely knowledgeable and such an awesome person ?Lots of Gluten Free options. Great atmosphere! Devin was the best server definitely ask for him!“

“Hey! Enuff wit crappy reviews! Saturday Lamb, pork ribs, or chicken dinners are the. Best. In. Youngstown. I am including places like The Palm on Steel st and The Royal Oaks on Oak st in that, you know? Best.Lamb.Ever! Posted my pics, this is a small joint, like a booth and a round bar. But the staff is great! The owner is an old tyme bar owner who is usually there, (like the owner SHOULD be!) got a juke box that usually plays '70's soul and pop (which reflects the age group mostly there, but welcoming to the young. Just NO ATTITUDES!) And outside covered dining when the weather is warm. One of my favorite (occasional) hangs in a lazy Saturday afternoon! Oh, my two dinners and four Heinekens was $40.00. May 2021.“

“I've been there twice this month. Employees at the counter are outstanding.The meal's are awesome compliments to the chef'sKeep doing what you're doing. I will be back.The bakery is amazing.Vegetarian options: My first time I was there had breakfast sandwich. Excellent ? The second time I hadMocha sub. It was also excellent . I will be back to try the rest of the menu.“

“Very good for the area, great service, nice reuse of the building too, if you are in the area go try it you will like it a lot of the food and desserts are made at the restaurant and will take you even if you don't have reservations too.“

“Stopped in from out of town as we love finding small, quaint, local businesses and were pleasantly surprised at the quality of meal (we got breakfast), amazing customer service, and hometown feel. It was also a fantastic value as we ordered an omelet, breakfast sandwich, and 2 (not so great) coffees for less than $24! Great place!“

“Very nice and friendly staff. The customers were all cool and you could tell most of them were regulars. We went for a birthday and the whole place customers and employees joined in on us singing Happy Birthday to him. Our waitress was awesome and so sweet. The food was delicious, especially the sweet potato fries with cinnamon butter. Definitely a ‘usual’ for me from here on out.“

“Cannot beat the service and the prices, but most importantly, we are here every week after Golf League, and it seems like we try something different each week and have never been disappointed. Highly recommend! Pic is a view from the best outdoor dining deck in the County.“