50 Best American Restaurants near Carnegie

“Came in for dinner on Sunday and the place was pretty busy. There was a Pens game on and several tvs were showing the game and the surround sound was playing the game, as well. The staff were super friendly and quick to take our order. Two women were both bartending and serving the tables, but we never had dirty dishes or empty glasses for long. The pepperoni rolls were our favorite. We also had a 16" pizza with extra cheese and half sausage & bacon. The pizza was ok! I'd say 7.5/10. The sauce had great flavor. My brother had the special chicken sandwich, parmesan style. He said the flavors were great, but he wasn't a huge fan of the bread. It wasn't toasted and after a few bites, it was totally soggy. There are two 1-person bathrooms and they were both clean, smelled like strawberries (lol), and were stocked with soap and paper towels.“

“I wasn't able to cook Christmas dinner. We were calling every place on Christmas day. Manny's was the only one to answer. Sam was so sweet. Even though they weren't doing orders to go or anything like that I think he really felt how much I needed this. Not just the food but a win you know. He so incredibly kind to me. We've never ate there. So, I hung up looked up the menu and called back with our order which was a big one. Again he was awesome answering questions about the food as I placed the order. Explained it would take a little bit since it was just him cooking it. I honestly didn't care how long it took as long as the food tasted half way decent. When my hubby and Mom went to get it he told them he wasn't able to make my tuna melt and what would I like in place of it. So hubby got me a hot sausage.I just want everyone to know how incredibly kind Sam was to me on this Christmas day. Even though he wasn't suppose to to do a to go order he understood my need. And my both my hubby and mom said when they went to pick the food up he was extremely kind. They also said the bar was a nice looking place. So, me and the hubby will be coming there soon,lol. Plus, the food was absolutely incredible!!! All 6 of us were very much satisfied.Thank you Sam from the bottom of my heart for what you did for me and my family today when I couldn't. It means more than you can ever know. I know my mom was only able to tip you so much due to the price of the bill but we will be down to have a drink so I may thank you personally and rectify that. Again thank you so very much! Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!??Cristal?“

“My husband and I stopped here for lunch, and one of the specials was burgers & fries or chips. Since I love burgers that’s what I ordered.That burger was so delicious! Usually I don’t finish a burger, but I ate every bite of it. The fries were just as good.The service was amazing, and the waitress was very pleasant.It was such a great lunch!I highly recommend this place.“

“Great breakfast place! I go to Pittsburgh on occasion to visit family and this is a place I enjoy stopping at for breakfast, as my relatives in the area turned me on to it. The food is delicious. I enjoy the eggs annd breakfast meats, but they have sweeter things for those who have a sweet tooth. The service is top-notch. The atmosphere is typical of a breakfast diner.During my last visit, the servers did a wonderful job working with a picky guest at the next table who brought in his own diet caffeine-free soda and sent his food back several times due to it not being perfect. They also tolerated his companion, who talked on and on and on about several recent vacations she went on recently and how her son is in a band in another state, among several other topics.“

“We had an amazing date night in April trying this restaurant for the first time. We had the Risotto Balls app and the NY strip and Pork Chops. It was all amazing and there are many more items we are exciting to try when we go back! Great service, welcoming atmosphere.“

“My husband and I had dinner at Robinson’s Smokey Bones last night. We were hungry and not disappointed with our meal. We had a friendly, upbeat waiter, Patrick, who gave us suggestions based on what we asked about menu items. My filet medallions, potatoes, and broccoli as a were delicious, and my husband thoroughly enjoyed his meal as well. The berry cheesecake we split for dessert was scrumptious! We’ll definitely be back, and we’ll ask for Patrick on our next visit! I recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a tasty meal in a great setting!!“

“We had the pleasure of visiting Altius for the first time, and it was truly delightful. The entire staff was kind and welcoming, making our experience all the more enjoyable. The food surpassed our expectations. A special thanks goes to our server, Jacob, whose attentive service truly enhanced our evening. We are grateful for his professionalism and warm demeanor.“

“My recent experience at City Works exceeded all expectations! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm atmosphere and friendly smiles from the staff. Despite it being a busy night, the service was prompt and attentive, ensuring that my dining experience was nothing short of fantastic.Now, let's talk about the food. Oh my goodness, where do I even begin? The spicy shrimp was perfectly seasoned and had just the right amount of kick to tantalize my taste buds. The fried pickles were crispy and addictive, and the smokehouse burger was an absolute delight – juicy, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Each dish showcased the skill and expertise of the chefs at City Works.The ambiance of the restaurant added to the overall enjoyment of my visit. It's clear that City Works puts effort into creating a welcoming and comfortable environment for their guests.Whether you're looking for a casual night out or a place to indulge in some delicious food, I highly recommend City Works. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!“

“Been wanting to try the breakfast sandwiches since they opened and since moving to this side of town, thought today was a perfect excuse. I've seen people rave about this place and now i know why. Seeing as though we got there around 8 am, I'd recommend getting there early because I've been told it can be line out the door later on, but that's how you know it's good. I got the classic with bacon and my boyfriend got the breakfast smash. We also opted to split the Creme Brulee griddled French toast with lemon curd. Paired with an Arabica pour over coffee for him and Oblong tea for me, it was the perfect Easter breakfast. The sandwiches were cooked perfectly. That French toast though, wow! The perfect amount of sweetness and with the mild lemon curd, just chef's kiss. Staff was friendly and service was quick. Can't wait to come back.“

“This place is great but the best part was our server. Tiffany's service was nothing short of extraordinary! From the moment we walked in, her warmth and enthusiasm set the perfect tone for our experience. Her recommendations were spot-on, showcasing her deep knowledge of the menu and her keen understanding of our tastes. Throughout our time there, she remained attentive, ensuring our glasses were never empty and our needs were promptly met. But what truly set Tiffany apart was her infectious energy and genuine desire to ensure we had a fantastic time. She didn't just serve us food; she created an atmosphere of joy and laughter, making every moment memorable. Tiffany is the epitome of hospitality, and her dedication to her craft shines through in every interaction.“

“Shout out to Mission BBQ! We don't get to eat over here often being an hour away but we love the food and love your mission.! The brisket and pork are amazing and I have never had potato salad like yours. I would love the recipe. Thank you for the great service in every way it comes.“

“I got a standard breakfast and it was good. Served by owner Jojo who is supernice. Nice diner atmosphere. Looks like she’s been in business a long time. The only feedback I would give is to please please please do not wear perfume. To be clear, I should not smell my server in anyway at all. I shouldn’t smell their body odor, nor should I smell what is covering up their body odor. Nothing. Completely neutral. No smell at all. That means their body or their breath. Nothing.Please.“

“We have enjoyed Eleven for many years and this visit did not disappoint. Pre dinner service at the bar was outstanding and attentive. Veal & Pork Meatballs / Scallops appetizer was delicious. Tenderloin and pasta dinners were on point. Seating is the only area we seem to be challenged with when we go. Booths are always taken and end up in a less desirable table.“

“There's a lot of things to love about fig & ash; it's got a fun atmosphere, great service, and good food. The attentiveness of the staff was particularly a highlight -- different dishes and utensils for each part of the meal showed an attentiveness to the experience. The food is inventive on simple themes, which we loved (but also felt like it didn't hit on some things).Overall, it was a great experience, but I think for what it was, the price is just a little too high (and thus the 4 stars instead of 5). Specifically, some of the food pairings were a little off, and the environment is a bit cluttered. Nothing bad for a slightly less expensive restaurant, but at this price point it's a 4/5 for me.“

“We've been here a ton of times, this time for my son's 18th birthday. We booked the 5 course experience and it was totally worth it! Danny, our waiter, was the beat We've ever had! Thanks for making everything very memorable and fun!!“

“Very friendly family environment! Husband and wife were very great to us. We drove all from Philadelphia to go to the hall of fame in Ohio to stop here because of diners drive ins and dives. They did not disappoint. They were busy but accommodating. Food was very large and very good! Highly recommend it!“

“First Time Trying Food At Twin Peaks in Robinson, PA. Server Was Very Nice and Went Over Menu With Us. My Husband Not Knowing How To Look Up Menu Using QR Reader. I Did Mine In 2 Seconds...Easy To Do. She Stopped Atleast 5 Times To Check On Us Throughout The Time There..Refilling Drinks and Making Sure Food Was Satisfactory. Very Clean Place. TVs Everywhere. Definitely Will Go Back. Awesome Place“

“This was my first visit to Billie Ann's and had a good experience. It's a traditional diner type of breakfast place with a very friendly staff. I ordered the western omelette and French toast. The omelette was okay, I felt it could've had more cheese and less of the other ingredients. The white toast was also okay. The French toast was very good and highly recommend ordering it. The other plates of pancakes that passed by looked very good. Overall a cute little diner with nice people“

“Food was generally good. The menu is small on Tues. The Pretzel app was good. The Cesar salad was OK, lettuce needed more dressing. Beef cheek was tasty. The chocolate desert was very good. Had a good glass of wine. Price was high for what we got.“

“We stayed the night at the hotel before our morning flight and decided to get something to eat at Caroline’s Restaurant and it did notDisappoint. The coconut shrimp special was delicious and the service was great. Brianna was very attentive and friendly- wonderful waitress!! Will definitely be back!“

“We booked a brunch reservation for 4, arrived on time and then waited half an hour before anyone gave us water or menus. No apology or explanation given. It seemed like there was one girl trying to run the entire front of house. She did her best, but service was lacking. Once we did get to order the food was delicious. The Bloody Mary was unremarkable and could use some love.“

“Best breakfast spot in Pittsburgh. Parking: very limited parking but we were there on a Sunday morning and were able to find a spot. Dining area: The restaurant is pretty small but again we were lucky to find an open table. Shortly after we arrived there were a few parties that had to wait for seating. Food: This was not only the best breakfast that I had in Pittsburgh but in most other places too. I had the pancakes with scrambled eggs and sausage. They make their sausage in house and I went with the spicy sausage though there were different options. I also had pepper jack cheese in the eggs. The pancakes were also quite large and were some of the best I have had in any restaurant. The coffee was also very good and the waitress also provided a to go cup for it as well. Service: The service was excellent. Very friendly and attentive staff. The owners were also there and interacting with the patrons. The next time I am in Pittsburgh this is where I will be eating breakfast.“

“This wonderful spot is open for Breakfast and Lunch and Early dinner (until 5:00pm). The Staff are friendly and Service was excellent. The Menu is vast..lots to choose from. But I went with a 3 Cheese Grilled Cheese Sandwich and it was delicious. It would have been nice if they offered a Cup of Tomato Soup to pair with the sandwich, but Soup is not on the Menu. I asked but the young lady said she would suggest it to the owner The value of what was offered was very good!“

“Excellent restaurant! Can’t wait to return. Everyone is so welcoming and fantastic hosts. I appreciated the relaxed atmosphere, art, and creativity while enjoying really outstanding food. It was the perfect spot for my birthday tonight. ❤️“

“Awesome vibes and food! This place was spotlessly clean and well lit, everyone is incredibly friendly, service staff and even the cooks were so helpful, welcoming, and kind! We got homemade meatballs, zucchini tower, and homemade tiramisu and every single single was just to die for!!! Drinks were strong and cheap and the pool table is well taken care of!Kid-friendliness: High chairs available, bar in the front and laid back dining area in the back“

“As others have said, the Fancy Veggie Burger was easily one of the best veggie burgers I’ve ever had. It’s hard to describe the flavor but it was absolutely delicious. Also the gluten free bun was perfect and I’m glad they offer it as many places don’t provide these alternative bun options. Fries cooked in veggie oil were superb and fresh and the rhubarb cocktail was like a slightly boozie lemonade making the meal even more enjoyable.“

“Very comfortable local diner-style American restaurant. Very nice for relaxed weekend breakfasts, and their Reuben sandwich is fantastic. Food always comes out piping hot and fresh, and their rotating daily specials give you plenty of options.Their French toast is fantastic, and their pancakes are pretty well made too. I wish they offered real maple syrup, either as an option or a small upcharge, because their French toast with real maple syrup would be an easy 10/10.It would be nice if they took cards, but there's lots of cash-only businesses around so it's not a big deal.Atmosphere is very cozy and would get 5 stars, but please consider changing the channel on the TV in the dining area to something other than Fox News! It didn't offend me, but relaxed Saturday morning breakfasts don't feel like the time to catch up on the latest political theatre and it throws off the vibe“

“KIND BUSINESS ALERT! Carl & Lisa run an incredible restaurant. The food is outstanding. Portions are large and worth every penny. The variety will make you want to return again & again. The cabbage roll is wonderful. Perfect! Very small space to eat in. They have limited hours. Owned by a retired police office, hence the name! Support local businesses. I'm from Chicago, and these are some of the best periogies I've ever had!“

“If I could leave a 9 star review, I would! Truly unique and artisanal cocktails, an inspired small plate menu, and presentation of food and drink that is reinventing and exceeding any expectations I ever could have dreamt up. Giuliana is a thorough, knowledgeable, and all around classy server.“

“After several years, still a 4. I started with a drink at the bar and then moved on to a table. It was around 5 on a Saturday and the place was dead except for a wedding party killing a half hour at the bar. Too early, I guess. The bar service was fine. The table service was too, though he perhaps came off as a little less than genuine. In any case, I didn't really want for anything. My burger and fries were very good and I enjoyed the wine. The burrata app was weird (they minced up the burrata?), but it tasted good. Perhaps they didn't want to serve the whole ball? My main gripe was that menu presented was different from the one found on their website. This was due to a recent seasonable update, but come on folks-it's just a quick upload. I was originally disappointed that the burger that I'd come there for was not on the new menu. When we asked, though, he explained (in a sort of annoyed, ugh-I-have-to-explain-the-burger-thing-again tone) that the burger was just too popular. While they still serve it, it's not on the menu "to give customers a chance to notice the rest of the [more expensive] menu offerings". Mind you, this is a $27 burger and fries we are talking about here - not a super-cheap dish that's bringing in the riff-raff. They apparently plan to rebrand the burger as a secret menu item or something. Maybe it's me, but if your burger is outshining the rest of the menu to the point where you actively try to sell less of it, perhaps the rest of the menu is actually the issue. I, for one, rarely order a burger and love more fine dining food, but nothing else on this menu really stood out to me.“

“Came here late night after a photoshoot in the city. Treated the people I was with to a nice meal. I called to see if there was a wait. The person on the phone was very helpful and it was not busy, so we could get in. They greeted us very kindly and sat us upstairs. My only complaint is that the fans made it cold after coming in from rainy weather. I suggest coming here during (Happy Hour) as the food and drinks are very pricey, but understandable as the quality of the food was worth it. The house made tortillas were warm and delicious. The queso, salmon, and guacamole appetizers were delicious and filling. Pineapple Margarita hit the spot. All the tacos they have are superb. Very delicious late evening option if you want quality food.“

“When we arrived the restaurant was very crowded we have been here about 6 times even though it was crowded the waitress waited on us she was excellent our food came within 7 minutes.The food was delicious. It doesn't matter how crowded it is the most you wsit on your food to arrive is 5 to 7 minutes unbelievable we continue to keep going back because it's a very pleasant place and everything is just so perfect. Give it a try and you will keep going back. You will always get a large portion of food“

“Bistro To Go was the exclusive caterer of our venue. At first I was nervous with only one choice, but after our first phone call and tasting I knew we were in good hands. Nikki and her team truly care about their couples and their wedding days. We were able to tailor our menu to our liking and keep it in our budget. Our guests raved about the food and we definitely feel like it was not your average wedding food. Highly pleased and thankful for the bistro staff!“

“Went before my haircut a few doors down and was packed not a seat in the house and was just as good as ever....had the eggs Benedict regular no fancy frills and it doesn't disappoint. 2 girls running around servicing the entire place but they make it worth the visit everytime“

“THE definition of small greasy spoon diner. Absolutely loved it. Pete is the owner, cook, host, waiter, etc. One man shop! Educated on wonderful jazz music while enjoying the best breakfast egg bowl topped with french toast "croutons"! Who thinks of this wonderful idea?!“

“Loved the food!!! I ordered a country fried steak with gravy, eggs, home fries, and biscuits. It was delicious and worth the visit. The service was good; server checked on me and got me the check quickly without rushing me out. I appreciated that because I don't enjoy waiting for the check. Definitely diner atmosphere but that's exactly what I came for. Overall, great experience and would come again.Parking: Parking is relatively easy and cheap with street and parking lots. 25 cents for an hour of parking.“

“We got visit here after going to the conservatory. It was a Friday and there was about a 30 minute wait and about a 30 minute wait for food. We gladly sat at the bar and ordered from a variety of mule drinks. Angry mule and the cranberry mule are so refreshing. We ordered the cod sandwich and fish taco. The portions were definitely large and delicious. Will definitely visit here again!!“

“The experience started with the warm welcome from the staff. From the security to the bartender, they were all friendly and pleasant. The food was really good and seemed to be fairly priced for the area, although I still feel the area is overpriced in general. The process of getting into the venue was easy and organized. The space was a beautifully quaint and well-used venue. The crowd for a sellout was the perfect size and it was not overcrowded. The acoustics of the venue were very excellent and the price of tickets was phenomenal. If there is a downside, it is the parking, however it is free in the evening, which beats $40-$50 at most other venues. I will certainly be back just for the experience. Amazing work!“

“We had a wonderful dinner. The food was prepared perfectly by Executive Chef Nick Senske and his team. The cauliflower and truffle dip was sooo delicious as was the carrott appetizer. We shared three pasta dishes, all were delicious. The Short rib casserchia was very tasty! We will be back.“

“My girlfriend and I are recent regulars. It has quickly become our favorite brunch spot in Pittsburgh. The food is consistently amazing but what ultimately keeps us coming back are the people. They truly care about their customers and they quickly feel like a second family. I wish I could give this place more stars.“

“Downey’s House is a local spot with a LOT of charm and amazing food. The Italian rolls are early the best thing on the menu. Service is always great and the bartenders keep the place running with their excellent service and friendliness. “

“Where can I begin… the food was delicious! Friendly service and real conversation. My family and I are from Indiana visiting for the weekend and we wanted to try Grandma B’s. Went on Saturday morning and it was so impressive we said “We’re coming back tomorrow before we leave!” Only to return Sunday morning and they had standing room only! Sadly my party and I were just going to head back to Indiana, hungry when they called us back in and said”We’re going to make room for you all up top.” They proceeded to prepare another area upstairs to accommodate our party! Hands down best food in service in Pittsburgh!“

“This was a mixed bag. There were 8 of us. Parking is sufficient, right off 88, not hard to find. Easy wheelchair access. After ordering, you seat yourself. They don't take reservations. Waitresses bring your drinks & food to the table.You order at a cafeteria counter, but the food is upscaled. They smoke their own meats outside in the parking lot. The menu is varied with brisket & pulled pork as the smoked products served in familiar as well as new formats like a pulled pork taco. Smelled great, but I was determined to try the buttered lobster roll. It was amazing! Small, tender bun stuffed with the meat of 1 lobster all in butter, unfortunately I did bite into a small bit of shell. Hubby tried the lentil, ham, veggie soup. It was a pretty large bowl & really good. His entree was a shaved ribeye sandwich, also excellent, although I thought it could have had more meat. Crispy, salted waffle fries were terrific. Others had burger, small plate salmon dinner, crab cake - everyone was pleased. The desserts were not very good. Creme Brulee & cheesecake were good, cookies & brownies were hard, not good.Overall, I would go back again. Next trip I will be trying those tacos.“

“Dined for lunch with a group of 14 ladies. Nikki was our server and was wonderful. . .fast, pleasant, just all around good. I like Spots and I like Frangelico; so, I tried the Frangelico Spots. Not saying they were bad, just not my cup of tea. Everyone was very pleased with the experience.“

“Awesome vegetarian Sunday brunch. Almond French toast with a big buffet of sides plus Bundt cakes. Loved the eclectic atmosphere. Lots to look at. Great vibe.Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free options available. No meat served.Parking: Parking is free on the street on Sundays.“

“We had a wonderful evening with family and friends. PA market is an excellent place to get together and enjoy many different flavorful dishes and drinks. The service is always outstanding. We had the arroz con pollo (rice with chicken) and it was delicious. Pizza is always well liked as well as the burgers. Highly recommend.“

“I've lived 5 minutes away for years and never knew what I was missing!I tried Coughlins Law for the first time with my husband and kids a few weeks ago and have already been back two more times (will absolutely be going again and again because we NEED to try everything and the menu is always changing!)So far we've tried the Crab Rangoon Nachos (massive, addictive, and the perfect salty sweet app!), the Fried Burrata (looked delicious but can't confirm because my kids polished it off instantly) the Coughlin Law Burger (loved the theatrics with the smokey dome and genuinely could taste it, too! It was like a super upgraded outdoor BBQ burger) and about 10 more dishes.The service the first time was quick and helpful, but the most recent was above and beyond. The waiter we had was so friendly and funny it genuinely felt like he was talking to old friends the whole time and it made the whole meal that much better.All that to say, I highly recommend this place to anyone who hasn't been here yet. You truly can't go wrong with anything on the menu!*Pro-tip: order as much as you can because they make for killer leftovers too“

“Soo good ? The food is bomb?, I had the Philly steak with mushrooms and beer cheese, a side of fries and my husband had the Rodeo burger ? with fries also we had the Fish sandwich/fries and the twice fried chicken wings with the house bbq/onion rings and everything was cooked to perfection and so delicious.“

“Four of us went to Revival for Easter. I’ve seen the place so many times on Resy, but didn’t pull the trigger until now… I regret waiting to visit. Awesome experience all around. Service was excellent. Food was prepared perfectly. Menu had a nice variety. Definitely going to be heading back soon.“

“I'd definitely recommend this place if you're in the area, but wouldn't go out of my way for it. The service was fantastic, but the food wasn't a full A+. The duck I got was incredibly tender, the demi was unctuous as all hell, and the leek puree really brought everything together, but the skin lacked any sense of crisp to it and my wife's pork chop was incredibly under seasoned.“