New American Restaurants near Elm Grove, WI

“The atmosphere is clean and fun. The service is great. The menu has many options and the food is delicious. Pricing is justified with the quality and quantity of the food served. I can't wait to come back to enjoy another very pleasant experience.“

“What a spectacular experience! the young lady who took my order took the time to walk me through her menu favorites and described how each was made was such a joy to speak to! The food is the best greek I’ve had in a very long time! I had the pork with red sauce as recommended! Highly recommend, I can’t wait to try something else next time!“

“Last two times I have gone here I have had bad food. Fried chicken livers way over done, and beef shank was dry and tough, variable were under cooked to he point of being raw. And last time I went somehow my bill came out to $168. I had drinks and bought cocktails mix to go, but just seemed like too much after I thought about it. Not sure if I trust restaurant manger, seemed to be playing around with the bill.“

“A group of seven of us went there on Monday night. The overall experience left us with mixed feelings. Scallop Specials: Introduced by the staff serviced our table. It's too Salty, also it's more expensive compared to other main dishes on the dinner menu. Chicken & Mushroom Risotto: it tasted fine, but not to my standard. Tip Calculated Automatically One aspect that caught us off guard was the automatic tip calculation. Without asking, the restaurant included the tip in our total bill. While we appreciate the convenience, it would have been nice to have the option to adjust the tip based on our experience. Warmth of Service Unfortunately, we didn't feel particularly well-treated during our visit. The staff efficiently took our orders and delivered the food promptly, but there was a lack of warmth or personal touch. A smile or a friendly chat can go a long way in enhancing the dining experience.“

“We celebrated our dad’s 80th birthday here, the second big milestone our family has celebrated at Parkside 23. The food was absolutely delicious and our server, Aaron, did a phenomenal job! The private room was perfect for us with just over twenty guests. It was a great space and beautiful ambiance. Our event coordinator, Brittany, was very helpful and responsive! Highly recommend it!“

“This is truly a neighborhood diner that is a local favorite spot. We went on a Saturday mid-morning for brunch, and trust me . . . We were not alone. That joint was packed. We had about a 25 minute wait which was cool. Once we got seated, we were greeted by our waitress. The wait staff is not like an ordinary staff. They are a group of people that look like they just put on whatever is clean and come to work. You really don’t know who works there as the restaurant staff look like the average customer. . , it’s kinda weird, but it works. Our waitress was awesome!We had the Buffalo chicken BLT wrap with hand cut fries and creamy coleslaw and the spicy chicken quesadilla with tortilla chips w/salsa and sour cream. The food was soooo flavorful and seasoned to perfection.It’s a very busy dish place where everyone minds their own business. Loved it!!! I will be back. This restaurant should be featured on Diners, Drive-ins and Dives.“

“My wife and I love coming here when we're waiting for our dog to be groomed down the road. The chicken dumpling soup is awesome and I had a patty melt today. That was as good as I've had in many years. What I liked most is the service we received from Debbie. She was amazing. Debbie anticipated our needs constantly, even though they were very busy. Extremely impressed!“

“We love Cooper's Hawk. It is always a treat to eat there. The staff, ambiance, and food are outstanding. There were three of us and we all had the medallions of beef. It came with mashed potatoes and asparagus. It was just delicious and I would recommend it. It is noisy and that would be my only complaint. However, it won't keep us from returning soon.“

“"the" Kitchen in Sussex, is a hidden gem. I am hesitant to review it publicly because it may lose its small town diner feel.I have been here 2x, both times for breakfast. Fast service, friendly service, quick coffee and good. My first time I had an omelette - nothing wrong with it. The second time I had the Corned Beef with two eggs over easy - nothing wrong with it. And, a side of ham - moist and not dryed out. The wheat bread both times were good.A nice, small town diner that for me does it right.I will be back (at least) 1x per week.“

“Please just stop in and try a plate. Food is made from the heart ❤️you can't go wrong with food like that! When speaking with the owner he is updating/upgrading the menu to a better selection and his creativity. The service is great! The place is very clean too! Thank you. I would definitely come back when on this side of town.“

“This was literally the best experience we’ve had somewhere. We came in and our toddler just started screaming. We were about to leave when the manager came over and offered him a cookie to calm him down. Amazing. We asked if we could order his food before ours, so another server got his order, and his food was out within two minutes. It made us so happy that we were treated like that. We just wanted to be able to go out and eat, and you all made it happen. Thank you to our server Jayden, the other server, the manager, and kitchen for making our toddler(and us) happy!“

“My husband agrees that the duck fat burger is one of the best he’s ever had! I love the vegetarian fat noodles they’ve had on the menu during the winter season, seriously mouth watering.. but pretty spicy (the Thai chilis they put in there are no joke and last time I was crying at the table for a good 25mins because I accidentally ate one), I wish there was a warning about that. The cocktails are good, but not anything fabulous or fancy. We’ve been back once since our first time there a couple months ago!“

“Benny's is one of the best family restaurants I've been to in a very long time. Our server was fantastic, the food was delicious, and my classic bloody was made from scratch, not a mix! I had an avacado omelet, American fries and pancakes, Happy Birthday to me! Glad I picked here, we'll be back again.“

“Easily a hidden gem. The food is outstanding. Excellent tacos, fried chicken sandwiches, quesadillas. A must try. Easily some of the best food in the area.Dietary restrictions: They do have gluten free things on the menu. My wife has Celiac's and she is safe to eat there.“

“First time here and we’ll surely be back. Appetizers were delicious, we ordered the French onion dip and Brussels. Ended up splitting the Buffalo chicken sandwich which was nice and crispy. Service was 10/10. All around a great experience. Amazing drink menu too!“

“My husband and I each had the 3 meat meal with 2 sides! Delicious! We got the pulled pork, brisket and hot link (cheddar jalapeño sausage) for $20 each! We tried the mac and cheese topped with the hot links! Hot, fresh and great tasting! Try the hickory bbq sauce!“

“This was a random Google find, and I'll definitely be back. The Chicken sandwich was delicious, the breading light and crispy (and completely attached!); one of the best I've had in a while. The breakfast Burrito was a good size, bigger than expected as it was about standard burrito size (you know how some places offer smaller breakfast sized burritos) The corndogs were pretty good, although they were about half the size the picture online made them appear. Fries did not disappoint and my son said his burger sliders were good. Overall it seems like you can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Employees seemed in good spirits too.“

“Food and service are very good. Wine list $ start quite high and we do NOT like/do NOT understand the $4 added bar charge for each mixed cocktail like a Manhattan! So, $8 + $4 "RXS" What is that all about? Will probably patronize less in the future.“

“This is a nice neighborhood bar. I go there to watch sports as they have a good setup with multiple screens showing just about any game you want to see. The food is good and reasonably priced. They have a good selection of beers on tap. Friendly and attentive bartenders. The only thing I can say negative is that it can get pretty loud, so if you're looking for a quiet place for conversation this isn't it.“

“What a find. The fish fry was the BEST I've had 8n a LONG time!! Waitress was hopp8ng but provided excellent service!!Parking: They've got a drive through also. I'm sure it's for pre-orders.Wheelchair accessibility: They have a ramp for entrance“

“Classic milwaukee neighborhood tavern, but with the best food ! The burgers are amazing- fresh ground daily. Don't skip the soup, it's all home made. This place has really nice regular clientele, and lovely bar staff that also cook the food.Before dark it's a decent tavern for families too.The burgers are some of the best around.Kid-friendliness: Pool table, fun juke box, nice regular clientele and kid friendly staff. Kids love the burgers.Parking: Large parking lot with plenty of spaces, easy to get around d.“

“My husband and I met up with a few friends here on a Saturday night and it was super busy! It took a little bit of waiting at the bar to get a table, but we did settle into a booth soon enough. Our waitress was super sweet and was clearly working very hard on this busy night, but took excellent care of us. I had a French Kiss followed by the House Daiquiri. The French Kiss was yummy, but a little strong on the hibiscus syrup in my opinion. The House Daiquiri was confusing - all the daiquiris I've ever had have been served neat in a coupe - my friend ordered a vodka gimlet which was served this way - but the daiquiri was on the rocks in a tall glass. It was very good nevertheless. My husband got an old fashioned, which he thoroughly enjoyed. They also have some bar food which we were excited to try. We ordered a basket of salted fries and risotto bites, but found out after that they were out of the risotto bites. The fries were really good: the outside was crispy and inside fluffy and not dense. It was also seasoned very well. I imagine the risotto bites were equally delicious, so we'll have to go back to try it! Our check did include the risotto bites, but our waitress was sweet and fixed it right away. Overall a good experience and would definitely come back!“

“The atmosphere is so inviting. The patios were full on the day we were there. The food was very good and the bread left us wanting more. Our server, Caleb was efficient and accommodating to the two members in our group using mobile aids. Place was busy and he never missed a stepWheelchair accessibility: The walkway/ramp is rustic stone pavers with a slightly steeper grade that would be difficult for a manual wheelchair to manage. That said, it is accessible“

“I love this place! First time here, and what an experience!! The salmon tacos tasted amazing, bright, and the sause added a kick! The drinks were spot on! The owner took the time to introduce himself, adding further to the friendly, welcoming atmosphere! I WILL return! Highly recommended!“

“Our family can't thank Pete and his staff enough. With about a week's notice he accommodated us for my Dad's celebration of life lunch/dinner. The food was excellent and he and his staff did everything to ensure we were taken care of.“

“Something about George Webbs is so classic, with a Wisconsin diner atmosphere. It's not exactly cheap, but the experience of sitting in an old-fashioned webbs diner is a part of what you're paying for. Burgers ate uniquely theirs, which is good in their own way.“

“Went to Reunion after a church service with a large group (12ish) to celebrate my friend’s kid’s dedication. We all had the Sunday buffet and there were so many options. There was something for everyone, even the picky kids with us and we all left very full. We also each got game play cards for the arcade upstairs. So fun! Reunion made the experience a day to remember and would definitely go back with a small or large group again! -Mac and cheese with the rib sauce was the best flavor!“

“Our second time in the area and we had to return to the Omega for dinner and breakfast the next morning. Great local eatery with reasonable prices. They close early on a Saturday night (the kitchen shuts down at 8:30 at least what the sign said. We got there at 8:40 so no dinner), which baffles me.“

“Staff was friendly, and the establishment was nice, but the food was a bit pricey for the selections and portion size. Not sure it was worth it. Wings were small, spinach dip was bland and they charge for ranch dip..shouldn't that come with the wings?“

“Excellent service and tremendous portions. My girlfriend had a wonderful plate of scrambled eggs with fantastic sausage and their smashed Yukon taters. I had the Eggs Benedict which could have fed a family of 4 - Although, the ham lunchmeat and untoasted English muffin were a bit off for the price. But, there was A LOT of food!“

“Boulder Junction consistently aims to please with a top-notch dining experience. The combination of quality and quantity makes it the best sit-down spot money can buy. The efficient service ensures a speedy meal without compromising excellence. Topped off with a great, safe location, this place is deserving of healthy financial tips for the fantastic dining experience it provides.“

“The food was fresh and tasted great! However, that wasn't the best part for me. The best part was the outstanding customer service. This seems to be a family owned business and the lady running the place when I stopped through was super nice and tried her absolute best to make sure I had a good experience. At the end, she explained to me that their goal is to cater to the customer's needs and make it feel like home. I'd say the succeeded! I love small family owned businesses like this and will be coming back! :-)“

“My husband I have lived in the area for many years and finally decided to try the Friday fish fry at the hotel restaurant. What an incredible surprise! What were we missing all these years. The food was wonderful with generous portions. But more important, the service and atmosphere were outstanding. Karen and Lawrence were the only ones handling all the dinner guests but you would never know it by their fantastic smiles and attitude. We actually felt like we were at home. Karen and Lawrence made us feel like family and delivered outstanding service despite the amount of customers there were. In fact, many of them were also engaged like it was one big family. I could on and we look forward to our next visit.“