“The pizza is amazing. Delicious wood fired/brick oven pizza. Super fresh ingredients and the best crispy, yet fluffy crust. Order at the counter and you have your pizza very shortly afterwards. Super fast and efficient. We love this gem in Lawrenceville. Kudos to doing pizza very well! We appreciate you and your pleasant staff!“
“The waiter Kevin is wonderful. He is friendly and very respectful. He provides top notch service.The food is always delicious. I like that they have a smaller menu than most Italian restaurants. The Garlic Parm wings are amazing. The pizza is delicious and always fresh. I absolutely recommend this place to anyone.“
“We are picky pizza eaters, and the brick oven/wood fired pizzas here are absolutely ?. Fresh ingredients and unique artisanal meats. The Diavola is one of our faves with the perfect amount of spice. We also love the Caesar salad. Nice friendly neighborhood atmosphere, and a nice local beer selection as well. We can tell they are passionate about their craft and hoping they are around for a long while. Definitely worthy of a trip to Lawrenceville. Thanks, guys!“
“We love Grandma's NY pizza. We're from NJ and transplanted to Georgia. This isthe best pizza that we found in this area. Definitely the closest to NJ/ NY pizza that we have come to love. They have many items on the menu and are rarely disappointed by anything we've gotten there. Love the hot wings, garlic bread, vodka rigatoni, chicken parmesaum and many others. Its the best bang for the buck! We will always come back to Grandma's NY pizza“
“Me and my husband visited first time to this place. We ordered the veg pizza with lots of toppings on it and it was so reasonable than all other pizza stores. The staff was so nice and friendly. Will definitely go there whenever we wanna eat pizza.Vegetarian options: Best place for vegetables pizza lovers.“
“Laid back and chill modern atmosphere. Courteous service with just the right amount of attentiveness. Oh, and the food... it's like the whole point, right? The awesomeness of the pizza (which you have to experience to truly comprehend) is nonchalantly complemented by the atmosphere and music. Cosmo's has this formula dialed in. Need a spot to impress your friends from out of town? You won't be disappointed.“
“Ive ordered here thru Uber eats twice food is soo good and fresh! The Cesar salad was sooo good!! Highly recommended thin crust pizza was perfect too glad to have a decent place for pizza close by. They have deep dish too that looks amazing might be my next order.“
“This spot has great authentic Italian food. They have the best pasta and lasagna in Georgia. And the Chicken picata is also a great must have. I really enjoyed the bread that the staff kept full on our table. The staff makes this place even better. My go to Italian “
“The owners were very nice and welcoming. I needed pizza quickly for an event at Code Ninjas and they were the perfect fit. The children enjoyed the food and I look forward to sharing with more of our parents to visit soon.Vegetarian options: Veggie pizza and sandwiches“
“Placed an order for a large pizza with several toppings, some split half and the garlic knots. The order was wrong on the pizza side and didn't notice until I got home. It was pouring rain and I was just ready to get home after a long day. Called the location to let to let them know the order was wrong for the pizza, the gentleman who answered offered to correct the issue. Super happy with the outcome and customer service from this location. 10/10 Highly recommend this location. We've ordered from here several times and everything turns out amazing! Thank you for taking care of the issue promptly and for being kind!“
“This is hands down my favorite pizza spot since Cooley closed. The service here is horrible. They don't even acknowledge you. They make you wait. While waiting you see your order seating in the warmer. You want this pizza to be hot, fresh out the oven. They need to pay the staff more. The pizza is incredible though. It's hard to stop eating. Do yourself a favor and get the 8 corners vs 12 or look forward to more pounds being added to your weight. Horrible service, excellent pizza, so 4 stars from me. It is expensive though but I'll leave at 4 stars for now. Staff do better. Without customers the employer can't employ. Customers service is everything. We need more of it these days. The customer service needs improvement forsure.“
“I don't know what is or is not authentic NY Pizza, but I presume I will never have the authentic NY pizza experience unless I'm in danger of being mugged on the way to the pizza place and back while wading through throngs of impersonal, angry people against a sound track of blaring horns, the murmur of voices, and cell phone chimes.Inappropriate political commentary aside, this pizza is delicious, without any regard for its similarities to pizza from another region. I'm no connoisseur but I believe the mushrooms are sautéed and the veggies seem fresh. Subjectively, the crust is crispy, thin, and light, the sauce is of the sweet variety, and the meatballs and sausage are more flavorful compared to the more conservative selections used by many pizza places. On the Supreme, I generally could not sense the cheese, which might speak more about me than the pizza, but isolating it reveals a good mozzarella. The pricing of the pies is on par with chain pizza like Dominos and Papa Johns, so, let's say it's average.Any gripes I have are minor matters of preference, so, they do not influence the rating. For example, I prefer doughy garlic knots but these more closely resemble baked bread. Feel free to disregard my tastes based on pizzas I think stand out: I consider Mellow Mushroom to be the very best chain pizza. The BBQ chicken from Papa Johns is a 9/10. My favorite sauce is, somehow, Little Caesars, despite (or maybe because of) the abundance of garlic powder in the recipe.“
“Had a Philly last week and all I can say is that it was the best Philly I had since I moved to Georgia me and my family are from up north and we’ve been looking for pizza and food that reminds us of home needless to say Italian pie has the best pizza slices, Phyllis steaks and overall food 10/10 and the staff was very friendly!“
“We have been wanting to try Gaetano's Kitchen for awhile now and finally had the opportunity. G's didn't disappoint at all. We went with the lasagna, penne catatonic, spaghetti, crab cakes, The Big Paul, shrimp, chicken, and desert. The wife said "Top Notch Cuisine"! I can't argue. If you want great and authentic Italian food to go or delivered to your door, then Gaetano's is a great choice.Would have added pics but it's already half eaten!“
“food is 10/10 and the price is average. the staff is kind and welcoming and the pizza is so so good like litterly everything here is so good it dosnt matter what. the pictures on yelp are not accurate and I don't know why it's a 2.5 rating this is the best pizza I have had.“
“Today was my first time trying this restaurant. I took my first bite and it was so good that I had to stop what I was doing to write a review! This place is awesome! The food was fantastic and the service was excellent; that is a potent combination! I love their selection of Cuban products! Needless to say, I will be back for more!P.S. I saw some reviews complaining about the prices; remember you are paying for quality. Not to sound pretentious, but if you want cheap food then go to a national chain. If you want high quality food made with high quality ingredients then try La Piragua Pizza!“