22 Best Sandwich Shops in Overland Park

“I don’t know who runs this Schlotzsky’s, but they deserve an award. Hands down, this is the best fast food experience I’ve ever had—if you can even call it fast food. Every time I go, it’s consistently great, and the level of attention to detail is honestly ridiculous.

When I walked in, someone literally ran to the register to make sure I was greeted and ready to order. I’ve never seen anything like it. And the organization? Next level. Every condiment packet, every straw, every napkin—perfectly lined up like someone took the time to make sure everything was facing the same way. It’s one of those little things that tells you this place is run by people who actually care.

On top of that, they’ve never messed up my order—not once. The food is always fresh, made exactly how I asked, and just hits the spot every time. The sandwiches are legit, but even beyond that, the whole experience is just smooth. It’s rare to find a place that’s this consistent.

And the cleanliness? Unreal. This place is spotless—not just clean, but sparkling. The tables, floors, drink station—everything looks like it’s been scrubbed down constantly. Add in the fact that everyone working here is genuinely friendly and welcoming, and it just puts the whole experience over the top.

If every restaurant operated like this, the world would be a better place.“

“2 TVs in each corner if you’re a visual person. Great music playing overhead, an overall fantastic atmosphere. My brother and I grab a bite to eat there after hitting the comic shop right next to it. Highly recommend the Turkey Bacon Avocado, meatball sub, or their Philly Cheesesteak.

Vegetarian options: Clear options on the menu

Dietary restrictions: Different breads, wraps, and I believe lettuce can be used as a wrap as well

Parking: Ample parking

Kid-friendliness: Suitable for all ages

Wheelchair accessibility: Very easy for some in a wheel chair; handicap parking as well“

“Had a coupon BOGO for the new store in Glenwood Plaza. Never ate at one. So tried it today. Had the Club Sub & Mikes Famous Philly. Wow...the Club Sub was huge! Very good, freshly sliced ham a& turkey, plenty of bacon. Dressed with lettuce, tomato, mayo, pickles & onions on wheat. Great sandwich! Huge! Great value for the $$$. Will eat that again! The Philly was decent. Ample shaved beef, grilled fresh, along with peppers and onions, and ample white american cheese for a good gooey to it. No added toppings. Had on the rosenary parm bread. Personally, I wish there would have been more peppers & onions on the sandwich. I should have asked for more, but didn't know if there would be an upcharge. Only downside IMO was red onions are better for sandwiches than white onions, and be nice to have a few more options on toppings, like maybe sliced bell peppers, and spinach as an alternative to the shredded lettuce. So, we will be back. Club Sub on my favorites list, but need to try the chicken philly & chicken bacon ranch philly. Got a couple coupons left in the postcard, $2 off order and 25% off order, so will use those. If anyone has an extra postcard mailer and don't like Jersey Mike's, IM me and I'll give you my address ..I'll take those coupons...lol... Overall, very pleased. And my 91 year old mother enjoyed both sammiches also, so that is very good! Try them out...I was very pleased...“

“Joe took care of us today, he was awesome! Extremely patient, very kind, and had great suggestions on what to eat. He was totally right about the burnt end sandwich, btw. I highly recommend it WITH crispy onions. He even brought our food over and made sure we were settled. I love this place, and I definitely give them 5 stars.“

“We recently relocated to Corporate Woods and were pleasantly surprised by this charming cafe! Even if our office wasn't located here, I'd still frequent this spot. Their wraps are simply amazing—you must give them a try. The avocado toast is a standout; it's anything but bland, thanks to the thoughtful toppings and flavorful avocados. Additionally, the Biscuits and Gravy are a hit with everyone in the office.“

“The staff is very friendly here. I highly recommend 😉“

“I’ve been going to Yellow Sub since I was a kid. Planet Sub is a version of that. It’s a memory for me. It’s almost always terrific. We were not as happy with the sub or service at this particular location/visit but we hope it was just a one off bad day. We will give them another try.“

“Fresh subs!! Absolutely loved it. The service is really good as well. Great decor for the Holidays!“

“I never tried this place until now and it was delicious! Great customer service with daily specials that makes it a great experience. Definitely plan to return to try out other menu items. It has a great aftertaste after devouring it. Pretty reasonable prices and great quality.“

“Enjoyed my 1st visit to CBC. The food was very good in a pleasant atmosphere. Will definitely go back.“

“First visit! 5 stars from the time we walked in to the time we left. Great service excellent food!“

“You may think ordering a GIANT might appear you’re a little piggie when it’s January and everyone is into their New Year’s resolutions. If you think you’re being reasonable and order the REGULAR or SMALL, you’re going to regret it and wish you ordered the GIANT! YUM!“

“Sandwich and salads look good and tasty“

“I love their salads. So far I’ve tried the mediterranean and the uptown!“

“Good... Happy place.“

“Much-improved with new ownership!“

“My passion to trade has grew so big , Mrs Debra Gary fx have made my world beautiful for earning $11,570 on my little investment of $1000 , I was always losing on options market .. Ever since I invested with Mrs Debra Gary fx she has helped me made profits with the best strategies, and I fully recommend her to you too so you can also share this great experience with me you can contact her on her email : [email protected] whats-app: +12522852775“

“My Order was delivered in 12 minutes! Wow. Everything was correct. The delivery guy was really nice. �“

“Yes Delicious 😋 in every way“

“Absolutely excellent. Friendly, capable service. Food is five star so far .... I'm eating my way through the menu!“

“Thanks to the servers I only had $10 and my order came out to be $10.91 😢 but the workers said don't worry about it I'll cover the 0.91 cents! I'll come back with a gift one day soon! 😀🤟🏻

Love James McGinnis 🤟🏻“

“TL;DR: Delicious, good portions, great price, and they always get it right!

Full Story: For the history of me ordering takeout, I ALWAYS check the whole order before leaving with my food. I've had to train my friends and family to do this too whenever picking up food for me. I'm not a picky eater, but we all want what we ordered. We've all had countless orders messed up only to find out after we're back home. I still frequent several of my favorite spots that mess up my orders (albeit I catch it in the store before leaving) so it's never a deal-breaker, just a monkey wrench that slows down your plans. With this Jimmy John's location specifically, I've ordered lunch here at least once a week for almost two years now. Even tho they've never messed up my order, I would still always check before tipping/leaving per habit. After about a year of perfect orders, I can say that I no longer check my sandwich before leaving and they still have a perfect track record! This is the only restaurant in the world that I do not have to check the order b/c they ALWAYS GET IT RIGHT! Thank you guys! Keep up the great work! =)“