20 Best American Restaurants in Stillwater

Brick & Bourbon American • $$
215 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Chicken and Bacon Mac & Cheese
Smoking Gun Maple Old Fashioned
Bourbon & Maple Crème Brulee
St Louis Rib Mac & Cheese
Roasted Short Rib Ravioli
New York New York Sliders
Black & Blue Mac & Cheese
Cast Iron Mac & Cheese
Candied Bacon Flight
Three Wiseman Burger

“The food was amazing. Yeti, our server did an excellent job of checking on us and making sure we had everything we needed. I would definitely recommend this place to a friend, the wait wasn't too long even on a busy Saturday at lunch time.“

4.9 Superb609 Reviews
The Main Cafe Cafe • $
108 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Triple Berry French Toast with Scrambled Eggs and Bacon
Country Fried Steak and Eggs Hashbrowns and Pancake
Hamburger and Fries
Blueberry Pancakes
Two French Toast
Farmers Omelet
Eggs Benedict
Hash Browns
Gyro & Fries
Gyro Omelet

“Went for breakfast on March 9th, the atmosphere was great, and the food was AMAZING and tasted so, so good. Overall, we were so happy and satisfied with the more than happy to give this place high reviews. The only negative side to this story was that the waitress who served us did not seem happy that we chose to eat there. She barely greeted us and even asked about the specials. She simply pointed to the whiteboard and told us they were listed on the board and then walked away. When taking out order, she seemed to have an attitude and acted like she did not want to be there. Not one did she come by to check if we needed a refill of coffee or how the meal was. In fact, she did not bother to come by until we flagged down another waitress to get our coffee refill. She did not thank us when we paid for our meal despite getting a $25 tip.Despite all this we would recommend this restaurant for a great atmosphere and wonderful food. We do plan to give this place a second chance on our next trip back.“

4.6 Superb58 Reviews
Leo's Grill & Malt Shop American • $
131 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Cajun Chicken Sandwich
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Sweet Potato Tots
Chocolate Malts
Waffle Fries
Kettle Chips
Onion Rings
Hamburger
Leos Melt
Burger

“I had a Chocolate Malt from Leo's today. I think it was the best chocolate malt I have ever had, and I have had a lot of them. I honestly don't know what was different about it, but it was amazing. I can't wait to go back and have another one. I wish they had a really big one.“

4.6 Superb112 Reviews
Howard's Bar American • $
302 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Burger and Fries
Prime Rib Bennie
Reuben Sandwich
Cheeseburger
Chicken Wings
Cheese Curds
French Toast
Lasagna
Salad

“Our server was perfectly attentive without being overwhelming! Great food. Good drinks. An enjoyable Sunday night for casual dinner and drinks with a friend. The cheese curds are literally the best I've ever had outside of the State Fair.“

4.5 Superb67 Reviews
Domaćin Restaurant & Wine Bar New American • $$$
102 2nd St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Beef Tenderloin Right and Risotto Left
Castelvetrano Olives
Meat and Cheese Plate
Margherita Flatbread
Wine Lovers' Plate
Cheese Board
Beef Tartare
Panna Cotta
Duck Confit
Aleksandar

“I can't say enough about this place. We came here for my birthday dinner on the recommendation of a relative. I made a reservation and we were seated promptly at a cute window table. Our server made great wine recommendations, based on what we planned to order for dinner and her personal favorites. She took into account any budgetary requirements. The wine was absolutely delightful. We ordered charcuterie, which was just the right amount without taking away our appetite for dinner. The pasta dishes are incredible. Our favorite was the orecchiette which had a Bolognese sauce. The desserts were exactly the right size that we could each order our own and were so delicious. We can't wait to come back!“

4.7 Superb69 Reviews
Phil's Tara Hideaway Bar • $$
15021 60th St N, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Brussels Sprouts with Balsamic Reduction
Seared Duck with Potato Gnocchi
Mediterranean Pork Chop
Athenian Potatoes
Fettuccine Alfredo
Grilled Octopus
Greek Platter
Bread Pudding
Fried Walleye
Baked Potato

“We have passed by Phil’s Tara for years, and always said “I really want to try that place”. Well, today we did, and it was simply divine. We don’t get out on date night often, but when we do, we want to try new things; oysters were our first endeavor. Out waiter, Jackson, gave us the entire 4-11 on exactly how to throughly enjoy oysters, and we ordered more after. Jackson truly made our experience one-of-a-kind.We fell in love with Phil’s Tara today, and we will be back again, and again.“

4.5 Superb107 Reviews
LoLo American Kitchen and Craft Bar American • $$
233 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Alderwood Smoked Sea Salt & Rosemary Fries
Korean Fried Chicken Wings
Bacon Wrapped Hot Dogs
Fried Brussels Sprouts
Smoked Sea Salt Fries
Seared Amish Chicken
Triple Pork Tacos
Mahi Fish Tacos
Chicken Tacos
Korean Tacos

“I recently visited for a Saturday lunch, and overall, it was a fantastic experience! Despite being busy, the service was impressively fast, and the staff was incredibly friendly. The only downside was the small interior, which made it a bit loud, especially during peak hours. However, it's perfect for groups of six or under, with an ideal size for 2-4 people. I tried the Lilo burger, which was delicious but quite spicy due to the ghost cheese. My partner opted for the chicken tacos and couldn't stop raving about them. However, the real star of the show was the smoked salt fries - they were absolutely phenomenal! If you're looking for a lively spot for lunch in Stillwater, I highly recommend giving this place a try. It's perfect for a fun day out!“

4.5 Superb103 Reviews
Ziggy's On Main, Live Music, Great Food & Drink Sports Bar • $
132 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Cheese
Cheese Curds

“We had a great experience at Ziggy’s today! Being from out of town, we stopped in for a quick drink and some cheese curds and we weren’t disappointed. The bartender (and possibly manager/owner?), Steve, took great care of us and showed real midwestern hospitality. Do yourself a favor and try the cheese curds with blackberry ketchup—they are divine!“

4.5 Superb48 Reviews
Matchstick Restaurant & Spirits American • $$
232 N, 232 Main St N, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Caramelized Brussel Sprouts
Smoked Chicken Wings
Cauliflower Fritters
Sea Bass Fish Tacos
Wood Fired Carrots
Pave Potatoes
Sea Scallops
French Fries
Steak Tartare
Wedge Salad

“Matchstick has become my "go-to" place whenever friends or family come to visit (or if I just want an amazing meal). Their menu is truly impressive. It has become hard to choose a favorite dish because I have truly enjoyed everything I have tried so far. The service is really out of this world awesome. Their menu has something for everyone so you really can't go wrong if you are trying to impress someone and make them happy. Matchstick is really special!!!“

4.4 Superb74 Reviews
Meister's Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
901 4th St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Fries and Mushroompuffs
French Fries Half Order
Basket of Fries
Miester Burger
Steak Sandwich
Cheeseburger
Onion Rings
Polish Dog
Chili Dogs
Hamburger

“This is my favorite neighborhood bar! I've been going to this bar for the last 25 years. I meet 3 old friends and we caught up on each other. In this bar you don't need to talk loud over the music. In this bar you don't have to worry about having trouble with anyone. In this bar you're getting good beer in a frosty mug. The Meister Burger is the absolute bomb!“

4.4 Superb55 Reviews
Mad Capper Saloon & Eatery American • $$
224 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Parmesan Truffle Fries
Ricotta Bruschetta
Southwest Salad
Benedict Burger
Italian Nachos
Fish and Chips
Chicken Wings
Cowboy Burger
Garganelli
Gnocchi

“Stillwater has somehow kept this place a secret from Wisconsin people. Or maybe it's the wonderful new-ish bridge diverting traffic from historic downtown that made us miss it..... Regardless Wow! If you haven't you have to, if You've heard, then you know, and if you don't wanna know then you just plained missed out, on the second ? most stunning experience I've ever had at a restaurant. Don't treat this place as a bar restaurant it's not even in the same breath. Long winded I apologize, for starters The lovely waitress offers us warm sugar donuts just as a treat. Spectacular idea. Then we indulged into this heavenly plate of Parmesan fries. I could have just had those and been happy. I had the capper burger. Perfectly cooked wonderfully done personally I'd 86 the ciabata bun for a pretzel bun or traditional bun but it didn't downgrade it at all. my wife had the carbonara... that may have edged out The Post American Eatery .. maybe. It was bursting with flavor absolutely a masterpiece. We ended with some delightful key lime pie. Perfect service perfect food perfect atmosphere. All at 4:00 on a Monday. Standards set high bar none. Mic drop Mad capper. Well done Chef well done all. I'll be back and this time I'll charge my phone one more time Chef well down ?“

4.3 Superb87 Reviews
Sal's Angus Grill Bar & Grill • $$
12010 Keystone Ave N, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Petite Medallions with Baked Potato and Green Beans
Kids Chicken Strips with Fries and a Treat
Chicken Fettuccine with Bread Stick
Prime Rib Loaded Baked Potato
Bacon Cheese Burger and Fries
Bacon Cheeseburger with Fries
Sweet and Sour Chicken Wings
Sal's Spaghetti & Meatballs
Salmon with Mashed Potatoes
Stuffed Chicken Breast

“Have the bull bite appetizer it was amazing. I had the Prime rib med rare. It was Perfectly cooked. The green beans were yummy. My husband had the 5 piece fish fry. He said it was very good. It was busy. We made reservations. Celebrated a friend's birthday thier chocolate cake came with sparklers and a cow bell. Fun and delicious. So good!“

4.3 Superb64 Reviews

13
Feller

Feller American • $$
402 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Foragers Crostini
Walleye Fritters
Brussels Sprouts
Feller Burger
Smoked Wings
Bison Steak
The Feller
Stillwater

“Ok, so... Feller is the restaurant, Made Coffee is the coffee ☕️ shop, the Long Goodbye is the bar, and Lora is the hotel. We weren't quite sure at first, so sharing what we learned. The food at Feller was pretty exceptional on our first visit. Wife had the stuffed pheasant, and I had a Nicoise salad after we shared a Foragers Crostini (which was so good). I expect to return to try more dishes, and I'll post more if that happens.And we did return. More food photos added.“

4.1 Good64 Reviews
The Tilted Tiki Tropical Bar & Restaurant Cocktail Bar • $$
324 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Tropical Pineapple Beyond Burger
Tropical Pineapple Cheeseburger
Friki Tiki Cheese Curds
Coconut Shrimp Tacos
Kahuru Coconut Shrimp
Pineapple Fried Rice
Tilted Spam Sliders
Fish Bowl Bloody
Volcano Bowl
Pulled Pork

“The waitress was very friendly and remembered all of our orders(table of 7) and everything was correct when it arrived. Everyone tried a different menu item and all were good. Drinks were decent, opt for the stronger ones. I think the meal portions could be bigger or have sides with them, I was still a little hungry after. They do live music during the week. I think it would be a fun place to go back to and listen to the music. Give them a try, as good as other restaurants in stillwater I tried.“

4.1 Good68 Reviews
Cozzie's Tavern & Grill Bar • $$
11154 60th St N, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Loaded Brussels Sprouts
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Wings 12 Piece
Classic Patty Melt
Apple Walnut Salad
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pot Roast Sliders
Burgers and Fries
Chicken Pot Pie
Walleye Fingers

“Excellent food, service and atmosphere.Laelle our server was prompt, efficient and friendly. She was taking care of several tables, doing a top notch job. We had walleye sliders, fried perfectly topped with a slaw. Poutine was super cheesy goodness. The wild rice soup soooo good. The cheeseburger flat bread was spot on. Definitely worth a stop.Kid-friendliness: The kids loved eating out on the patio“

4.1 Good71 Reviews
Joseph's Family Restaurant Family • $
14608 60th St N, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Beer Batter Walleye Sandwich
All American Egg Breakfast
Quarter Pound Hamburger
Buttermilk Pancakes
Reuben Sandwich
Broasted Chicken
Rhubarb Delight
Steak and Eggs
Cheese Curds
French Toast

“It's still a great restaurant, maybe even better after the change in ownership!I really appreciate the update to the look of their menu. Don't worry, they still have the same great breakfast selection and burger selection!Friendly staff (no complaints), decent food, and I've rarely ever had to wait to be seated. There is a bar, but it has never posed an obstacle for one of their main goals of being family friendly.There is a smaller parking lot that is typically full during meal times. I've only had an issue finding a spot twice in the 8+ years I've been going here.There is handicap parking. The doors do not have a handicap accessibility button, they are pull only doors. The environment is typically not loud or distracting. It is a great local restaurant.I would recommend all-American breakfast, waffles, pancakes, their cheese curds, and the build your own burger. They make great pies, my personal favorites are the cherry and the French silk pies.“

4 Good97 Reviews
Brian's Bar & Grill Bar • $
219 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Double Half Pound Burger
Stillwater Burger
Boneless Wings
Cheeseburger
Tater Tots

“General really busy on the weekend but have enjoyed the drinks, food and service here. Boneless wings are excellent and they allow my clean and clipped, well behaved Poodle to be with me. That a huge benefit as I don't understand why many don't.“

3.8 Good59 Reviews
Perkins Restaurant & Bakery Bakery • $
2050 W Frontage Rd, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Country Fried Steak
Garden Salad
Onion Rings
French Toast
Hash Browns
Blueberry

“Close to many hotels in the Stillwater, MN Frontage road area. We got to the restaurant at 5:30 pm on a Friday evening. There was a bit of a wait for a table and order prep from the kitchen but the food quality and kind service made up for it. Plus, at Perkins you know the desserts are always great.“

3.8 Good68 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
1725 Market Dr, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Swiss Burger
Double Cheeseburger
Hot Fudge
Baskets

“We had lunch. My favorite is the home chicken bacon cranberry blue cheese salad. My wife's favorite is the chicken cashew saladKid-friendliness: Kid friendly with children's meals that include a main item, soft drink, fries and a small dish or cone of ice creamWheelchair accessibility: Wheel chair accessible“

3.7 Good55 Reviews
Freight House American • $$
305 Water St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

The Freight House Cheeseburger
Freight House Burger
Pulled Chicken Nachos
Walleye Sandwich
Giant Pretzel
Cheese Curds
Street Tacos
Fish & Chips
French Fries
Hamburger

“Overall an amazing experience! Our waiter was so polite, friendly, and down to earth. We had the DF walleye & salmon. Both entrees were super delicious! Be sure to note that you need to enter on the south side of the building during the winter.“

3.6 Good76 Reviews
Loading...
map Map