Restaurants in Millburn

“Came here at 4pm. Just us but we were impressed by kind service and delicious summer roles and phos. Recommend special beef pho without onions (not a fan of onions).”

“Oh my goodness! The food here... AMAZING! The drinks... AMAZING!!! TOP NOTCH SERVICE!!! You will definitely enjoy a date, single night out, or hanging with friends here. Plan a lunch, dinner or whatever here but def GET THERE!”

“The service and atmosphere were excellent and the food was very good. The scallop and octopus appetizers were excellent. Duck entree was well above average. The bread pudding for dessert was also delicious. Would highly recommend this restaurant.”

“The Carriage House Restaurant is literally steps from the PaperMill Playhouse. Great to stop in prior to a performance. The atmosphere is best described as "cozy and rustic". I've stopped in about 2-3 times for drinks and appetizers. The food has always been very tasty. Little on the pricey side. On a positive note, you're only a few steps away from the theater. As of now, I've had Chicken Sausage Appetizers and a Steak Quesadilla. Nice wine and cocktail list. We've enjoyed their wine and cocktails on a previous visit. In December '23, I had an issue making reservations. Left two telephone messages and never received a call back. I couldn't even make a reservation on Opentable or Resy. We stopped in and informed the hostess of the issue. Anyway, we ended up eating at the bar. The Carriage House Restaurant does offer Cabaret and Murder Mystery shows.”

“Cute place! First time eating at the restaurant. Loved that the noodles a little thicker and chewier than regular ramen. Has a home made taste. Definitely will come back again.”

“I have been getting Vinnie’s for 2.5 years now and I finally decided it was time for a review. Let me tell you that this is one of the most delicious pizzas I’ve ever had, and definitely the best in the area.The way they make their delicious pies is simply genius- the crust is made of crispy cheese rather than regular dough. The dough itself is so perfectly thin and crisp. Typically, I am a toppings girly; I love me some toppings. But here, I don’t need any toppings- plain pie is perfect as is.Also of note is their Caesar salad. The croutons are so good and garlicky, always fresh lettuce and shredded parm. 10/10The staff is very friendly and are always quick with orders even on busy nights. Can’t recommend enough.”

“Everything was delicious!!!The garlic Brad sooooo good that I had two pieces even though I knew I had a big meal coming.We polished off our entrees.We definitely are coming back when the weather lets us eat outside.”

“Happened to discover this Gem and it was one of the best meals I have had in a long time. Great selection, super fresh ingredients, and an outstanding staff. All I can say is WOW. I will be back over and over again.”

“Great food! Great ambience and vibe! Highly recommend! One tiny note to the management: we got a table next to the door and everytime the door opened and closed, it felt like a tiny earthquake.”

“This place is a total gem! Food is excellent. And, the best of all, Larry the dining room waiter is better than excellent. He has mastered the art of serving. He does not just serve his customers he conducts a symphony of service. Everything is carefully choreographed to the liking of each table. Absolutely the best of the best old school ristorante. Cannot wait for our next visit!”

“I’ve walked past this on Main Street so many times and am glad we finally came to eat! Such a cute space. The staff were very friendly and the food was super fresh.”

“The service provided by the waiter was outstanding. He was attentive, friendly, and ensured that every aspect of our dining experience was enjoyable.As for the food, it was absolutely delicious. I had the pleasure of trying the Greek salad, grilled octopus, and grilled shrimp, and each dish was prepared to perfection. The flavor was authentic and left a lasting impression on my taste buds.I definitely recommend this restaurant to my friends and family .”

“I used to love this place. I wonder if they’re still opened. I went on a Sunday afternoon. Sign on door said closed. Two weeks later I called on a Saturday because I didn’t want to take the drive to find out they’re closed. No answer at all. I called several times. If you’re still opened please get it together. I miss this place.Update: ok I gave it another try. They were open and I had the best vegan broth. Now the immunity is my second favorite. Thanks for getting it together ???”

“We came in and the kitchen had just closed. The server ran back and they reopened just for the 4 of us. Also, Crystal and Olivia recommended appetizers and they were delicious. They were very personable and a pleasure to talk to. This spot was a great find for our last minute stop at 9:30pm. Great place to go - we will be back again .”

“My daughter ordered from Millburn Poke Bowl today for delivery. The food arrived quickly. I had the sushi burrito....what great value for the money. The presentation is attractive; the burrito was packed in a lidded box that almost looked like a gift. It was packed full of vegetables and rice with very generous amounts of spicy and ahi tuna. They added just the right amount of dressing/sauce. I ate half for lunch and half for dinner. I would highly recommend Millburn Poke Bowl if you want delicious, fresh ingredients and a very generous amount of them.”