50 Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn

“repas poisson excellent et canolli extra“

“Food is yummy! My go to place in Brooklyn! Coda is excellent and the flatbread are also yummy! The Sangiovese red wine on tap is also nice! Highly recommend and make reservations in the weekend“

“I'd had this place on my list for a long time and finally got the chance to visit! I was not disappointed. We were seated on the outdoor terrace (which was pretty loud and cold, because of the AC). Volume aside, the food was amazing! Standouts: the tiramisu and corn pasta. A great neighbourhood spot, though a little pricey!“

“Came to a wedding and the food is absolutely phenomenal!“

“Great food, warm and welcoming staff.“

“It was my third time coming here. This time we brought some of our friends and did the prixe fixe option and got to sample everything. My favorite was the monkey bread! But my friends were ranting and raving about the lemon pasta. I love that nearly the whole staff cycled through and came by our table. They were so kind and friendly, and the owner is just such a warm fun/funny guy. He gave me an extra serving of the monkey bread after I told him how much I loved it.“

“The food was great start to finish.
The cocktail I tried was also on point.
They didn't rush us at all.

But:
It was very loud.
Our two top menu choices were both out.
Service was a little off.

Maybe Sunday evening's aren't their best time?“

“My colleague and I were in Brooklyn for a work trip and decided to try Al di Là Trattoria, and what a gem it turned out to be! We opted to dine at their wine bar, conveniently located right around the corner on Carroll Street, and it was the perfect selection.

The atmosphere was welcoming, and the service was impeccable. Our bartender was the definition of professional, attentive. As for the food, the meal was absolutely delicious.

This is a must-visit spot in Carroll Gardens. We highly recommend it and will definitely be back next time we are in the area. A 5-star place for sure!“

“Fun indoor/outdoor dining environment and delicious food make for a nice night out!“

“Finally scored a Resy Notify for this reservation and it was well worth it! We got a reservation around 5 or 5:30 I wanna say and within minutes of us getting there, the restaurant went from empty to bustling and packed in what felt like a manner of minutes! The restaurant itself is beautiful and the large windows allow for wonderful lighting - first, for happiness and second, for the Gram. We tried a bunch of different things that were all delicious. What really struck me was how simple these dishes were yet packed with a delightful combination of flavors. Of all that we tried, would highly recommend the whipped ricotta, mezze rigatoni, and ricotta- filled occhi. I came here a few months ago and cannot recall the gelato flavors but we tried all three and were not disappointed in the least. I hope to come back here soon!!“

“cameriera italiana con capelli corti. scortese e molto maleducata. non tornerò piu. non ha saputo ne servire il cliente oltre al fatto che dovrebbe farsi un corso di corretto italiano prima di parlare con un cliente in quel modo. pessima pubblicità al locale. peccato e mi dispiace ma non tornerò più.“

“What a great place !! Cozzy spot for the family great ambience and vibe of the place. The food is just authentic and best in the city. These guys deserve to be in the manhattan city. Sara, Alexzander and the third guy are the best people and are great with their guest.“

“I just love this place... !“

“Step into Bamonte’s and you’re stepping into a time capsule, old-school Italian charm where everyone seems to be part of the same famiglia. Servers in suits, voices raised over clinking glasses, and that cozy chaos you expect from a real-deal Italian joint. Food? Solid tasty and comforting, but not exactly life-changing. Not ideal for a whispery date night, unless you’re into yelling “pass the bread!” over Sinatra. Still, it’s a Brooklyn icon. Mangia!“

“I hosted a birthday party in Rosticceria Evelina's semi private room for 11 people and it was absolutely perfect. They provide a very reasonable, flat, per person rate for a prix fix menu (many places have a very high spend minimum) and they created a personalized menu card for our event which was a lovely, personalized touch.

The food is amazing - one dish was better than the last. They accommodated for allergies and allowed me to make a last minute change.

I can't recommend it enough“

“No indoor dining because Covid They have taken great care of making a lot of available tables and even have some enclosed outdoor booths. The use of space is pretty amazing and well adapted to the neighborhood They neighborhood is great I saw the prettiest dogs in Brooklyn all walking in full force The place has a friendly family-type vibe Th coworkers are all friendly with each other and warm to their clientele The food is impeccably well prepared, tasty and quite authentically Italian I doubt one could find anything more authentic with such fine ingredients and creatively presented anywhere other than Italy. If you do, let it be known and I’m sure the staff here would feel the kindred spirit of another fine cuisine It’s in the medium-high priced category but it lives up to the prices in its quality Wait staff is genuine and kind and do make a great effort to make one comfortable and enjoy their meal Highly recommend“

“The atmosphere and service were outstanding. We only went for desert and coffee. The chocolate cake was amazing. A couple we vacationed with has eaten dinner there 2 nights before and said how amazing the food was. One of the staff members even gave us a personal tour and history of the building. Will be back to Brooklyn and will definitely come back.“

“The food was amazing! OSTERIA did not disappoint! The way Italian food I’ve ever had! I will definitely come back! As an influencer I hope to influence my audience to try authentic Italian food! The cocktails and desert were so good! A 10/10 what an experience!“

“On my visit to NY, I went to Brooklyn and discovered Bar Mario, a bar that has all the magic you're looking for, with excellent service down to the last detail. It offers a variety of drinks and delicious prepared dishes. The menu is incredible, I highly recommend it.
I will definitely be back
Thank you so much!!“

“Posto gradevole e accogliente, personale attento,premuroso,gentile, cordiale. Il top 🔝 Si mangia benissimo lo consiglio vivamente!!“

“Absolutely delicious food and a great menu! We will definitely return!“

“Barbalu offers great dishes served impressively fast. I’ve tried many of their saucy pasta plates and Italian wines, and I’ve loved every single one. The service — as you can tell — is quick, and the place is almost always packed.

I definitely recommend making a reservation ahead of time to secure a good spot and enjoy the experience without the wait!“

“everything. food is delicious!“

“THE best Italian cuisine in NYC. Period. Bring the crew and make sure to order the butternut squash tortelli and bottle of Lambrusco.“

“I find value in both the meals and the area. I found myself impressed by the restaurant's look. Staff members provide impeccable attention with remarkable dishes. Their staff attitudes are consistently positive. The staff shows care, the restaurant is well-kept and I want to visit again.“

“best goddamn eggplant parm sandwich I’ve ever had they also carry canned DOP San Marzanos and jarred Calabrian chilis; if you know you know“

“I recommend the restaurant“

“Food, drinks, and atmosphere are excellent!!“

“Romans is an absolutely phenomenal restaurant in the heart of Fort Greene. Emily and Fernando hosted us for an exceptional meal and evening. The menu is inventive and changes regularly. The execution with the fresh ingredients on Roman flavors can stand up to any restaurant in the city.“

“Food first! Atmosphere quaint, Staff friendly, Owner was wonderful Spent time with Us & felt his ❤️ for his Flora. Highly recommended 👏“

“Food is amaziing!!! Service is great and friendly. Try it out you will not be disappointed!!👍“

“Siamo stati lì circa 10 giorni fa, é stata una bellissima esperienza mangiare un piatto tipico Barese, i panzeortti, dall'altra parte del mondo. Sento di mettere 5 stelle sia per il cibo, per la location ma soprattutto per Pasquale e Vittoria (mia compaesana Bitontina) che hanno accolto me e la mia famiglia facendoci sentire a casa. Torneremo sicuramente a trovarvi. Complementi ancora. Un saluto da Bitonto“

“The food was great. The french toast and gnocchi cacio e pepe were magical. What really stood out was the service- everyone was so attentive, and I never had to wait for anything I wanted or needed. Everyone working Sunday brunch yesterday deserves a bonus!“

“This restaurant was very busy but enchanting! I had the Piatta del Buon Ricordo and got a special plate which I will cherish! The food and wine were delicious and the staff was friendly and welcoming! This is the perfect place if you're looking for a special and unique experience!“

“Experimentar o Amaro é uma experiência divertida!“

“Definitely recommend their octopus appetizer, steak, and truffle mushroom pasta! The staff is great & service is as well. Not very loud and very cozy atmosphere. Great for dates or group dinners! Extensive spritz room, we loved! I recommend the bergamotto spritz“

“Walked in on a Friday & joined the wait list. Definitely waited much longer than we were quoted. However, the food made up for it. Everything we had was delicious and fresh. Chef choice of meat, cheese & veg was creative and balanced. I also especially enjoyed the lumache pasta!“

“Exciting news… Felice is now open for lunch Tuesday through Friday. Filice is our place to go for intimate, dinners, family, celebrations, and connecting with friends. They serve totally delicious food beautifully presented. They have amazing staff that goes the extra mile. They have charming ambience making it our favorite restaurant. All this and now they are open for lunch.“

“Wonderful place! Food and service were exceptional! Great appetizers and entrees. A must try restaurant if you are in NYC Area!“

“Lovely atmosphere. The food was super tasty, fresh, and authentic. Staff was friendly and wonderful, and cocktails were top tier.(Loved the Terina Basil) From the food to the warm hospitality and the elegant designs. What really makes this elegant restaurant out is the service, and the owners/management came over to our table and introduced themselves and made us all feel welcomed. I will definitely be returning!“

“I have enjoyed eating at Aurora many times since 2010 with my wife, friends and family.The food and service is always consistently good. But when I went this week, I found myself disappointed that they did not serve bread. The waiter told be they do not do it anymore with no explanation. It may be a small thing, but it was significant for me.“

“The idiosyncrasies of the seasonings are amazing in each dish.“

“Food is awesome staff great neighborhood awesome“

“food was great and so was the service!“

“I recommend everything! This place is a much needed gem to the neighborhood! Friendly and sincere owners, great service, amazing cuisine, pleasant and inviting atmosphere and chic decor. It really has it all!!!“

“When I lived In Brooklyn, I was a regular for years. I came back last night and the food and service from Viktor the owner was as usual...extraordinary ✨ An absolute must place to dine when you're in the Carrol Gardens area of Brooklyn!“

“Like the latest review, I also made a reservation but when I arrived, Marie’s was completely shuttered.

I checked their Instagram, and it turns out they’re closed indefinitely ❗️Doesn’t seem like they’ve updated their Google info yet, but I’ve attached a screenshot of their latest IG post!“

“I was there with my colleagues Monday, November 10. We were at the nearby Signal Awards where our podcast received a Bronze prize for our podcast about Italian food, “I Wish I Were a Prosciutto.” We were hungry and looking for something with prosciutto. We had your most delicious pizza with prosciutto and arugula. The crust was Neapolitan perfection and the toppings were bursting with flavor. We were also impressed with the good-as-Nona’s meatballs. The service was outstanding and we appreciated meeting Gloria de la Rosa. You made our special night more special. We live in Connecticut, but we would come back again when we are in Brooklyn, tell our NYC friends about your place, and talk about it on our podcast. We wish you continued success! Thank you so much.“

“This was a really lovely gem. The food is great, with every dish bringing that very unique comfort that Italian food masters. The drinks are well-balanced and strong, would especially recommend sampling the negronis. The service is personable, attentive, and really ensures that you want to come back - and bring your friends and family. An all around lovely spot in Bed-Stuy.“