What are you looking for?

Italian Restaurants in New York

4.7 - 567 votes

Hours: 5 - 10PM

165 Duane St, New York
(212) 528-0400

Papa Johns Pizza

Dated place. Food was good. Charged us a lot for water even though we asked for tap water. More reviews

4.7 - 564 votes

Hours: 4:30 - 9:45PM

501 W 51st St, New York
(212) 757-9290

Papa Johns Pizza

Such a great dinner in this quaint little neighborhood restaurant!! Very friendly staff and great service. Will return ASAP! More reviews



4.7 - 527 votes

Hours: 5 - 10PM

126 E 7th St, New York
(212) 673-7200

Papa Johns Pizza

We had a terrible experience with both service and food. Service was rushed and they seemed overwhelmed when asked any questions. They food was poorly pr... More reviews

4.6 - 1127 votes

Hours: 11:30AM - 11PM

147 W 43rd St, New York
(212) 221-0100

Papa Johns Pizza

Excellent Wonderful Good service Great place to eat so delicious food In love this place! More reviews

4.8 - 321 votes

Hours: 12 - 10:30PM

227 Malcolm X Blvd, New York
(646) 928-4870

Papa Johns Pizza

Met friends here for dinner one night and everyone loved it. My only complaint is that they were out of the burrata when we tried to order it around 7:30... More reviews

4.7 - 467 votes

Hours: 11:30AM - 10PM

22 E 49th St, New York
(212) 838-5972

Papa Johns Pizza

The gnocchi was amazing. Just do it. The salads were ok. Great wine list-the list is up beside the bar and not in the menu. We had some mistakes on our t... More reviews

4.8 - 301 votes

Hours: 11AM - 6PM

97 Nassau St, New York
(212) 227-3104

Papa Johns Pizza

Cash only. Solid $20 sandwich that will last you at least 2 meals.Got the flagship #26 Pisillo for lunch. Had a lot of great flavor variety and really le... More reviews

4.6 - 755 votes

Hours: 11:30AM - 11PM

106 E 60th St, New York
(646) 707-3997

Papa Johns Pizza

The decor, ambience and menu were very great. I would not ever think saying that one day but the service was too fast and ruined our dinner. We ordered p... More reviews

4.6 - 615 votes

Hours: 12 - 11PM

146 W Houston St, New York
(212) 533-1242

Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza is always amazing The service level went down a lot, trying to kick you out when you are still eating the last peace of pizza. Take your pizza and ... More reviews

4.6 - 536 votes

Hours: 5 - 10PM

507 9th Ave, New York
(212) 244-0088

Papa Johns Pizza

Great meal and service. We were on a tight timeline to make it to a play and the staff made sure we were able to get out the door quickly. Greatly apprec... More reviews

View on map