20 Best Italian Restaurants near Gardiner

“Lombardis is our "go to" for takeout Lasagna meals. Salad is simple but delicious. Lasagna homemade thin layers not overpowered by cheese, sauce is absolutely delicious and plentiful.Homemade bread is amazing!The best authentic homemade Italian food in the New Paltz/Gardiner area!You will not be sorry. Try them!“

“Pasquale's in Gardiner has been our go to pizza joint for years. Sadly, the manager who brought life to the place ( Chris) is no longer there. It has been awhile since he left, but the difference in the atmosphere is still palpable. The wait staff are wonderful, however, Chris used to make the rounds of the dining room , greeting customers, joking etc. After all this time, I'm still not sure who is in charge when the owner isn't present. ( an owner who has never acknowledged our existence btw). The music is played so loudly at times I can not hear what we are talking about. So the negative aside, the pizza is wonderful. Consistent, hot, crispy. The menu is varied with something for everyone. The garlic knots are large , really garlicky, soft and delicious. Service is fast as is the kitchen. No complaints there. I will say with the loud music and how cold they keep the dining room , we don't go as often, but I do recommend it.“

“The reviews on yelp for APIZZA are mixed and the bad ones seem to be mostly about price. Sure it's a little pricey but not really, and they give you a giant pizza which doesn't suck. I really liked their pizza and so did my family which includes some smallish kids. We also ordered meatballs which were solid, and a house salad which was also very good. I was greeted by someone in the pizza oven area as well as the front counter and everyone was happy and nice. I waited for my to go food and had the Italian margarita while checking out the action in the kitchen. Omg, that drink was so delicious, and to top it off the pizza chef throws every dough in the air! Mama Mia!“

“What an exceptional place .Roland and his staff , which includes family members have struck a perfect balance at this restaurant.Aesthetically, inside the restaurant it is just beautiful. It’s very upscale and almost feels elegant without being overwhelming. The food preparation and presentation is beautiful and well done. Food choices are interesting and varied and the food is excellent. You feel like you’re in some elegant upscale restaurant, but the feel from the waiters and the staff is very welcoming and warm and friendly. Nobody is stuffy or arrogant or pretentious. They are very accommodating and if you have any dietary restrictions they’re also pleasant about any accommodations. They always have great specials each week.This is such a wonderful place to have a nice cozy dinner or to have a family get together. It just always feels good when we come here. I can’t recommend this restaurant enough.“

“It is one of our favorite hangouts in the Hudson Valley. It has a great vibe, great food, great ambience, both in the winter and the summer time. Service is good and the food is very comfort food that makes you feel you are eating at home. The pizza is Roman style so thinner than most and very tasty. A great spot close to Kingston and the Mohonk preserve“

“The food here is amazing! This is not just a pizza place. I had the Sir Duke sandwich and it was so good...and not on an average boring roll. My daughter's LOVE the pizza and they have a drive through window! I always ask for a slice of the stuffed meat pie. You should go inside because you will see a bunch of things not on the menu and they are delicious too!“

“We ordered a large sausage & pepper pizza and it was DELICIOUS!! VERY fresh. The sauce tasted homemade, sweet sausage slices and tender, crisp green peppers with a crunchy but not over baked crust. BEST pizza we’ve had in a long, long time! Arrived really quickly and was still quite hot. We highly recommend RINO’S!!“

“This place is open late, isn’t expensive, and is absolutely delicious. The staff is friendly, there’s a bunch of space to sit, and they completed our pick up order in 10 minutes. I have NEVER called a pizza place and been told the wait was only 10 minutes. For sure is one of the top places in new paltz for pizza. They even let you get single garlic knots, and don’t make you order them in sets, which is dope. My only complaint is that the garlic knots are literally just little rolls covered in raw garlic- im talking COVERED in raw garlic. As a garlic lover, it was even too much for me. Did I eat them all? Yes. But only after I scraped it off.“

“Went on a very cold day and had a great time. The food, music, and atmosphere were amazing. They have wine and Grappa +. Fav was the seycal blanc / lemon grappa / flatbread / mussels. I am looking forward to another teip when I can enjoy the outside fire pits and grounds“

“The food is very good. The service has generally been EXCELLENT. Some of the hostesses have really gone above and beyond. Most of the wait staff is great too.I love watching the sky drivers come in-can't wait for warmer weather to sit outside and enjoy that. There are not many places in this area I'm excited to share with visitors. This is one.“

“I am a retired law enforcement, I have eaten all over the state, for an Italian pizza place, Franko’s is one of the best Italian food pizza/ restaurant I have eaten in.. great pie to, and they load up the wedges.. respectively RG“

“We eat here often and do take out . Never had any issues. Recently catered a celebration for our family … 60 plus people and it was quite a large order the food was delivered on time hot and delicious. Super happy with their help it was a bit last minute and they accommodated our giant order . Very appreciated .“

“This is my 4-5th time here in the last few years. Always a solid choice. Food is always good and service is usually on par. Ambiance is quiet and tranquil. Really can't ask for much more. Prices are regular Italian establishment type. Pizza is decent nice crust, good sauce, and toppings are fresh. Bread is crispy and warm. Pasta fagoli is good, Italian wedding is amazing, and the tortellini en brodo is klller! Deserts haven't partaken...can't seem to get there.“

“Highly variable quality. We are local and order takeout here several times a month. The pizza quality varies. On a good day, the pizza is fantastic. Other times the pizza is just ok. Stromboli are always excellent, so sometimes we just order those to avoid risking getting an ok pizza. The salads range from great to fair. Most times the greens are very fresh and dry, other times the salads are soggy and slimy. Lately, salads have been more consistently good. Sometimes the person answering the phone is courteous and responsive. Other times they respond in only one syllable words or incomprehensible grunts. Most times I get home to discover my order was filled correctly. Occasionally my order is incorrect, perhaps as a result of variable phone responsiveness/miscommunication. Wings are always great...really great! When ordering fresh, I expect fresh made food and I don’t mind waiting, but the sliders taste like they sat out for a loooong time. Dry, lack flavor, and unsatisfying. I imagine freshly made sliders are excellent.I like Pasquales and will continue to patronize...because Lillos in Walden is no longer an option. Keep up the good work P...Note: Ca$h only.“

“Unsung hero's, total gems and neighbors whose catered food tastes like it was made in the kitchen of someone who loves you. Dependably kind and amazing for all occasions. Today's family milestone begins with Chicken Marsala, magnificent. Thanks Russo's, you rock!!“

“Not only are they the best pizza in town, but they're also the classiest guys. They were able to help us out in a pinch when my payment wasn't going through and let us come back to pay it the next day. They're real stand-up folks and people like them keep the world turning. They've earned my loyalty.“

“We had never heard of Paesanos until we moved to Modena. We were happy to find out that the pizza is great, garlic knots are the best, extra crispy wings are amazing and the subs are delicious. Also prices are very reasonable. Only complaint is that they only deliver for cash.“

“Have had excellent pizza here in past. Garlic knots aa good as you can get. But a real pleasant surprise was i asked if they have any sauce they sell. I took out an order of bolognese sauce. Home made and Incredibly delicious! Love the Sicilian and grandma slices. (And the beautiful owner should be in movies).“

“Always the best pizza in New Paltz but also great burgers, amazing Italian dishes, tasty desserts. LaBella is great for family dinner or date night.Dietary restrictions: Delicious gluten free pizzaParking: Handicapped spaces and curb cuts for access“

“The food is always good, and the staff is friendly and helpful. Lots of choices for pizza, it's hard to choose! They all look so good! The chicken soft tacos are excellent! Already place to go with the kids after a practice or game!Kid-friendliness: Good meal optionsParking: Always plenty of parking!“