18 Best American Restaurants in New Paltz

Frank’s Fresh Pickling Co. Deli • $
56 Main St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Fresk Mozzarella Pezzi
Chicken Dijianaisse
Steelhouse Salad
Italian Combo
Roasted Reds
Bistro Wrap
Turkey

“If you are looking for a Great sandwich for a more then reasonable price, you have found your place. The sandwich selection is full of great options, and you won't be disappointed. The Cuban has been my go-to for a quick weekend lunch option. The staff is attentive and friendly, and one gentlemen calls me young man, even though I am sure that I am older then him which leads me to an extensional crisis while I eat my Cuban. I hope that this joint can survive in our sweet little town full of Teeny boppers and hopeless hipsters. Do yourself a favor and grab a sandwich from this place before our only option is a mutant meat sandwich from Amazon grown in a laboratory for 2$ a month for eternity.“

4.8 Superb61 Reviews
Novella’s New Paltz American • $$
2 Terwilliger Ln, New Paltz

“Love working with Bryce & his dedicated team during special events! I am a professional photographer and every time I’ve worked at Novellas I’ve been nothing but comfortable, excited, and warmly welcomed by all staff!Everyone is dedicated to make operations run smoothly and Bryce is fantastic to coordinate with. Every time I have concerns about lighting or need updates throughout the night, Bryce always has an answer, a solution, a smile on his face. Thank you for creating a great environment for both guests & vendors. We appreciate all your hard work together at Novellas! Can’t wait for more events together in the future.“

5 Superb28 Reviews
B-Side Grill American • $
62 Main St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Double Cheeseburger with B
Hotel California Burger
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Stuffed French Toast
Chili Cheese Fries
Cinnamon Pancakes
Chicken Sandwich
Corned Beef Hash
Overloaded Fries
Fried Pickles

“It does not look as cool on the outside as it actually is on the inside. Highly recommend.Atmosphere: the ceiling is covered in records, and the walls are covered in music posters and guitarsVibe: while you wait for your food, a magician comes to your table and entertains you with cool card tricksFood: they really do have 30 different types of burgers! I had the Gwar Burger which was a double patty burger with pulled pork, delicious! My friend had the Yard Burger (or something like that) which was one patty and one friend chicken patty with lettuc and tomatoa and he really enjoyed it. I also got sweet potato fries as a side, top tier!Other: they serve ice cream in a major way. Like there's a whole old timey vibe ice cream shop as you enter. There's also a music novelty and memorabilia store attached to the sit down restaurant. If you're really good at Pacman you could win a free burger and fries!“

4.6 Superb99 Reviews
Main Course Marketplace American • $
175 Main St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Hudson Valley Cattle Co Hanger Steak
Cobb Salad Without Blue Cheese or Avocado
Steak Sandwich and Soup Combo
Grilled Chicken Panini
Main Course Cobb Salad
Pan Asian Kale Salad
Blackened Chicken
Braised Short Rib
Roasted Chicken
Smoked Turkey

“I stopped here to get a light lunch and for a rest stop during a road trip. Although the listing makes it seem like a food court, it is actually a single ordering counter that offers coffees and a variety of prepared food items. I wanted something light, so I tried the empanadas with chimichurri. Although the portion size was good, the filling tasted like "sloppy Joe" meat, and the sauce was sweet. The restaurant has ample indoor seating, and a nice outdoor deck. Parking is limited, and I was lucky to arrive before the lunchtime crowd.“

4.6 Superb82 Reviews
Garvan's Gastropub Irish • $$
215 Huguenot St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp and Butternut Squash Ravioli
Seared Sea Scallops Appetizer
Guinness Chocolate Cake
Wild Mushroom Primavera
Corned Beef Sandwich
Guinness Lamb Stew
Stuffed Mushrooms
Braised Short Ribs
Potato Leek Soup
Bangers and Mash

“What a great place! Highly worth the slightly higher prices. Really quaint location tucked away, and the atmosphere is really fun. Great selection of drinks and food, and they even have a dedicated vegetarian menu if that's preferred.Really glad I checked out this place. Owners are super nice and friendly as well. Highly recommend to any in the area!“

4.5 Superb148 Reviews
Karma Road Cafe • $
11 Main St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Baked Tofu with Walnut Pesto
Avocado Explosion Sandwich
Sweet Potato Biscuit
Baked Tofu Sandwich
Tempeh blt Sandwich
Breakfast Burrito
Chocolate Peanut
Organic Coffee
Hybrid Burrito
Blackened Tofu

“My fave vegan spot in New Paltz. Food is delish and staff is delightful. Puppy friendly with indoor and outdoor seating. Lots of GF optionsVegetarian options: Everything is veganDietary restrictions: In addition to being all vegan, there are lots of GF options, and everything la elements and adjustable so you can avoid nuts, seeds wtc.Kid-friendliness: Totally kid friendly“

4.6 Superb65 Reviews
Jar'd Wine Pub Bar • $
10 Main St, New Paltz

“Love this little bar. There's even a small balcony with a view to the Gunks, and a little raised bed of herbs that the bartender uses for drinks... so fresh lavender in your cocktail...be still my senses, only one at a time please! Service is always lovely and welcoming. If you like Bourbon, a cocktail called the "Bees Knees" is the way to go.“

4.9 Superb16 Reviews
Mudd Puddle Coffee Roasters Cafe • $
10 Main St #312, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Of Pastries & Treats
Local Coffee Shop
Blueberry Muffin
Espresso Cups
Sandwiches
Croissant

“A really nice coffee shop off the beaten path in New Paltz. They have a good menu with all your typical drinks with some seasonal specials. I highly recommend the amaretto and campfire specials. They served baked goods and food and both are fresh and tasty. It is a smaller space with limited seating. I personally love the back porch. It is a bit colder outside, but the view makes it worth it. Service is decently paced unless it's Uber busy, then it could be a bit slower, but it's not anything too extremely long. Staff are quite friendly. Would recommend“

4.5 Superb58 Reviews
Lola's Cafe American • $
49 Main St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Tomato Basil and Provolone Panini
Short Rib Grilled Cheese
Turkey and Brie Panini
Side of Peanut Noodles
Asian Chicken Salad
Black Bean Burger
Baja Chicken Wrap
The Hot Chicken
S'Mores Shake
Sandwiches

“Hands down my favorite place in New Paltz for lunch or dinner, dine-in or takeout. First-rate food, excellent preparation in a kitchen visible from the dining room and the best staff in the business. Cannot recommend Lola's Cafe New Paltz enough–five stars and A+“

4.4 Superb97 Reviews
Maggie Mae's American • $
215 Huguenot St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Sandwich
Fish and Chips
Dublin Nachos
Quesadilla
Onion Soup
Fries

“Yesterday, my sorority alumni met at Maggie Mae's for our fall luncheon. My seat had the perfect view of changing fall leaves. The weather here on Long Island was absolutely horrible. When I set out on my road trip upstate, I almost turned around and went home. I am so glad that I didn't! Not only did I share some funny memories and have some good laughs with my sisters of all ages, but I had an incredible lunch, followed by a dessert that almost literally blew me away! I'll post the pictures, but I'll tell you that I had a delicious chicken francaise with asparagus and the most wonderful mashed potatoes. I saved most of the potatoes for last, with a fair bit of the sauce. I only wish that I had brought a rubber scraper with me so I could get every last delicious speck of mashed potatoes. Then came my favorite part: dessert! The menu describesit as a rich chocolate Guinness cake with cream cheese frosting. Yelp reader, I am a Guinness girl. However, I could not begin to conceptualize how the two flavors would work together. Not only did they work together wonderfully, but the cream cheese frosting put an interesting sweet little twist on the flavor. I have a terrible sweet tooth. and when I find a sweet that I like, I just can't get enough of it. I wish I could have another piece of that cake right now...“

4.4 Superb47 Reviews

11
P&G’s

P&G’s American • $
91 Main St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Cheeseburger with Fried Onions
The Mack Truck Burger Melt
New England Clam Chowder
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
Cheeseburger & Fries
French Onion Soup
Mashed Potatoes
Chicken Nachos
Buffalo Wings
Chicken Wings

“Been coming here since I got my license, that was 40 years ago. Now that I live in New Paltz I try to get there once a week. Party platter, Chicken BLT, Mac Truck burger or Nachos with Chili is what I usually get. A Guinness is always available and great smiles from all the servers and bartenders. Never been disappointed not once.Parking: If you are lucky you'll be able to park right out front. If not the entire street has parking as well as across the street there's a huge parking lot.“

4.3 Superb97 Reviews
Gadaleto's Seafood Market & Eatery Seafood Markets • $$
246 Main St #1, New Paltz

“The market: Quite simply the only place worth going for seafood, fresh or prepared, within 50 miles. I come from San Francisco and grew up going to places like this, its one par with SF or Monterey seafood joints. If you're wanting someting special, if you call ahead and give them a few days, they can get you just about anything, including bulk quantity for events/catering. So happy this place is only 25 min from home.The Restaurant: This is not a fancy seafood restaurant, its a seafood joint. There is a difference. Think paper plates and curly fries. Better for a quick bite than a fancy occasion.“

4.3 Superb39 Reviews
McGillicuddy's Irish • $
84 Main St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Potato Gnocchi with Prosciutto and Butternut Squash
A Pint of Guinness Stout
Corned Beef and Cabbage
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Kids Boneless Wings
Irish Potato Soup
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Tenders
Honey Buffalo
Chicken Wings

“Cuddys is a great wing spot in new paltz! This is my go to place when i’m not sure what I want to eat because i’m always able to find something on the menu! The drinks are great here as well! Great family spot, after work quick bite, traditional bar food!“

4.1 Good68 Reviews
Main Street Bistro Bistros • $
59 Main St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

South of the Border Breakfast Burrito
Chicken and Waffles
Chicken Quesadillas
Scrambled Eggs
Salmon Hash
Frittata

“The Bistro has been a very popular breakfast and lunch place in New Paltz for many years. Recently under new ownership, some things have changed. The breakfast and lunch aspect have stayed roughly the same, but they have added a VEGAN VIETNAMESE dinner six days a week. I don’t usually do reviews of places in NewPaltz, and wasn’t planning to, so I did not get pictures, will next time. Great food and make sure you try the bubble tea, probably the best in town!Vegetarian options: The DINNER is all vegan“

4.1 Good98 Reviews
The Parish Cajun • $$
10 Main St #327, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Green Beans GF
Buttermilk Fried Chicken
Shrimp and Grits GF
Cajun Chicken Wings
Buffalo Cauliflower
Blackened Catfish
Traditional Gumbo
Steak of the Day
Shrimp & Grits
Fried Okra GF

“I treated myself on my birthday to dinner and drinks. It was after 6p on a Thursday night. It’s a small and cozy spot with a few people at the bar and a couple of us seated. I started with two unique tequila drinks. I then had the chopped salad with blue cheese crumbles, followed by the shrimp with grits. It’s my new favorite. I never would have put those two together. I want to go back and try more appetizers and another entree.“

4 Good62 Reviews
The Lemon Squeeze New Paltz Bar • $$
107 Main St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Wagyu Bacon Blue Burger
Blue Point Oysters
Chicken Carbonara
Lobster Bisque
Fried Oysters
King Salmon
Pear Down

“lemon squeeze had the only people all night that would help my friends when a man was harassing us. we were there for a few hours before this happened and had the best time with the live music and great vibe! the staff genuinely saved us that night and deserve ten stars“

4 Good82 Reviews
Huckleberry Bar • $$
21 Church St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
Nashville Chicken Sandwich
Korean BBQ Chicken Wings
Fried Brussel Sprouts
Burger and Fries
Brussels Sprouts
Rosemary Fries
Parmesan Fries
Steak Sandwich
Fish Tacos

“Had a great weekday brunch here. Food and cocktails are spot on. This is the kind of place you'd expect in the city proper and a nice option is here. Very vegan friendly. Prices are high but fair for farm to table ingredients and ethical wage transparency the whole way down.“

4 Good88 Reviews
The Bakery Cafe • $
13a N Front St, New Paltz

Customers` Favorites

Coconut Macaroon
Croissant
Rugelach
Danish
Bakery
Bagel

“I was a little disappointed by the brownies I got here. They tasted like cardboard sprinkled with cocoa powder. They looked fudgey and sweet but tasted nothing like what they looked like. The staff were friendly and the upstairs has many tables in a diner-booth style. I'll try another baked-good next time and hopefully, I can change my rating.“

3.8 Good40 Reviews
Loading...
map Map