What are you looking for?

Italian Restaurants in Madison

4.5 - 424 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

Northside Town Center, 1849 Northport Dr, Madison
(608) 241-1144

Benvenuto's Italian Grill

The food was ok at best. The chicken parm was delicious but the rest was barely warm from taking far to long to be delivered to our table. The service ... More reviews

4.6 - 254 votes

Hours: 5 - 10PM

15 N Butler St, Madison
(608) 250-6330

Naples 15

This was the best meal we have ever had. We LOVE this place & Salvatore! He made our meal & celebration a wonderful memory! We can’t thank him... More reviews

4.8 - 122 votes

Hours: 11AM - 2:30PM

222 W Washington Ave Ste 30, Madison
(608) 467-8108

Casetta Kitchen and Counter

Great food and love the atmosphere. Just too bad they're only open weekdays for lunch - I've recommended this place to people who literally can... More reviews

4.5 - 143 votes

Hours: 3:30 - 9PM

515 S Midvale Blvd STE 1, Madison
(608) 661-7663

Luigi's Pizza

The Lasagna was Fantastic. I loved the way the sauce brought everything together. It was so good I almost ate the whole serving before taking a picture... More reviews

4.3 - 181 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

704 S Whitney Way, Madison
(608) 661-9254

Nonno's Ristorante Italiano

Service was pretty inattentive, but quality of food was good. Pasta was al dente, flavorful. Would go to again. More reviews

4.4 - 160 votes

Hours: Closed today

2500 University Ave, Madison
(608) 238-1922

Lombardino's Restaurant

The hostess and waiter were great both times I went because I was staying at the hotel across the street and this place had been recommended. Both times ... More reviews



4.2 - 200 votes

Hours: 4 - 10PM

122 W Mifflin St, Madison
(608) 284-9378


The ambience was nice, the servers were nice and prompt, and the menu selection was decent. Not sure how I felt about the food my partner and I got-can&#... More reviews

4.5 - 125 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

2004 Atwood Ave, Madison
(608) 709-1316

Bar Corallini

If you haven't tried this place yet you definitely should. It's such a cute space off of Atwood. The atmosphere was nice and relaxed. The decor... More reviews

4.3 - 154 votes

Hours: 4:30 - 10PM

107 State St, Madison
(608) 630-8184

107 State

Cool place with REALLY cool people. A nice change of pace from the places right on the square that treat you like it's your privilege to give them y... More reviews

4.4 - 130 votes

Hours: 9AM - 7PM

4606 Verona Rd, Madison
(608) 273-1981

Gino's Italian Deli

No need to complain about Gino’s! Just awesome food for a great price!Lasagna is bomb ?Cajun chicken salad ?Sub ? More reviews

4.3 - 142 votes

Hours: 4:30 - 9PM

128 E Wilson St, Madison
(608) 255-8376

Osteria Papavero

Soooooo disappointing. This was probably the worst meal of my life. I don't know if they are short staffed or what but the food was undercooked. I o... More reviews

4.2 - 157 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

1026 N Sherman Ave, Madison
(608) 243-1200

Cafe la Bellitalia

I love good pizza but I don't want it frozen, and they make good pie! Their sauce is wonderful ! Sausage and pepperoni is the way to go! That was pr... More reviews

4.3 - 131 votes

Hours: 3:30 - 8PM

751 N High Point Rd, Madison
(608) 831-7776

OLIVA Italian Mediterranean Cuisine

Good service, good food, and casual dining. Enjoy Italian and Mediterranean dishes here. More reviews

4.6 - 88 votes

Hours: Closed today

116 King St, Madison
(608) 285-9021


Dined outside, white table cloth under umbrella. The Hendricks Gin, Lemoncello Martini was delicious. Friday Wisconsin Fish Fry was the best we’d ever ha... More reviews



4.7 - 68 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

2903 University Ave, Madison
(608) 498-4995


Best pizza I've had so far in Madison. Staff was amazing! Even gave us free desert. More reviews

3.6 - 214 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

EAST TOWNE MALL, 4502 E Towne Blvd, Madison
(608) 244-3530

Red Lobster

Open table reservation allowed us to arrive and get seated at a table immediately. That NEVER happens at Red Lobster! More reviews

3.9 - 162 votes

Hours: 11AM - 10PM

4320 E Towne Blvd, Madison
(608) 249-0340

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

My sister and I both got the stuffed cheese shells and loved them!! Our waiter was absolutely amazing as well. We finished off with some cheesecake that ... More reviews

3.8 - 169 votes

Hours: 11AM - 10PM

7017 Mineral Point Rd, Madison
(608) 829-1158

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

The food was absolutely delicious. Our server Kelly was absolutely wonderful. It was my brother's birthday. Thank you so much. More reviews

4.2 - 112 votes

Hours: Closed today

914 Regent St, Madison
(608) 257-2874

Greenbush Bar

Pizza was some of the best in Madison! Antipasto was dissapointing for the price, but we'll definitely be back for the za More reviews

3.7 - 176 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

131 W Wilson St, Madison
(608) 257-3832

Paisan's Restaurant

A staple in Madison. Good view of lake Monona and Frank Lloyd Wright community center. Food is wrygood and pizza crust is popular. The GARIBALDI™ is e... More reviews

3.9 - 141 votes

Hours: 10:30AM - 11PM

6644 Mineral Point Rd, Madison
(608) 833-9300

Rosati's Pizza

My white pizza was delivered scorched. My husband’s tomato sausage too salty & spicey. Very dissatisfied. More reviews

4.8 - 42 votes

Hours: 11AM - 1:30PM

1 E Main St, Madison

Common Pasta

Seriously DELICIOUS! Visiting from out of town and just happened to walk by this gem. Authentic, so yummy, and big portions (which I devoured all of in o... More reviews

4.1 - 87 votes

Hours: 10:30AM - 9PM

4556 Monona Dr, Madison
(608) 221-3818

Rocky Rococo Pan Style Pizza

I have a deep and maybe a bit irrational love for Rocky's pizza. I don't live close to here but make sure to eat it every time I pass through. More reviews

3.7 - 119 votes

Hours: 11AM - 8PM

7952 Tree Ln, Madison
(608) 829-1444

Rocky Rococo Pan Style Pizza

Yummy, quick, clean, friendly. Took pizzas and more back to our host house. Everyone was thrilled. More reviews

3.7 - 113 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

1054 Williamson St, Madison
(608) 258-2000

Roman Candle

Nice place. I like that you can get slices with any toppings you want. Nice selection of tap beers. More reviews

View on map