29 Best Italian Restaurants near Middleton

Novanta Pizza • $
8452 Old Sauk Rd, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Truffle Gelato
Build Your Own Pizza
Graham Cracker Cake
Vegetarian Pizza
Mozzarella Ball
Salsiccia Pizza
Gorgonzola Salad
Diavola Pizza
Lemon Sorbeto
Pizza Nutella

“Really good pizza at a fair price. We got the Salsiccia and the Lombarda. The Salsiccia was definitely the better pizza but both were very tasty in different ways. The tomato sauce shines through! Novanta is a great option when you want something different than the greasy standard pizza.“

4.6 Superb79 Reviews
Johnny's Italian Steakhouse Steak House • $$
8390 Market St, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Four Cheese Ravioli & Shrimp Rosa
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Warm Chocolate Cake
Goat Cheese Salad
Steak Steak Steak
Chicken Parmigiano
Turtle Cheesecake
Stuffed Mushrooms
Steak Medallion

“Love Johnny’s Italian steakhouse! The atmosphere is warm, comfortable and cozy. The staff are awesome (Niko helped me today & he is such a sweetheart) and the food is amazing! Every single time we’ve been there it’s been perfect!Parking: You park and walk in. As easy as that!“

4.4 Superb112 Reviews
Villa Dolce Italian • $$
1828 Parmenter St, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp & Scallops Linguine
Goat Cheese Bruschetta
Wild Mushroom Ravioli
Gelato Experience
Crispy Calamari
Truffle Fries
Salmon Salad
Meat Lovers
Bolognese
Tiramisu

“Villa Dolce is a consistently wonderful experience. No matter what day of week, or week of year, the service is impeccable, the bartenders are talented, the food is amazing, and the overall experience is absolutely worth it. Highly recommend!!“

4.3 Superb85 Reviews
Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano Italian • $$
1611 Aspen Commons, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce
Braised Short Rib Ravioli
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Ravioli Quattro Formaggi
Bacon Wrapped Dates
Bruschetta Classico
Sea Scallop Risotto
Rigatoni Bolognese
Bread Basket
Creme Brulee

“Great value for good food- crazy big portion size so definitely bang for your buck. I had the dijon salmon which was good (not great, but good!). The house salad was tasty and filling as was the bread. The service was very prompt too. Will be coming back for laid-back, super-filling food. update: I’ve been back many times! Some dishes have been hit or miss for me but I get the seared salmon salad, minestrone, or piccata and I’m happy every time. Or really any salad or soup. My kids like the spaghetti kids meal.“

4.2 Good81 Reviews
Gino's Italian Deli Italian • $
6509 Century Ave, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Tomato with Bread and Salad
Spicy Capicola Sub
Pastrami Sandwich
Italian Beef Sub
Roast Beef Sub
Sub Sandwich
Cold Lasagne
Italian Sub
Hot Lasagne

“Each year my large family comes for Christmas and we order Gino's Italian Deli piping hot lasagnas, garlic bread and salad. What a treat loved by all and especially the cook with little to clean up :) Thanks for making it easy every year Gino's for our holiday gathering needs.“

3.8 Good39 Reviews
Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Livingston Pizza • $
10 N Livingston St, Madison - 6.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Vegan Sausage Supreme
Woodsman's Tomato Pie
The Woodsman Pizza
Fat Uncle Tony
Chocolate Cake
Caesar Salad
Market Salad
Meatballs
Forza

“Wonderful experience for dinner at Salvatore’s, E Wash & Livingston, Madison, WI.Crispy Calabrese Tofu was exquisite. Pizza great! Manda’s service was above and beyond. She was great with my 7 year old granddaughter!Vegetarian options: Crispy Calabrese Tofu exquisite!“

4.8 Superb113 Reviews
Casetta Kitchen and Counter Italian • $
222 W Washington Ave Ste 30, Madison - 6.16 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian on Focaccia Bread
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Housemade Focaccia
Focaccia or Hero
Spicy Chickpeas
Sullivan
Paradigm
Turkey

“I went here for lunch and it was super busy. I suggest ordering ahead of time and picking up because so many people were there. The sandwich itself was good and there’s a lot of food for the price. The main reason for only four stars is because of how busy it is and how their hours are very limited.“

4.9 Superb53 Reviews
D’Vino Wine Bar • $$
116 King St, Madison - 6.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Alfredo Sauce
Chicken Parmigiana Alfredo
Tortellini Con Pesto
Tortellini Pesto
Pizza Di Patate
Fried Doughnuts
Sicilian Steak
Fried Ravioli
Crab Cakes
Tiramisu

“Once again you did not disappoint. We went for brunch this time, EXCELLENT. The food was spectacular, service was great. Our waitress Laura friendly, helpful and knowledgeable. Bartender took pride in her craft. Owner is so personable and had come to our table everytime we have been in. Highly recommend!!“

4.5 Superb192 Reviews

9
Cento

Cento Italian • $$
122 W Mifflin St, Madison - 6.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spuntini Salad Pasta Course Entrée and Dessert
Rigatoni Alla Carbonara
Warm Marinated Olives
Seasonal Cheese Board
Pan Roasted Salmon
Porcini Pappardelle
Charcuterie Board
Chicken Parmesan
Margherita Pizza
Grilled Octopus

“Enjoyed the scampi, although it was a little spicier than expected. The chicken parm was just fair. The chicken was mostly breading and dry, there wasn't enough sauce, and the noodles were very dense and chewy. My husband and I split both the dishes we ordered and we both only took a few bites of the chicken parm and had the rest boxed up. Not sure we'll get back to it, maybe we'll add more sauce at home and try it again. Service was great. We said that we planned to share our dishes and everything came up "pre-split," with no added charge. We very much enjoyed the complimentary (special occasion) cheesecake!“

4.4 Superb273 Reviews

10
Novanta

Novanta Pizza • $
2903 University Ave, Madison - 3.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Mushroom Onion
Vegetariana Pizza
Salsiccia Pizza
Pizza Novanta
Pepperoncini
Alice Pizza
Bruschetta
Margherita
Cannoli

“I stopped here for the first time because I had an appointment a few buildings next door. What a nice little restaurant. It is super family-friendly, and you can tell the food is authentic. Excellent Service as well, they were super accommodating for handicapped people Very friendly. I really enjoyed the pizza I had there today.“

4.7 Superb55 Reviews
Gino's Italian Deli Italian • $
4606 Verona Rd, Madison - 4.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Bread Sticks
Hot Italian Beef Sandwich
Hot Meatball Sandwich
Cajun Chicken Salad
Pastrami Sandwich
Greek Pasta Salad
Ham & Swiss Sub
Sicilian sub13
Garlic Bread
Seafood Pasta

“Recently had the chance to be in Madison and Gino’s is absolutely, positively worth visiting. I had the Italian Beef and got the large. This is a good sized sandwich at 8”. The thinly shaved beef was done perfectly with just the right amount of fat to make the sandwich tender and flavorful. I thought the seasoning was well done and the au ju sauce was amazing! I thought it was awesome service when the woman who took my phone order suggested I get the sandwich “dry” and they would put the sauce in a to go container. She said it was worth it because it makes this sandwich and she wasn’t kidding. There’s a choice of hot or mild peppers. I chose the mild and they were sweet, with a low tinge of spice. I will get the hot next time. Bread was either fresh or baked in house. Had a nice crunch with a soft and mild flavored body. You will not be hungry after eating this sandwich! I grew up blocks away from Omaha Nebraska’s “Little Italy” and I’ve eaten more than a fair amount of Hot Italian Beef sandwiches in the last 50 years. This sandwich, Is up there. I’m looking forward to my next Wisconsin visit already!!“

4.6 Superb64 Reviews
Osteria Papavero Italian • $$
128 E Wilson St, Madison - 6.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Budino Di Pane E Cioccolato
Pappardelle Al Cinghiale
An Assortment of Bread
Butterscotch Pudding
Gnocchi Al Gorgonzola
Budino Di Caramello
House-Cured Salumi
Pistachio Cake
Braised Lamb
House Bread

“Fantastic selection of rotating items with fantastic and knowledgeable waitstaff. Bluntly, some selections on the menu are better than others but everything is still good. That said, the fact this restaurant rotates items so frequently is an open invitation to frequently return. I've noticed despite the frequent rotations that they always feature a vegetarian item. Occasionally features exotic meats like kangaroo. Would highly recommend to anyone. The humble butterscotch pudding is surprisingly one of the single best desserts I've ever had.“

4.3 Superb84 Reviews
Naples 15 Italian • $$$
15 N Butler St, Madison - 6.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spaghettoni Gerardo Di Nola Alle Vongole Veraci
Margherita Doc Pizza Reginella
Pancchetti Lardiato Naples 15
Pacchetti Lardiati Naples 15
Aragosta Alla Don Salvatore
Linguini Alla Puttanesca
Gateaux Alla Napoletana
Calamari Alla Malvasia
Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina
Ravioli All' Aragosta

“I was at Naples 15 and was in shock to see the Grammy-award winning pianist Bill Charlap and his wife Renee Rosness. They were visiting from New York and came for a concert but stopped by Naples 15 for remembrance for the friendship between Salvatore (owner of Naples 15) and the famous singer Tony Bennett.“

4.4 Superb144 Reviews
Lombardino's Restaurant Italian • $$
2500 University Ave, Madison - 4.18 miles

Customers` Favorites

Roasted Mushroom Pizza with Fontina Fontal Cheese Fresh Sage Roasted Garlic & San Marzano Sauce
Orecchiette with Fraboni's Sausage & Rapini
Beef Short Rib with Gnocchi
Chocolate & Sea Salt Budino
Spaghetti Alla Bolognese
Half Chicken Al Mattone
Linguine with Clams
Calamari Fritti
Mushroom Pasta
It Was Good

“Solid choice for Italian food. Everything we ate was good. The pizza we had was tasty. Our pasta dishes were all good. We had the calamari for an appetizer, and it was kind of flavorless, but at least it didn't taste fishy. I think the breading could have used a bit more seasoning. The atmosphere is kind of fun, probably looks the same as it did in the 60s. Definitely the kind of place you can bring the whole family or a date.“

4.5 Superb79 Reviews
Nonno's Ristorante Italiano Italian • $
704 S Whitney Way, Madison - 3.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Caesar Salad with Chicken
Risotto Mare E Terra
Spaghetti Carbonara
Spaghetti Bolognese
Ravioli Al Formaggio
Ravioli Di Formaggio
Rigatoni Salsiccia
Chicken Parmesan
Calamari Fritti
Caprese Classica

“Really quiet when we were here, populated but not busy or loud. Very very nice customer service, a little pricey but it's very good authentic food. Got Ravioli Carne, great spicy sauce and really good serving size, added a Caesar salad for $5, also very good. Creme Brulee was also delicious, not too sweet, and the canolli cake was magnificent, also not overly sweet, great balance between canoli and cake“

4.4 Superb110 Reviews
Dahmen's at Hawks Landing American • $
88 Hawks Landing Cir, Verona - 4.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Veggie Deluxe Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Fish Tacos
Fish Fry

“We were looking for a new place to try and found this hidden gem. Great home made food and family friendly. It's not a big restaurant but there's plenty of seating. We were pleasantly surprised and very happy with the service. We will be coming back!“

4.5 Superb35 Reviews
OLIVA Italian Mediterranean Cuisine Mediterranean • $
751 N High Point Rd, Madison - 1.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mediterranean Calzone
Chicken Parmigiana
Red Lentil Soup
Lamb Shish Kebab
Chicken Alfredo
House Salad
Cigar Borek
Lasagna
Falafel
Humus

“A hidden gem on the westside of Madison. The falafel is amazing. Highly recommend it. Prices are very reasonable and you get what you pay for if not more. Staff is very friendly and efficient.Looking for great Italian or Turkish food this is your place.“

4.4 Superb41 Reviews
Zoe's Pizzeria Pizza • $$$
604 E Main St, Waunakee - 7.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Knots with Frosting
Vegan Pepperoni Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
The Works Pizza
Cheese Pizzaa
Garlic Knots
Veggie Pizza
Ranch Pizza

“We finally ordered Zoe's for pick up last night. I had 1/2 vegan pepperoni 1/2 vegan pesto. Husband got regular cheese and garlic knots. I have been crazing pepperoni (vegetarian, which from most places is not at all like I remember pepperoni). Zoe's was EXCELLENT. The vegan pesto pizza was really good to. Whatever vegan cheese they are using is better than many places. The middle of my pizza was a little wet/floppy. Not perfection, but hey I will take based on how good the rest was. Could be a vegan cheese related issue?? My husband liked his pizza but didn't love it. He said it was chewy - he ordered hand tossed crust and said he would try a different one next time.Vegetarian options: There is a vegan menu - someone posted a photo on the Madison Area Vegans Facebook page. The online ordering system has vegan options, but there are more on the menu.“

4.3 Superb59 Reviews
Cafe la Bellitalia Italian • $
1026 N Sherman Ave, Madison - 7.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Chicken Parmigiana
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Shrimp and Scallops
Fettuccine Alfredo
Meatball Platter
Sampler Platter
The Works Pizza
Baked Manicotti
Chicken Alfredo

“First timer. Soooo good. I had takeout beef ravioli, we also got alfredo and spaghetti with Italian sausage. I had never seen it served with a sausage on the spaghetti. All dishes were amazing. Staff we’re very friend authentic. Can’t wait to dine in. Only wish they were open during the day because it is about a mile from work. Great atmosphere.“

4.2 Good80 Reviews
Common Pasta Italian • $
1 E Main St, Madison - 6.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Green Fusili Pasta Salad
Mac & Cheese

“My office booked Common Pasta for a client event and it was such a hit! The menu was simple yet varied, the portions were large, and the food was indulgent in the best way. Incredible service from a chef who knows Italian food. I can't wait to eat Common Pasta again! Highly recommend the food and hiring their truck for your next event!“

4.3 Superb30 Reviews
107 State American • $$
107 State St, Madison - 6.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Crostini with Pickled Onions
Roasted Atlantic Salmon with Sweet
Crostini of Saut
Dairyland Bliss
The 107 Burger
Smash Burger
Cheese Curds
French Fries
Shrimp Pasta

“I like this downtown restaurant. On State St, about a block from the Capitol Square. I loved the dark atmosphere. Cool jazz music playing. Besides not being very loud in there, the booths help make it easy to have a conversation. The rough brick wall also helps to break up any noise.Our server was very friendly and the timing of her check-ins was good.First off, I liked the bread. Besides being complementary, each piece was crunchy on one side and warm & buttery on the other. The roasted mushroom crostini was a great way to start the meals. It was crunchy chewy, with the expected sweetness from the cheese and glaze.My salmon crunchy outside and soft moist inside. The garlic lemon sauce was a great added flavor. The shrimp scampi also tasted great, although a bit too heavy on the garlic. The Bliss Burger was a tasty burger dripping with juicy goodness. The accompanying fries tasted just McDonald's fries, but a little less salty. The meat in the Ziti with Ragu was a nice combo of hearty meat with soft tender tasty ziti.The waitress passed by with plates of desserts that looked real good, but we were just too full. ....Next time.Overall, I really liked this upscale city tavern.“

4.2 Good68 Reviews
Greenbush Bar Pizza Takeaway • $$
914 Regent St, Madison - 5.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Daily Deserts Please Inquire
Vegetarian Antipasta
Garlic Cheese Bread
Signature Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Veggie Pizzas
Cannoli

“Doughnuts are amazing. My family showed up on Friday night after getting some pizza. The workers there, a husband wife combo, were amazing. Not only were the doughnuts amazing, the workers laughed and joked with my 4 year old son. Showing him all the doughnuts they had in stock. They even gave us 2 free doughnuts to take home for tomorrow. I will be buying all doughnuts from here from now on. 10/10“

4.2 Good27 Reviews
Avantis Italian Restaurant & Pub Italian • $
119 S Main St #1, Verona - 7.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Manicotti with Marinara Sauce
Eggplant Parmesan with Alfredo
French Onion Soup
Chicken Marsala
Baked Manicotti
Crispy Calamari
Homemade Soup
Garlic Bread
Dinner Salad
Sicilan Pizza

“Love the old wood in the restaurant. Spencer the owner and bartender is always smiling and ready for a conversation. I have always enjoyed the food and have had many of the dishes offered.Parking: Street parking is hard because there are a lot of businesses that share the road and parking. Very small number of spaces out the back of the building.“

4 Good61 Reviews
Amara Madison Italian •
670 N Midvale Blvd, Madison - 3.1 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crab and Avocado Bruschetta
Spinach & Ricotta Gnocchi
Angry Shrimp Spiedini
Burnt Ricotta Cake
Charcuterie Board
Chocolate Cake
Beet Salad
Porchetta
Strawberry
Calamari

“One of my new favorite places to eat! Excellent drinks (especially the melon spritz), delicious food (the fried mozzarella balls and mafaldine cacio e pepe highly recommend trying) and beautifully decorated - absolutely love the vibes. Will definitely be back!“

4 Good439 Reviews
Benvenuto's Italian Grill Italian • $$
2949 Triverton Pike Dr, Fitchburg - 6.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

12 Oz Prime Rib and Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Roasted Garlic Shrimp Fettuccine
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Lasagna with Extra Cheese
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Seafood Cannelloni
Chicken Parmigiana
Bruschetta
Caprese

“Best italian food I've ever had. I had the special chicken and shrimp alfredo. It was the best alfredo, perfectly rich creamy just the right consistency. The Chicken was moist, Shrimp was grilled and plenty of it. I can't wait to go back. Service was the best.“

3.9 Good75 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
7017 Mineral Point Rd, Madison - 2.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
Eggplant Parmigiana with Fried Mozzarella
Unlimited Soup Salad & Breadsticks
Five Italian Cheese Fonduta
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Five Cheese Ziti Al Forno
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chicken Gnocchi Soup
Shrimp Scampi Dinner

“Our waitress was on point! I never had to ask for anything because she came back to the table every 7 mins to ask if we were okay and had some of the itmes with her so there was no I will bring it right back just give me 5 minutes type deal. Would eat here “

3.8 Good106 Reviews
Luigi's Pizza Pizza • $
515 S Midvale Blvd, Madison - 4.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Layer Cake with Chocolate Ganache Filling and Chocolate Ganache Icing
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Lasagna Close Up View
Garlic Cheese Bread
The Racket Pizza
The Arthur Salad
Cheese Sticks
Caesar Salad
Meat Pizza
Tiramisu

“I don’t usually write reviews but my experience at Luigi’s was amazing! We absolutely loved the racket and the Maximus! I’d also definitely recommend the garlic cheese bread. Service and atmosphere were also great! 10/10Vegetarian options: Tons of vegan, gluten free, and vegetarian options!“

3.6 Good57 Reviews
Benvenuto's Italian Grill Italian • $$
1109 Fourier Dr, Madison - 1.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tuscan Chicken and Roasted Potatoes
Crock of Baked French Onion Soup
Prime Rib Sandwich and Fries
Caesar Salad with Salmon
Benvenuto Pizza 16 Inch
Pepperoni Cheese Bread
Chicken Carbonara
Tiramisu
Meatballs
Italian

“The service was the best. Araceli was amazing server , help us with everything we need , the best GF menu I had so far .. I recommend this place very clean classy .. Barb the manager came and checked on us to make sure we had everything we needed .. very happy and I’m definitely going to be back soon“

3.6 Good57 Reviews
Rosati's Pizza Pizza • $
6644 Mineral Point Rd, Madison - 2.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Three Cheese Baked Penne
Thin Crust Pizza
Italian Beef
Sandwich
Meatball
Lasagna
Sausage
Combo
Salad
Sauce

“A culinary haven where every bite is a work of art and every glance at the plate feels like a discovery. The presentation is a testament to their craft, and the ambiance is a warm, inviting embrace. Suggesting this place to friends feels less like a recommendation and more like a well-guarded secret being shared.“

3.7 Good98 Reviews
Loading...
map Map