New American Restaurants near Middleton, WI

Longtable Beer Cafe Bar • $$
7545 Hubbard Ave, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Burger with Coleslaw
Large Charcuterie Board
Soft Hot Pretzel V
Beer Cheese Soup
Grilled Cheese
Cheese Curds V
Fish and Chips
BBQ Platter
Brisket

“We decided to try this Cafe out on an incredibly busy night! The food was excellent and the service was extraordinary! The manager waited on us because they were so busy! He stopped by twice to ask if we needed anything! Will definitely be back. I love the ambience!“

4 Good64 Reviews

2
Jardin

Jardin Vegan • $$
829 E Washington Ave, Madison - 6.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Left to Right Affogato Seasonal Spiked Sorbet Trail Cookie
Blackened Tofu with Soba Noodles
Cast Iron Trail Cookie
Lobster Casarecce
Patatas Azules
Chickpea Paneer
Three Sisters
Quesabirria
Yuba Salad
Flatbread

“WOWWWW! As a non-vegan, I was definitely skeptical of this restaurant, but that was my mistake. This is one of the very best restaurants in all of Madison. It was so good that I went twice in one week because I couldn't stop thinking about how fantastic the food was! The service was excellent and Juan, the chef, made our experience super memorable. Make sure to get the chickpea paneer and the bao, they are both to die for! I'll be coming back (maybe again next week haha) and plan on taking all of my friends and family there to impress them. Cannot recommend this restaurant enough! Thank you to the staff for such an amazing dinner!!“

4.8 Superb110 Reviews
Heritage Tavern New American • $$$
131 E Mifflin St, Madison - 6.27 miles

Customers` Favorites

Old Fashioned Ham Cinnamon Roll
Bacon Wrapped Cheese Curds
Foie Gras & Lardo Poutine
Crispy Pork Belly & Tuna
Heritage Tavern Benedict
Heritage Pork Schnitzel
Classic Eggs Benedict
Assorted Deviled Eggs
Caramel Profiterole
Lobster Scramble

“My company had thier holiday party here recently, I had never been before. What a beautiful establishment and great location!The staff was great, friendly and fast, I never waited longer than a few minutes for a drink. The food was fantastic and the presentation was beautiful. I would highly recommend stopping in or arranging a moderately sized event here. Try the Pear martini (Pear Tin Rug ?) it is amazing. Thanks, Heritage Tavern, for making the night a success! You guys ROCK!“

4.5 Superb97 Reviews
Madison's American • $$
119 King St, Madison - 6.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pork Carnitas with Corn Soft Shell Tacos
Nacho and Wing Appetizers
Blackened Tuna Sandwich
Shrimp Cocktail Solo
The Madison Burger
Breakfast Burrito
Lunch Size Burger
Biscuits N' Gravy
Chicken Sandwich
Brisket Sandwich

“It was a Saturday night in late February when I first visited Madison’s. They were playing Meg Thee Stallion and I knew we just had to go in. Megan brought me in the door, but the 80s music video / dance showcase on the TV is what I stayed for. I’m currently drinking a strawberry rhubarb Moscow mule — life is good.“

4.4 Superb98 Reviews
Turn Key Supper Club Bar • $$
1344 E Washington Ave, Madison - 7.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

Party Time Relish Tray
Crispy Lake Trout
Charred Carrots
Cheese Curds
Smash Burger
Fettuccine
Gnocchi
Fries

“Different twist on classic supper club offerings, but all delicious.Pork chop with cherry compote was superb. Had the charred carrots based on reviews and they did not disappoint, unusual and delicious.The burnt apple jam cake was absolutely amazing.“

4.4 Superb140 Reviews
delecTable American • $$$
3248 University Ave, Madison - 3.44 miles

“Had an awesome dinner here last night for my wife's birthday celebration. Delicious 5 course with perfect wine pairings, including a very hard to find Plavac Mali from Croatia. Chef Ben shares all kinds of information about the ingredients, the dishes and even the tableware. A must-try spot in Madison for the true food “

4.6 Superb51 Reviews
Buck & Honey's - Waunakee American • $$
1370 Water Wheel Dr, Waunakee - 5.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

B & H Sampler Bacon Wrapped Dates Fire Cracker Shrimp Cheese Curds Buck & Honey's Waunakee WI
Crab Cakes with Micro Greens♡
Bowl of French Onion Soup
Chipotle Chicken Pasta
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Scallops Berry Salad
Flourless Choc Cake
Firecracker Shrimp
Carnitas Tacos

“Overall was good me and my friend went here and ordered 2 things chicken wings and cheese curds and just saying the curds are the best I ever had and that’s saying something I have had my curds in my time will get again when I come back but I don’t recommend the chicken wings they are not good. and the menu didn’t have any prices so I assumed just getting 2 appetizers would be probably like 15-20 bucks turns out just the two appetizers was $40 which I know you can charge whatever you want but 40 dollars for 2 appetizers is outrageous but apart from the price would highly recommend just don’t order the chicken wings there bad just get all cheese curds you won’t regret it“

4.3 Superb194 Reviews
The Coopers Tavern Bar • $$
20 W Mifflin St, Madison - 6.15 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sliders and Cheese Curds
Pork Belly Mac and Cheese
Beer Cheese Pretzel
Fried Cheese Curds
Reuben Sandwich
Pork Belly Mac
Coopers Burger
Grilled Cheese
Fish and Chips
Belgian Frites

“My friend got married at the capitol and we had seating planned for all 14 of us, but one of the tables didn’t end up leaving like we thought- The manager and wait staff were amazing and made something else work with no ask. Amazing service and so thankful“

4.3 Superb134 Reviews
Palette Bar & Grill Cocktail Bar • $$
901 E Washington Ave, Madison - 6.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Mushrooms
French Onion Soup
Grilled Salmon
Ice Cream Cake
Braised Bone
Wedge Salad
Fish Tacos

“We stayed at the Indigo on 3/28/24 and absolutely loved the service. We stayed in the bar area (7pm) and the bartender was excellent, made us an amazing Wisconsin Old Fashion Sour, excellent professional and very knowledgeable. The food was delicious and quickly served. We casually mentioned that my wife's birthday was the day before and the manager I assume, ( very friendly and professional, bald gentleman) brought us a Keylime pie out of nowhere! She was extremely happy. You guys rock, thank you so much and we have been here before and continue to stay here because of the amazing service. Both at the restaurant and at the hotel, hotel staff is also very friendly and even gave our dog a doggie biscuit. This is our all time favorite place to stay whenever we are in Madison. Thank you guys! Never change, you are the best. -Cris and Nikki“

4.2 Good143 Reviews

10
CIRC

CIRC New American • $
1 W Dayton St, Madison - 6.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

English Breakfast
Salads

“BEST salad bar EVER for a very reasonable price! This truly was a "gem" for a dining experience because of the friendly service, exceptionally fresh and tasty (excellent variety) of food offered for the salad bar, great location, on-site parking (for free) and chic decor with a warm ambience.“

4.4 Superb28 Reviews
The Borough Beer Company American • $$
444 S Park St, Madison - 5.74 miles

Customers` Favorites

Nashville Hot Chicken Club
Grilled Cauliflower Tacos
Pint Sized Fish and Chips
Breakfast Bread Pudding
Classic Eggs Benedict
Fried Cheese Curds
Bacon Cheeseburger
Carne Asada Tacos
Borough Burger
Poutine Fries

“They had a new menu since last time we visited and a great selection of food. Their brunch was delicious, the service was great, and it was such a wonderful atmosphere.Parking: We found you can park in their lot right behind the restaurant.“

4.1 Good99 Reviews
Bistro 525 American • $$
525 W Johnson St, Madison - 5.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Steel Pan Nachos
Roasted Chicken
Chicken Tenders
Cheese Curds
Cheeseburger
Street Tacos
Fig

“Just had the best lunch here! Even on a Badger GameDay, the staff was so attentive and friendly. Thank you to Tom, Naomi, Aaron, Patrick, and Kelsey!!! The bistro burger was amazing! Highly recommend that to everyone as well as the BLT wrap, and the cheese curds! Definitely would recommend this to anyone coming through Madison!!“

4.2 Good36 Reviews
The Flying Hound Alehouse European • $$
6317 McKee Rd, Fitchburg - 5.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Flying Hound Burger
Ribeye Quesadilla
French Onion Soup
Chicken Sandwich
Jaeger Schnitzel
Chicken Piccata
Reuben Sandwich
Cheese Curds
Fish & Chips
Poutine

“This place is a nice, quiet bar/restaurant/tap room. We stopped in on a whim while shopping on a Saturday, for a beer and an appetizer. We ordered an IPA, a stout and the giant pretzel with the cheese sauce. The beers, tasty. The pretzel, delicious. The cheese sauce, home made and very very good. The service, stupendous! I'd recommend checking this place out! EDIT; we went a second time for dinner a few days later. One kid had the bacon and Bleu burger...loved it! Cooked perfectly! My wife had the Reuben and loved it! Corned beef cooked perfectly, sandwich not soggy and delicious. I had the beef stroganoff and I was wonderful - pasta cooked perfectly, tender beef and a very nicely prepared cream sauce.Whether it's a snack before shopping, or a dinner out with the fam, I recommend stopping here.“

4.1 Good85 Reviews
Hop Haus Brewing Company Brewpubs • $
2975 Sub-Zero Pkwy, Fitchburg - 6.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

All Different Types of Tacos to Choose From
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich
Hop Haus Strawberry Shortcake
House Made Pretzel Bites
Hop Haus Chicken Wings
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
Nachos with Carnitas
Beer & Cheese Curds
Hashtag Hazy Beer
Burger and Fries

“We recently discovered Hop Haus in Fitchburg and are now obsessed. The service has been amazing and the food is delicious! Get the cheese curds!!Vegetarian options: They were super accommodating to make my meal vegetarian!Kid-friendliness: Great outdoors area for kids to RUN!“

4 Good91 Reviews
Loading...
map Map