4 Best Caterers near West Allis

Tall Guy and a Grill Catering Caterers • $$
6735 W Lincoln Ave, West Allis

“My husband and I used Tall Guy and A Grill for our wedding in early February. I can’t recommend them enough- the initial Zoom call was great, we really felt like they wanted to get to know us and our vibe so they could best match it. We attended one of their tastings and it was very well organized and the food was phenomenal- all options! It just confirmed our choices and made us even more excited for the big day. During cocktail hour, they made sure we got to try every app. During dinner, our lead caterer Betsy personally made sure we had drinks and apps at our sweetheart table and checked on us the perfect amount. Our guests raved about the food- especially the short ribs and maple glazed carrots. The set up and clean up was so smooth I never even noticed it. We had a special milk request for our dessert table and they made it happen no problem. We would absolutely use them again and highly recommend them for your wedding!“

4.9 Superb52 Reviews
Carrie's Crispies Dessert • $$
7133 W Becher St, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

3 Rice Crispie Treats

“Super cute little spot for an extra special treat! Many different flavors to choose from and they make sure you know which ones are gluten free or dairy free. I tried the maple bacon and it was amazing! ? Definitely give this place a stop if you are in the area.“

5 Superb35 Reviews
BISHOP'S SWEETS & CATERING Bakery • $
8005 W Lincoln Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Pineapple Upside Down Cake
Dutch Cherry Pie
Peach Cobbler

“AWESOME desserts and friendly service! Check hours before you go since they are closed some days during the week. The blueberry and strawberry cheesecakes are delicious ? but the peach cobbler rates a chef's kiss...and the cherry pie is the BEST!“

4.8 Superb48 Reviews
Timber's Catering; Traditional to BBQ Caterers • $$
7412 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis

“Coming from the south, I have been looking for great bbq for almost a year now. This is definitely the best I have found in the Milwaukee area! Their pulled pork, burnt ends, and even their shrimp and grits were to die for. ALL of their sauces were amazing as well! However, the brisket was well over cooked and not much flavor at all. No bark, no juice, and was like eating a tender piece of jerky. BBQ is not a Midwest thing I have come to find out, but other than the brisket this is the closest you are going to get around here! All the servers were great, and made excellent drink recommendations. The inside of the restaurant has a very "Nashville" feel, too. We will be back!“

4.6 Superb51 Reviews
Loading...
map Map