12 Best American Restaurants in Old Saybrook

Liv's Oyster Bar & Restaurant Seafood • $$
166 Main St, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Cut Fries Truffle Parmesan Fries
Fava Bean Falafel Appitizer
Shrimp and Cod Curry
Special Noodle Bowl
Happy Hour Calamari
Pan Seared Scallops
Crusted Tuna Steak
Eggnog Creme Brulee
Oyster of the Day
Shrimp Cocktail

“We had not been to Liv's for a number of years since our last experience was not positive. We were delighted to find that this time was very different. Our meals were excellent, service was helpful and attentive and our overall experience was most enjoyable.“

4.7 Superb237 Reviews
Wayback Burgers Hamburger • $
1657 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Double Bacon Burger
Bacon Cheeseburger
Chicken Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken
Impossible Melt
Chicken Tenders
Rodeo Burger
Onion Rings
Tater Tots
Classic

“This is the best burger joint in old saybrook by far! Forget McDonald's, Burger King, and Wendy's!! Everything is made fresh! I ordered a cheesy and Onions ring and it was phenomenal! Besides the great and fresh food and shakes, the owner Lori and staff was also friendly and attentive! I will definitely be back!“

4.6 Superb70 Reviews
Penny Lane Pub Pubs • $$
150 Main St, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries with a Side of Chipotle Aioli
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
New England Clam Chowder
Jumbo Coconut Shrimp
French Onion Soup
Corned Beef Hash
Steak Au Poivre
Ahi Tuna Salad
Classic Caesar
Fish and Chips

“Pub atmosphere, friendly staff, winter often not too busy, summers can be packed and noisy be sure to make a reservation. In warm months (if nice out) there is pleasant outdoor seating behind restaurant making it easier to get a table. Above average beer selection with many draft choices several from local breweries. QR code on drink menu puts an informative updated beer list on your smart phone.“

4.4 Superb191 Reviews
Aspen Restaurant American • $$$
2 Main St, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Raspberry Bomb
New England Clam Chowder
Sticky Toffee Pudding
Side Fettucine Pasta
Lobster Bolognese
Pan Seared Salmon
Grilled Octopus
Truffle Fries
Crab Cake
Calamari

“The food was excellent at Aspen, as was the service. This was our first meal there, and it was delicious. I had the braised short rib, which fell apart beautifully as soon as I touched it. Melt-in-your-mouth deliciousness. The creme brulee cheesecake was delightful - a combo of my two favorite desserts. I hope to eat there many more times in the future!“

4.4 Superb174 Reviews
Rosemary & Sage American • $$$
1080 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Sandwich with Mozzarella Crisp Fries Coleslaw
Caprese Salad with Panko Crusted Chicken
Pear Salad with Blackened Scallops
Chicken a La Paz a House Speciality
Tomato and Roasted Garlic
Cabernet Sauvignon
Chicken Piccata
Garlic Butter

“Wonderful restaurant and the owner, Nancy is so thoughtful and attentive checking on all the tables. We went for lunch and I got one of the specials, eggplant parm with my choice of pasta (I chose angel hair) The portion was HUGE! It makes me wonder how big the dinner portion is. The eggplant was nice and thin and not greasy at all-it tasted wonderful. I can't wait to return and try some more items.“

4.5 Superb54 Reviews
Otter Cove Restaurant & Bar Gastropubs • $$
99 Essex Rd, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp and Seared Scallops
Cheesecake Slice of Cake
Salmon with Broccoli
Steak Tacos

“Had a wonderful birthday meal. It was the day before St. Patrick's Day so the specials were Irish oriented. My husband had the whiskey honey glazed salmon which he said was very tasty. My daughter had the traditional corned beef and cabbage and my son had Shepard's pie. Not much was left to bring home in doggie bags. Lots of nice wood paneling inside and we were seated near the fireplace. The grandkids even enjoyed it.Parking: The restaurant is right off of Route 9 in Old Saybrook. There is parking in both the front and the back of the restaurant.Wheelchair accessibility: Walk up ramp for a cess to front door and outdoor seating when the weather is nice.“

4.4 Superb38 Reviews
Comfort Café LLC American • $
90 Essex Rd, Old Saybrook

“Love this place! Karaoke every Friday and Saturday. It's just a real cozy place full of regulars, and the people there go out of their way to make everyone feel included and safe. It's a popular wedding party hotel, so the spring through fall get to be busy and fun!Wheelchair accessibility: The door directly to the bar area is not wheelchair friendly, but the hotel entry is just to the left and it's very easy and close-by to go through the lobby and into the inner bar entry.“

4.2 Good18 Reviews
Paperback Cafe American • $
210 Main St #8, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Berry Berry French Toast
Salvadorian Scramble
Paleo Pancakes
Avocado Toast
Big Breakfast
Hash Browns
Hash

“Such a cute and cozy spot in downtown Old Saybrook! When you walk in, there's a whole case of various pastries, and it looks like they have several gluten free options as well! I ordered a pumpkin spice latte that was to die for!! Sort of on the sweeter side of things- but I didn't mind. We ordered a tuna melt that came with a side of carrot sticks, and an avocado BLT special that came with a side of hash browns. Everything came out great! Definitely recommend a stop if you're in the area.“

4.2 Good76 Reviews
Fresh Salt Seafood • $$$
2 Bridge St, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Sea Scallops with Risotto with Lobster and Asparagus and a Red Pepper Drizzle
Traditional Sauteed Lobster on Toasted New England Roll
Chilled Summer Melon Soup
Seared Sea Scallop
Mushroom Risotto
Shrimp Cocktail
Fish and Chips
Fried Calamari
Tuna Triangles
Salmon Burger

“Nothing at all negative, everything was absolutely amazing! Sunday Brunch is an absolute treat here! The food stations are thoughtful and varied. You could enjoy something here every day and never get bored! The service is, of course, impeccable, the dining areas immaculate and tasteful, and the food is the phenomenal focal point! A special shout out to Chris's Bird, the hotel manager, who is truly dedicated to the enjoyment of every guest!“

4.2 Good359 Reviews
Jack Rabbit's Burgers, Wings and Things Fast Food • $
254 Main St, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Onion Rings French Onion Dressing
Original Shack Sliders
New Yorker Hot Dog
Sweet Potato Fries
Boston Burger
French Fries
Buffalo Bill
Cheeseburger
Chicago Dog
Rabbit Hole

“The burgers are great. French fries ,fantastic. Grilled mac and cheese, don't waste your time. I can't blame them, no one seems to know how to make mac and cheese anymore. The service was great and the girls waiting on us were wonderful.“

4 Good47 Reviews
Little Pub Old Saybrook American • $$
1231 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Little Pub Big Pretzel
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Sweet Potato Fries
French Onion Soup
Thanksgiving Wrap
Hot Honey Chicken
Pickle Wings

“Loved the cozy tavern feel with bare wood and wrought iron and fire place in the left dining room. Service was fast and friendly, and the food was fantastic! Definitely returning more in the future.Wheelchair accessibility: Entrance and dining room all level with the ground, no stairs.“

4 Good100 Reviews
Monkey Farm Bar & Grill • $
571 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook

Customers` Favorites

Fried Shrimp and Scallops Crisp Fries and Homemade Coleslaw
Hot Lobster Roll with French Fries and Homemade Cole Slaw
Lobster Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Reuben Sandwich and Fries
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Beef Melt Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Hot Lobster Rolls
Chicken Tenders
OK Lobster Roll

“First visit on a cold rainy day. Followed a couple to seating in an enclosed porch area, thinking inside area just a bar. Wish I had investigated as there was a cozy table in front of a fireplace that would have been warmer. Food was delicious, lobster roll, fries and slaw all very flavorful. Prices were reasonable and enjoyed reading about history of the building.“

3.9 Good106 Reviews
Loading...
map Map