12 Best Italian Restaurants in Wallingford

Fratelli's Pizza Rustica Italian • $$
950 Yale Ave, Wallingford

Customers` Favorites

Veal Piccata with Capers in White Wine Lemon Sauce
Calzone with Ricotta and Mozzarella
Spaghetti with Meatballs or Sausage
Chicken Scarpariello
Fettuccine Alfredo
Meat Lovers Pizza
Penne Alla Vodka
Vegetarian Pizza
Bruschetta

“I came here for dinner with my family and girlfriend and I must say the food is absolutely delicious but it is a little bit smaller than the Milford location. At the time when I went, there was another major party going on just arriving with Quinnipiac university which these women filled up most of the dinning area. I did call ahead of time and put a last minute reservation but still this restaurant needs to expand and have a separate area for parties it is way too small. A lot of people don't like to sit at the bar area for dinner squeezed into a booth with a noisy party eating buffet style.“

4.5 Superb49 Reviews
Anthonys Pizzeria and Deli Wallingford Pizza • $
368 Main St, Wallingford

Customers` Favorites

Rams Short Rib Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Hot Angus Top Round Sandwich
Pesto Chicken Sandwich
Sausage and Mushroom
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grandma's Meatballs
Grandmas Meatballs
Tuna Rama Sandwich
Gluten Free Pizza
Steak and Cheese

“This place is just crazy awesome! What a hidden gem. Not even close to your normal pizzeria! This place has the most extreme variety of cuisines that you would normally find at Disney or similar! Why this place didn’t have a line out the door not even sure?“

4.5 Superb48 Reviews
Trackside Brick Oven Pizzeria Pizza • $
118 Dudley Ave, Wallingford

Customers` Favorites

Old Fashion Marinara Pizza
Meat and Veggie Combo
Antipasto Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Meatballs

“I really liked this place. It helps that I love trains! The Train Car is really cool and the staff are so friendly. The food was really good! I am a New Haven pizza snob but I was very impressed with how good the Margherita pizza was! I am looking forward to coming back and try something else. This place will be a regular stop for lunch!“

4.6 Superb34 Reviews
Christo's Restaurant & Bar Pizza • $$
552 N Colony Rd, Wallingford

Customers` Favorites

Garlicky Shrimp Pizza with Glazed Balsamic
Great New Haven Style Apizza
Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls
Christos Special Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Detriot Style Pizza
Fried Pickle Chips
Daddy Mac Burger
Mozzarella Sticks
Margherita Pizza

“prices on the menu are not the same as what I was charged; when I politely brought this up with my server I was met with hostility and I heard her and who I assumed to be the manager speaking very loudly and poorly about me; the whole situation made me entirely uncomfortable despite being upcharged 8 dollars that I paid my bill and promptly left after being treated poorly about the discrepancy. The food and atmosphere great, but poor service absolutely-- and I work at a restaurant as a server...“

4.3 Superb120 Reviews
Paradise Pizza Pizza • $
624 S Colony St, Wallingford

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza
Boneless Wings
Buffalo Wings
Garlic Knots

“I deliver packages for amazon and I've tried tons of pizza all over CT, and I would have to say if your looking for really great Greek style pizza then this is your spot! Great menu and very friendly people! I would highly recommend giving them a try.“

4.2 Good24 Reviews
Gaetano's Tavern on Main American • $$
40 N Main St, Wallingford

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Chicken Sandwich
Fried Mozzarella
Fish & Chips
French Fries
Taco Salad
Potatoes
Italian
Calamari
Sundae

“Love this little local joint. Especially in the warmer months with the live music and sitting outside. The food has always been consistent and top-notch, from dinner to the brunches. Mixed drinks are always on point with many options. The service has always been a pleasure.“

4.1 Good61 Reviews
Wallingford Beach Donuts Donut Shops • $
200 Church St, Wallingford

Customers` Favorites

Apple Fritter
Sandwiches
Coffee Roll
Bacon Egg
Doughnut

“They have sour cream donuts! My wife loves them. I'm a fan of their frosted donuts and their iced coffee. They use frozen coffee instead of regular water ice cubes. Super delicious and nicely cafinated. The folks who work there are always friendly.“

4.1 Good36 Reviews
Carini's Pizzeria & Restaurant Pizza • $
# E, 5062, 822 E Center St, Wallingford

“This is my go-to neighborhood restaurant. Guy and Rosa are awesome people and the food is fantastic! I recommend the Carini's Vegetarian pizza, well done and the pasta rustica. But all the food is home made and well prepared. And don't forget the bread. It's baked on premises and is awesome!“

4.2 Good13 Reviews
Michael's Trattoria Italian • $$
344 Center St, Wallingford

Customers` Favorites

Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken 24 95 with Shrimp 26 95
Hot Seafood Sampler of Clams Mussels & Shrimp
Fresh Garden Salad
Seafood Spaghetti
Pasta Bolognese
Banana Cream Pie
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Piccata
Zuppa Di Pesce

“As an out-of-towner this was my first time visiting Michael's Trattoria, and it was a wonderful experience. The food was exceptional from beginning to end. Fresh baked bread is served warm with both olive and garlic, and butter. The salads were fresh and included a nice variety of spring greens, tomatoes, and chickpeas- and I would suggest trying their house vinaigrette. The Penne Alla Vodka was fantastic with perfectly cooked pasta, a sauce with the just the right balance of cream and zesty tomato, and a good amount of large, tender shrimp. The atmosphere is cozy with an elegant flair, and a nice mix of background music, including traditional Italian, and the service was friendly, and attentive. Highly recommended.“

4 Good90 Reviews
Nardelli's Grinder Shoppe Deli • $
970 North Colony Road Rt. 5, Wallingford

“Nardelli's was a beacon of light for these hungry travelers. We were rewarded with mouthwatering delicious chicken parm sandwiches. Moist and flavorful chicken breast, luscious sauce that did not overwhelm, tangy melty Provolone cheese on a toothsome roll perfectly sized for the sandwich. I got the kid's size and it was more than enough. My companion got the whole one....it was a lot of food!!!Nardelli's sells lots of prepared Italian salads, cutlets, meats and cheeses. If we are ever this way again, we're going for the cold subs. They look as tempting as our delicious chicken Parm!“

3.8 Good25 Reviews
Napoli Pizza Restaurant Pizza • $
1145 N Colony Rd, Wallingford

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tortellini Soup
Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Bruschetta Napoli
Lobster Ravioli
Sausage Cheese
House Salad
Absolutely

“They have some of the best pizza around. We ordered the Margarita pizza with fresh mozz and fresh basil to die for (well, live for).Update: we had asked for a pizza with peppers, mushrooms and grilled onions. Oftentimes at other places, the "grilled" portion of the order gets ignored. But not here. The chicken tortellini soup was great, too. Napoli's nailed it again. Well done and keep up the great service!Update: we brought my brother in law and his family there. It was hilarious a first time there in almost 30 years. His go to was always the Pizza Pops. He went for one today as a memorial to times past. Was not disappointed, once again! :-)“

3.8 Good60 Reviews
Serafino's Restaurant Italian • $$
72 S Turnpike Rd, Wallingford

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Stuffed Mushrooms
Seasonal Salad
Fried Calamari
Garlic Knots
Lasagna
Italian

“Had lunch here yesterday, as usual it was amazing! First off our waitress Nadia was super sweet, and very helpful. My husband ordered his usual Cavatelli Parmigiana, it was delicious...I had to sneak a bite. I ordered something new for myself, can't remember the name of it...but it was linguine with shrimp, chicken, mushrooms and sausage in a brown sauce. It was amazing! Just the right amount of kick from the jalapeno peppers. This might just be my new favorite! Thank you for another delicious meal!“

3.6 Good91 Reviews
Loading...
map Map