26 Best Italian Restaurants in New Haven

Modern Apizza Pizza • $
874 State St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
Italian Bomb Pizza
Plain Cheese Pizza
Clams Casino Pizza
White Clam Pizza
Veggie Bomb Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Meatball Pizza
Broccoli Pizza

“I'm gonna start with a real bold opener here and say that out of the pizza greats MODERN IS THE BEST, HANDS DOWN. It's not up for debate, it's not an opinion, it's an empirical fact.I have NEVER had a bad experience doing business with them.Dine-in: FIVE STARS.Take-out: FIVE STARS.Their customer service: not even a contest! Always so polite, kind, accommodating, and really care about giving you a positive experience.My favorite nuances withheld in Modern's perfectly cooked dough are:-The subtle sweetness that arrives on the back end of every bite that I believe is in the dough and not the sauce (correct me if I'm wrong).-Their pies produce the absolute perfect bubble.-The dough has a really good bouncy mouthfeel without being overly floppy.-Exceptional sauce, very bright and flavorful.-Good sauce/dough/cheese ratio.-Clutch undercarriage.The best way to measure the worth of any pizza is with a plain cheese pie.I've waited about 3 years, maybe a little more, to post this review. My opinion was formed the moment I tasted the absolute best and it hasn't changed yet. I hope this review helps you to make the right decision when it comes to your pizza patronage.“

4.6 Superb212 Reviews
Zeneli Pizzeria e cucina Napoletana Pizza • $$
138 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza with Arugula
Homemade Italian Meatballs
Rigatoni All Amatriciana
Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina
Insalata Di Arugula
Calzone Napoletano
Salad Pizza Napoli
Margherita Verace
Fresh Mozzarella
Nutella Pizza

“Popped in on our way through town and found the best pizza I've ever had. The service was great, the waitress was very attentive, the pizza came out incredibly fast and priced very well compared to other spots near by. I'll be stopping by any time I'm in the area.“

4.8 Superb191 Reviews
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana Pizza • $
157 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza and White Clam Pizza
The Original Tomato Pie
Clam and Bacon Pizza
Meatball and Ricotta
Fresh Tomato Pie
Spinach Mushroom
Pepperoni Pizza
Quattro Formagi
Veggie Pizza
Caesar Salad

“A local very popular restaurant worthy of Michelin 1+ star performance. white clam pizza is a must try. This restaurant is deep in history and is celebrating its 100th year. Great atmosphere and vibe. Run by generations of family owners. Definitely need to check out their wood fire stone oven. it is the largest I have ever seen from east to west coast. if you come across one bigger please let me know. Even if this oven is second in size I bet you have a hard time finding one bigger.“

4.3 Superb287 Reviews
Gioia Cafe and Bar Italian • $$
150 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Ember Roasted Squash Agnolotti
Complimentary Garlic Knots
Complimentary Garlic Bread
Rigatoni Carbonara
Garlic Rolls
Panna Cotta

“Fabulous food, wonderful atmosphere and great staff. Noise was a bit loud, but being in a booth made all the difference. Our waiter was great, but very busy and he had a lot of tables so it took awhile to order. He was great after that - very attentive and many other helpers. Our 3rd time there and definitely my favorite spot in New Haven!!!“

4.6 Superb190 Reviews
Consiglio's Restaurant Italian • $$
165 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Ravioli with Meat Balls
Ravioli and Meatballs
Pappardelle Bolognese
Tortellini Carbonara
Fettuccine Carbonara
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Sautéed Calamari
Eggplant Parmesan
Fried Mozzarella

“Consiglio's is a top notch Italian restaurant in New Haven. Food is phenomenal, service is fantastic and an overall outstanding experience. I never eat the same entree when we go there! So many choices and such amazing specials. Highly recommend.“

4.5 Superb202 Reviews
Pasta Eataliana Trattoria Napoletana Italian • $$
127 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Pasta with Tomato Sauce and Burrito Cheese
Pappardelle with Porcini and Sausage
Frittura Mista Gamberi E Calamari
Polipo Arrostito Con Friarielli
Gnocchetti Alla Sorrentina
Spaghetti Alla Carbonara
Rigatoni Al Gorgonzola
Tagliatelle Bolognese
Mortadella Flatbread
Pappardelle Porcini

“Nice, small cozy dining room. Servers were friendly and conversational. Food was great. few starters and main courses. Meatballs are fantastic. Took quite awhile for food to arrive and check took along time aswell. Specially for not being busy that night. Would still go back and recommend. For friends family or date “

4.6 Superb117 Reviews

7
Skappo

Skappo Italian • $$
59 Crown St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Quattro Formaggi
Broccoli Gnocchi
Braised Rabbit
Bolognese
Carbonara
Lasagna
Apps

“We visited Skappo for my birthday yesterday and our initial walk in the door we were greeted by this lovely woman who cleared a table immediately so we were not waiting long. Then mom (we know from the great introduction) came over to say hello and commented on my necklace. The food was so good and it was like we were at Nonna's house!! We started with the antipasto and the stuffed figs.So glad we chose both because those stuffed figs alone were worth the trip back. For our entrees I got the bolognese and my husband got the ziti with a creamy sausage sauce, both were delicious!!! It is worth the trip and we know we will be making return visits!! Thank you for your warm welcome and delicious food!!Beth and DaveVegetarian options: Last night the lasagna was vegetarian“

4.7 Superb71 Reviews
Portofino's Restaurant & Bar Italian • $$$
937 State St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Burrata and Prosciutto
Pork Osso Bucco
Sauce

“Went with friend on Sunday evening. He is regular and recommended it. Perfect meal with appetizer, wine ,main course and dessert.Had mussels. lasagne. and lemon iceAlso some white wineMussels were in tasty garlic sauce. Wish I had more room for bread to sop it up. He took some of sauce home.Lasagne excellent. Homemade noodles.Brenda the waitress was excellent attentive to our needs.A bit pricey and street parking are only neogative comments“

4.4 Superb161 Reviews
One6Three Pizza • $
163 Foster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
American Margherita
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Meatball Pizza
Mashed Potato
Spicy Salami
Pizza Joint
Cheese Pizza
Fried Oreos

“Great pizza and sides. Should be in the New Haven Pizza conversation more often.Brick oven, Fresh ingredients, nice crunch and undercarriage/ crust. About 5 two person tables So not much for sitting in. More of a take out spot. Well worth it to go pick it up. Out of the down town city area. In Quiet East “

4.6 Superb81 Reviews
Sally's Apizza Pizza • $$
237 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
New Haven Original Clam Pie
White Fresh Tomato Pie
Slice of Cannoli Pie
Plain Mozzarella Pie
Fresh Tomatoes Pie
Large Caesar Salad
Garden Special Pie
White Potato Pie
Meat and Cheese

“This place was everything I expected it to be. We were seated immediately, and our server was excellent. She asked us if we had any questions and even made a suggestion for us to add bacon to our potato and rosemary pizza. Both pizzas were delicious and unlike any other I have had before. We also tried a couple of the local Foxon sodas which were great as well. I hope to be able to go again the next time I'm in the area.“

4.1 Good231 Reviews
Villa Lulu Italian •
230 College St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Squid Ink Fettuccine Shrimp Scallops
Spicy Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Bucatini All Amatriciana
Lobster Ravioli
Broccoli Rabe

“Food was amazing, service was great, our sever angel was friendly and very attentive to us during our Valentines dinner. The octopus was some of the best I’ve ever had along with the lobster ravioli! Look forward to coming by again for dinner soon!“

4.2 Good212 Reviews
Caffe Bravo Italian • $$$
794 Orange St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Pasta with Mushroom Sauce
Fried Artichoke Hearts
Insalata Di Polpette
Iceberg Wedge Salad
Homemade Bolognese
Chicken Francaise
Fried Calamari
Chicken Bravo
Bolognaise
Bruschetta

“A true Gem of a restaurant that is located just outside the city. As you enter you are greeted by smiling faces and a warm and friendly environment! Truly southern Italian, the menu transports you to southern Italy and prepares you for a wonderful culinary experience! The specials are clearly the Chefs favorite weekly creations and come served with a whole lot of Amore' ! The food quality is amazing and the serving size is perfect! I started with the grilled Octopus, which was perfectly prepared and as tender as it gets, I highly recommend this! I had the Duck and tasted the Rare Tuna special, both excellent! We finished with an espresso and gelato, a perfect Italian ending. Prices are more than fair for the quality and service and the atmosphere transports you to a southern Italy Trattoria! This Gem is truly worth the trip, we cant wait to return!“

4.3 Superb97 Reviews
The Spot Pizza • $$
157 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Tomato Pie with Mozzarella

“Wait time in a line outside was 30 min-40 min to get a table on Saturday night. Service was fantastic and food was fantastic. I didn't care for the anchovies but that's my preference. I was convinced to get the tomato pie without the mozzarella and it ended up being my favorite.“

4.4 Superb67 Reviews
Family Mediterranean Pizza Halal • $
45 York St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Shawarma over Rice
Side of Lamb Shawarma
Lamb Shawarma Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Shawarma Plate
Baklava
Hummus
Salad

“If you are working near New Haven hospital till late hours and require something to eat, i will highly recommend this place. It is really accessible to get to this place (it is linked from new haven hospital to the parking garage. furthermore its sheltered) and the food served here is pretty decent. I used to love ordering the pizza and kebab from this place while i was living in New Haven. The price is also really reasonable“

4.5 Superb38 Reviews

15
L'Orcio

L'Orcio Italian • $$
806 State St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Bucatini All Amatriciana
Gnocchi Boscaiola
Caprese Salad
Creme Brulee
Ceasar Salad
Tiramisu'
Burrata
L'Orcio

“I love this restaurant and think it is one of the best in New Haven. Tonight we enjoyed the fresh pasta with mushrooms and Branzino, crème brûlée and tiramisu. Everything was perfectly delicious. The only imperfection was the rather long wait we had for our waitress to take our orders. She was perfectly nice and did a good job. The upstairs is quiet and easy to hear your companions talk. It would be nice to have more art on the walls upstairs.“

4.1 Good154 Reviews
Tre Scalini Restaurant Italian • $$$
100 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana
Spaghetti Carbonara
Palle Di Risotti
Gnocchi Saporiti
Clams Casino
Veal Marsala
Osso Bucco
Ravioli

“We used the smaller room for a family event and had the best experience. Catering was amazing to work with and planning was very smooth. The restaurant is gorgeous and the food was exceptional. The wait staff were such pros and I could relax and enjoy the party. I can’t recommend Tres Scalini enough for a party.Dietary restrictions: They made special meals for each person which were all delicious. Everyone was so happy.“

4.1 Good119 Reviews
Adriana's Italian • $$$
771 Grand Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Insalata Di Pesce Cold Seafood Salad
Meatballs in a Spicy Marinara Sauce
Spaghetti Ai Frutti Di Mare
Linguine Alle Vongole
Parpadelle Alastico
Wheel of Cheese
Calamari Fritti
Fried Calamari
Seafood Pasta
Veal Adriana

“Food, service, ambiance, and cost were excellent. 6 dinner, 2 apps, 12 cocktails. I had the veal chop special and was delicious and a huge portion. The leftovers were even great a few days later, rewarmed, in the oven, not the microwave. Old school Italian feel with original dishes. Definitely recommend.“

4.2 Good64 Reviews
Carmines di Vega Italian • $$
1500 Whalley Ave, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Escarole Bean Soup
Chicken Francese
Calamari Fritti
House Salad
Warm Bread
Pasta Side
Side Salad

“Came here on a quiet weeknight and was amazed by the authentic Italian cuisine. Started off with a wonderful Burrata then I had the Rigatoni Bolgenese with was really good. We also bought a loaf of the Italian Bread to bring home. That bread with some Cabot butter and you are on to something!! Would visit again.“

4.3 Superb43 Reviews
Nikki & Frankie's Italian • $$
320 Foxon Blvd, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheese Fries
Clam Strips Basket
Big Breakfast
Pancakes
Sandwich
Burger
Jalape

“We had dinner tonight at Nikki and Frankie's on Route 80 on the recommendation of a friend.. the eggplant was fantastic and made the right way the good old-fashioned Italian way.. the meatballs were legit the sauce was delish and couldn't be any fresher... we were welcomed like we were walking into aunties dining room and the place was clean as a whistle.. A must go to !“

4.3 Superb43 Reviews
Brazi's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
201 Food Terminal Plaza, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp
Shrimp Scampi Mediterranea
New York Strip Alla Brazi
Brazi-Style Fried Calamari
Shrimp & Clams Pescatore
Tuscan Chicken Salad
Chicken Parmigiana
Italian Antipasto
Penne Alla Vodka
Soup of the Day

“Visited here for lunch one afternoon before the holidays. Great service and great food! Plenty of parking and close to I-95. The staff were extremely accommodating and friendly. Nice variety of menu options. Great Chicken Parmigiana and Meatballs.“

4.1 Good101 Reviews
Da Legna at Nolo Pizza • $$
687 State St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Vegan Pizza
Nolo Cheese Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage Pepper
Mashed Potato
Goat Cheese
Arugula
Pie

“Sweet vibe and even sweeter staff. The food is fantastic, and they even got live music. What else could you want?Vegetarian options: Plenty of vegetarian pizzas since most pizzas are. But what's cool is they got a buncha vegan pizzas, too.“

3.9 Good77 Reviews
Scarpellino's Restaurant and Catering Italian • $$
257 Forbes Ave #1, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Tony Soprano Sub
Sandwich
Cookies
Chicken
Chef

“Stopped in on our stop in Ct. we live in Florida now( ( almost 30 years) but were born and raised in NewHaven, East Haven Branford. Our lunch was so delicious, I had eggplant on a hard roll, so delicious I could still taste it, not everyone makes eggplant correctly. My husband had a meatball sub, he so enjoyed it( and not easily pleased)the bread was so fresh as were the meatballs. It will definitely be put on our list of stops when we come back. Oh so good!“

4.2 Good43 Reviews
Encore by Goodfellas Italian • $$$
702 State St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato
Mississippi Mudd Pie
Chicken Parmigiana
Goodfellas Cupcake
Fried Mozzarella
Shrimp Cocktail
Lobster Ravioli
Veal Saltimbocca
Meatball Salad
Grilled Salmon

“Before I went to this restaurant, I read the reviews. There were some negative reviews. I guess any restaurant can have a bad night.I have to say I had great service and the food was excellent. I would definitely go back and I’d definitely recommend it to friends and family. I had a great dinning experience..“

4 Good177 Reviews
IL GABBIANO Italian • $$
501 Long Wharf Dr, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Lobster on Linguine with Red Sauce
Fried Calamari Marinara Sauce
Buccatini Casio E Peper
Calamari Fra Diavolo
Mediterranean Salad
Pork Chop Pizzaiolla
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Al Ragu
Eggplant Rollatini
Meatballs

“We had a wonderful dining experience at this restaurant. Food was excellent table was great facing the water. But the best part of our dining experience was our server. Her name Is LeeAnn and she was wonderful! So friendly, professional, caring and a beautiful smile. I would say that she was the BEST server that I have ever encountered and I have been to many different restaurants all over the world. We had a long day and a tough one and this wonderful person turned out day into a positive one. Thank you for your fab food and wonderful staff especially LeeAnn. See you again real soon!!“

3.9 Good195 Reviews
Via Gastrobar Italian • $$
260 Crown St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

French Fries with Italian Gravy and Ricotta
Lamb Chops Pulpo a La Gallega Cheese Curds
Filet Mignon Bites
Short Rib Sliders
Lobster Guacamole
Brussels Sprouts
Fried Ravioli
Chicken Parm
Empanadas
Meatball

“AMBIANCE!!! This is the perfect spot for a ladies night, happy hour or a date night. Small plate choices and Happy Hour menu is drool worthy! Plus!! $4 drinks! The staff is attentive and not over-bearing (they've obviously been trained to perfect this). I love that we weren't rushed! I'll be back!!“

3.8 Good80 Reviews
Dayton Street Apizza Pizza • $
60 Dayton St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pesto Special Apizza
Chicken Cutlet
Caesar Salad
Margherita
Meatball
Sausage

“The combo apizza here was delicious! It was huge and was plenty for three of us. Generously covered with my favorite toppings including pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, bell peppers, and onions. The crust is baked crisp and I liked that it wasn't overly charred like some other places. A great addition to the New Haven apizza scene.“

3.5 Good22 Reviews
Loading...
map Map