What are you looking for?

Italian Restaurants in Rochester

4.9 - 674 votes

Hours: Closed today

1313 East Ridge Road, Rochester
(585) 266-2676

The Pasta Villa

The pasta here is freaking amazing and the rest of their menu is out of this world good. I strongly tagging the family along when you try this place out.... More reviews

4.8 - 458 votes

Hours: 10AM - 3PM

2280 Lyell Ave, Rochester
(585) 247-0510

Casa Saratoga

Been buying Italian bread at this bakery before the name change almost everyday for 20 years and the past few times the bottom of the bread is all oily a... More reviews

4.7 - 345 votes

Hours: Closed today

5 Rochester Public Market, Rochester
(585) 434-5705


Great place, came here for our anniversary. Delicious food, very friendly staff, wonderful experience overall More reviews

4.6 - 232 votes

Hours: 11AM - 8:30PM

2133 E Henrietta Rd, Rochester
(585) 358-0488

Mamma G's

Great food, great price. I ordered lasagna which is made with crepes vs noodles. It was much lighter and very good More reviews

4.7 - 155 votes

Hours: Closed today

274 Goodman St N #108, Rochester
(585) 363-5100


Love this place! I always start with a raspberry beret drink. Delicious! Great menu, delicious food and friendly service. One of my favorite restaurants. More reviews

4.7 - 149 votes

Hours: Closed today

1386 Buffalo Rd, Rochester
(585) 235-7860

Calabresella's New York Style Deli

Best italian assorted sub on the west side! Staff are friendly and service is quick. Also love all the local foods they carry in their shop. More reviews

4.1 - 278 votes

Hours: 12 - 9:30PM

125 White Spruce Blvd, Rochester
(585) 424-4242

Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse

Great service and tasty steak. Loved the art deco and atmosphere. Some folks were a bit razzle and noisy, but overall a great dinner and service More reviews

4.5 - 173 votes

Hours: 12 - 10PM

385 Winton Rd N, Rochester
(585) 482-8430

Captain Tony's Pizza & Pasta Emporium

Flavor of crust and sauce was good. Medium pizza was woefully small. There were like 5 flecks of ham on my hawaiian pizza, not even every slice had ham. ... More reviews

4.7 - 126 votes

Hours: Closed today

190 Jay St, Rochester
(585) 232-9717


The food is amazing here and they have an awesome menu. The service is pretty great and service staff are pretty amazing. More reviews



4.8 - 107 votes

Hours: Closed today

181 Monroe Ave, Rochester
(585) 454-3510


A phenomenal meal and great atmosphere. The shrimp salad and lobster and crab risotto were standouts, and the corn cake for dessert was unbelievably deli... More reviews

4.4 - 182 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

175 N Water St, Rochester
(585) 232-6090

Pane Vino On The River

I have to say our waitress was attentive and kind and the appetizers were ok. However, from the second I stepped into the restaurant, I was disappointed.... More reviews

4.4 - 173 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

318 East Ave, Rochester
(585) 454-5444

Veneto Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta

We sat outside on a Saturday night. There were several lovely salads to choose from for me (I ended up choosing the delicious roasted cauliflower), and t... More reviews

4.1 - 238 votes

Hours: 10AM - 2PM

425 Merchants Rd, Rochester
(585) 448-0061

Lucca Kitchen & Cocktails

Ok this is not going to be good. What kind of Italian restaurant doesn't serve BREAD?!! That was first. Ceasars pizza serves bread!! Give me spaghetti, t... More reviews

4.3 - 189 votes

Hours: 10:30AM - 10PM

260 Park Ave, Rochester
(585) 360-4165


Warm and welcoming. Bartender told us this was a neighborhood place, which most diners walk to. Wish we lived in this neighborhood! Really enjoyed the st... More reviews

4.6 - 128 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

370 East Ave, Rochester
(585) 270-5601

Park Avenue Paninoteca

Just moved to the area and with all the restaurants being takeout and delivery only this one was on my bucket list to try and I'm SO glad I did! The... More reviews

4.3 - 183 votes

Hours: Closed today

2500 Ridgeway Ave, Rochester
(585) 340-6100

Bella Pasta Restaurant

My husband and I went there again because we saw the reviews were getting better so we decided to give them another chance. Big mistake! I don't kno... More reviews



4.3 - 175 votes

Hours: Closed today

165 Monroe Ave, Rochester
(585) 454-3510


I've been to Rocco a few times and to be honest, I don't get what the big deal is. The few times I've tried their food, it's been OK ... More reviews



4.5 - 135 votes

Hours: Closed today

1815 East Ave, Rochester
(585) 244-3460


So happy to return to our favorite restaurant in Rochester. Wonderfully prepared fish and veal dinners and attentive service. More reviews

3.8 - 288 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

4 Elton St, Rochester
(585) 471-8917

Fiamma Pizza e Vino

I keep going back, that speaks for itself. Never been disappointed, recently had my wife’s birthday party there. More reviews

4 - 238 votes

Hours: Closed today

30 Celebration Dr, Rochester
(585) 445-5770

Grappa Italian Nouveau

Highly recommend this restaurant if you are visiting Rochester. Great pizza and pasta. Everything was fresh and delicious. Awesome environment. Super kin... More reviews

4.2 - 185 votes

Hours: 3 - 8PM

920 Elmridge Center Dr, Rochester
(585) 723-9988

Brook House

Table service was ok but was easily the worst Italian meal I've ever had. Too many things wrong to list but there was nothing authentic going on in ... More reviews

4.3 - 160 votes

Hours: 11AM - 8PM

50 Spencerport Rd, Rochester
(585) 429-6540


My husband and I ordered takeout and purchased bread to go with the meal. After eating our meal, we found two flying ants baked into our loaf of bread. A... More reviews

4.2 - 178 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

4699 Lake Ave, Rochester
(585) 730-5444

Mr. Dominic's at the Lake

There on a hot weeknight. Place crowded. Service good but you could see the servers were very busy. Food very good and plentiful. Was never asked for ano... More reviews

4.4 - 140 votes

Hours: Closed today

280 E Broad St #100, Rochester
(585) 434-5243

Branca Midtown

Calamari was perfectly cooked. Lightly fried with a great dipping sauce. Tagliatelle was perfectly seasoned and tasted great. Pizza was charred with a gr... More reviews

4.1 - 193 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

288 Exchange Blvd, Rochester
(585) 413-3640

Tony D's

I made reservations for a large party a month ago the manager "is too busy". I called the week before our event & I had to leave a message.... More reviews

View on map